La Salle CollegianOctober 15, 2009
I've been duped! Tricked! Bamboozled!The cover of In Endeavors' new EP, You've Got Your Friends, I've Got Mine, claims that I would like its music if I liked Sunset Rubdown. So when I picked up In Endeavors from my editor's pile of free CDs, a Rubdown-esque band sounded like it would fit my fancy. This is not Sunset Rubdown—not even close.What it is like, almost painfully so, are bands such as the Strokes, Arctic Monkeys, and Franz Ferdinand. Thankfully for my ears, I actually like those bands too (albeit much less than Sunset Rubdown).Remember that brief period in rock history in the early 2000s when critics claimed that the "garage band" was making a comeback? These guys should've been part of that comeback. Their straight-forward post-punk sound would tessellate quite nicely with, say, the Strokes' Is This It, or any other of that era's albums.Yes, In Endeavors pretty much play by the garage rock rulebook the Strokes utilized at the beginning of the decade. Quick drumbeats, straight guitar chords, and laid-back vocals make up the entirety of You've Got Your Friends, I've Got Mine.The first track, "The Move," is a fast-tempo, pulsating song about... well, something about friends, I think? The vocal track is a little less than clear, as it is for pretty much the whole EP. But that's the garage rock charm, isn't it? The indecipherable lyrics don't really bring down the music because it's upbeat and fun, as garage rock can be.And so it goes for the other four songs: the guitars chime in first, set up the riffs, followed by a tight drum and bass combo, and then finally the lazy vocals come to the forefront. With only five songs, they just barely avoid being repetitive. If this were a full-length album, I might say differently, but the sole sound they create in every song on the EP is fun enough to last.A stand-out is the final song, "I Can't Run," which manages to evoke some kind of emotion other than "Hey, look, we're playing music in a band!" The song is about woman troubles—"You're running in circles / I'm trying to catch up to you / But you're running too fast for me, girl"—and somehow the band is able to get an emotional reaction from the listener despite its catchiness, upbeat tempo and off-kilter drumming. Impressive.In Endeavors is nothing new. It treads exactly where the Strokes did a few years ago. I mean, it's almost frightening how similar they sound. Nevertheless, it's solid music. In Endeavors is nothing new, it's fun and likely worth your time. Well, if you like the Strokes, that is.
I listened to this EP a couple more times today, over thirteen years later after I callously dismissed it in print, and I have some new opinions. But first, here are some various self-criticisms about the written review itself.
I know now that "X sounds like Y" is the laziest criticism one can possibly give. Not that I haven't indulged in it from time to time, but it's almost never worth it, because the assumption that everyone is going to be familiar with the comparison artist is probably false, and so if someone is reading this review and isn't familiar with the Strokes, then they've going to come away from the review knowing literally nothing about In Endeavors. Plus, it's a risky, um, endeavor, because you have to hit the fucking bullseye, or else you're going to look like an asshole. I see some Strokes in In Endeavors, but more from a production value perspective (lo-fi, kinda muffled, too cool to care) than anything else. Franz Ferdinand was the better pick here, but more on this in a second.
I know now that "X sounds like Y" is the laziest criticism one can possibly give. Not that I haven't indulged in it from time to time, but it's almost never worth it, because the assumption that everyone is going to be familiar with the comparison artist is probably false, and so if someone is reading this review and isn't familiar with the Strokes, then they've going to come away from the review knowing literally nothing about In Endeavors. Plus, it's a risky, um, endeavor, because you have to hit the fucking bullseye, or else you're going to look like an asshole. I see some Strokes in In Endeavors, but more from a production value perspective (lo-fi, kinda muffled, too cool to care) than anything else. Franz Ferdinand was the better pick here, but more on this in a second.
I hate talking about genre, too, because it's so easy to get it wrong. "Garage rock" is fine, but then why did I feel the need to throw in the genre signifier "post-punk"? This is not post-punk. It's closer to post-punk than other genres, but it's not post-punk. But see? Even when I get it completely wrong, it's tough to care all that much. The only people who give a shit what post-punk is are going to be the same people who already know that I'm wrong, and can easily dismiss the mis-genre-ing.
And it reads as pathetic that I got all this wrong and yet still worked up some agitation in the opening paragraphs for some PR shmuck who got it similarly wrong with a sticker on the album cover. It's tough for me to even remember a time when "sounds like Sunset Rubdown" could be a selling point for anyone, but apparently someone thought In Endeavors sounded like that Spencer Krug outfit. I still think it's preposterous, but on the other hand, who the fuck am I to judge? Again, that's lazy writing, filling up a so-called review with a review-opening aside about a sticker on the cover, a sticker that the band itself had nothing to do with.
Also lazy: the vocals are actually pretty easy to understand. What the fuck was I talking about? I feel like this was the ultimate lazy move—"I don't feel like diving into the themes of this album so I'm just gonna claim I can't understand the words." I'm not claiming here in 2023 that I am getting a clear sense of what those themes actually are, or even if there are any (if I had to guess: about having a twisted sense of independence by refusing to be personable when meeting other people). But there's a difference between boilerplate lyrics and indecipherable lyrics. I took the easy road.
I know I'm describing myself as "lazy" a lot, but it's interesting how often I referred to the music as "lazy" as well, back in 2009. "Laid-back" too. Objectively speaking, I don't hear much that one could consider laid-back anywhere on this album. It in fact has some of that nervous energy that made bands of this era kind of exciting, ya know? I'm not claiming that In Endeavors did anything new or exciting with it, but it's a competent example of the sound that was prominent way back when. Plus, the Strokes weren't "laid-back" either. Any act of being laid-back was a front in an effort to sound cool in an uncaring way. That did indeed make the Strokes sound cool, but let's not pretend that it wasn't an act.
I'm glad I didn't exhume this old album review from the vault before last September, because the We Are Scientists reviews from that month gave me the opportunity to ponder the retroactive phenomenon known as "landfill rock." Surely, if we're talking about music that ended up in a landfill, then In Endeavors are a clear candidate. Do you know how hard it was to track this EP down online? Well, not impossible, because this is the internet, but definitely a lot harder than it usually is! The band name didn't help me in terms of google searches. I finally tracked down the EP on YouTube under the wrong name (just "Endeavors," and it was erroneously paired with a completely different band called "the Endeavors"). I'll embed it at the bottom to prove that I found it and so you can listen for yourself.
But the point here being that In Endeavors may be better than I remembered or wrote about, but it's definitely not beyond any other generic indie rock band that was bashing these tunes out around that time. It's sincerely no wonder they never got a true debut LP off the ground—hundreds of bands beat them to it.
There are songs to salvage here, I believe. "Day One" has some oomph in it, especially in the yelling of the EP's title toward the end there. "Private Eye" has a jitteriness that sincerely reminds me of a less-charismatic Franz Ferdinand. And 2009 Joe was right to single out "I Can't Run" as the standout track, though probably for the wrong reasons. The drumming is indeed stellar, especially in the only well-written chorus on the EP. But it was misguided (and weirdly sexist) to dismiss the lyrics as "woman troubles." With thirteen years' worth of added perspective, I find additional poignancy in the "You're running in circles, oh yeah / I'm trying to catch up to you." Think about how In Endeavors failed to distinguish themselves in a crowded late-'00s rock overkill. This about how they completely disappeared because of that failure. Think about yourself too, the dreams you had back in 2009, and how thinking back, it all seems so stupid, so pointless, kinda like running in circles.
Maybe that's giving In Endeavors too much credit. If the only reason I'll remember this band or give them any credit whatsoever is that I randomly pulled a CD out of a box in the Collegian dungeon and deigned to write a shitty review about it and that this is one of the Collegian issues that survived in the archives (a.k.a. the pile of newspapers underneath a dorm room couch), then so be it. That's good enough reason for me. I'd rather listen to In Endeavors than Franz Ferdinand at this point.
See? I can't stop the comparisons. I am a terrible music critic. Always have been, always will be.

No comments:
Post a Comment