These Are Good People is an album that makes a case for starting fresh, which seems like good timing, here in the first week of January. I want to be better. We all do. And the beginning of a new year seems like the perfect opportunity to make promises to ourselves, that can make the changes necessary to complete the transformation into our perfect selves.
Nothing will ever be perfect, though. You won't be perfect. A little curio from the early '10s Philly indie/emo scene won't be perfect. Michelle Zauner isn't perfect. On that last point, she underlines over and over throughout the album. From my vantage point, she's being a little hard on herself, but damn does the self-criticism create some blistering music.
Well, it's that, and the tight attack of a locked-in four-piece band, guitars intertwined, Zauner swaying like a boxer to find the spaces in between for her singular, ethereal voice. I don't even know if she's a "good" singer, but she's the right singer for this context. The music is strong but probably wouldn't be as strong if she wasn't dropping self-burns like "I was all shapes and holes." Likewise, I don't know if Michelle Zauner works as well without the tense but sturdy emo sound behind her (full disclosure: I struggled with J-Brekkie until Jubilee, but maybe finally getting around to Crying in H Mart is going to unlock some stuff in her back catalog for me).
I read an interview with the drummer, Ian Dykstra (also drummer for Titus Andronicus), from around the time that These Are Good People was about to be released. There was some good insight, but in terms of what the lyrics meant, the dude was basically like "I have no idea, you have to ask Michelle." That comment either caused or confirmed a feeling that this is almost two separate artists working together, two different bands, one focused on music, one focused on lyrics. At times, it seems like two separate enterprises squished together. I could see the seams threatening to burst occasionally. I at the same time admired how it could manage to still all hang together.
New year, new me: I'm trying real hard to "get" albums on a deeper level then I would have in years past. It's difficult, because I am a stupid moron who doesn't understand most poetry that I come across. These lyrics are poetry, and I did my best to really get inside of them. Here is what I found.
The song I keep coming back to is "Dark Matter." It's never outright stated, but it seems to be about a young friend or loved one who passed away after a short battle with a disease of some sort. It wasn't sudden, because she has time to "contemplate the infinite," but it was quick enough that the "something dark" had "rushed" its way into this person. I'm thinking that the contemplation of the infinite is a projection, that it is those left behind who are doing the contemplating on that subject, that...
That maybe there is a tendency within us to focus on stupid, pointless shit. Something like what somebody said one time that hurt us ("For the love of god, someone get this girl to shut up"), getting too drunk and getting too personal ("Never have you ever looked your father straight in the eye"), how some people come in and out of your life ("water flows fresh to brackish then to salt into seas"). I don't think it's wrong that Zauner is singing so much about a clearly failing relationship, but note how outdated these emotions probably feel to her only a decade later. Time adds perspective, and that perspective changes everything, but it's so hard to remember that when you're in the moment, feeling all the stupid emotions that you'll one day regret.
I look back at some of the things I wrote five, ten, fifteen years ago, and I feel extremely uncomfortable. I seem like a completely different person. I look toward the future too; I try to envision myself, a better person, a better family man, a better writer, possibly 40 pounds lighter, possibly less shackled by social drinking, all that shit that goes through my mind at this time of year. The past, the future. Not much on the present, which is the most important thing, the thing we all forget about all too easily.
So when I say that I hear These Are Good People and I say that it sounds like the need to "start fresh," I don't mean that as a criticism. It is painful to listen to sometimes, emotionally speaking, but there's value in that discomfort. This is how it was. This is how I want it to be. And we're all just looking to start over, from right now, and live right here, in this moment. Thanks for the reminder.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment