Sunday, January 8, 2023

Exit Survey: Joe on These Are Good People

See the rest of the exit surveys HERE.


1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?

I'm always happy if at least one other person besides me writes a review. For the 205th week in a row, someone else wrote a review. Good stuff. Not only that, but there were eight reviews total, which is definitely above average.

Why so many reviews for this album? I don't know. It's random sometimes, with the right people deciding to write all at the same time. I'd like to think that maybe the slick new look of the Sunday write-up or the simpler-to-organize emails have something to do with it, but I'm not going to fool myself. It's also possible that members of the book club that are reading Michelle Zauner's book currently felt more pressure to write than usual. Or maybe it's just the dawning of a new year for Record Club, and eight reviews is going to be the new minimum!! We'll see!!!

2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?

Surprisingly same-y. No one loved it, no one hated it. There was some variance in the middle there from "eh, not bad" to "pretty good!" but no extremes. Sometimes, eight people together can just simply not be wrong. This was good, and that's it. 

I wonder if the fact that Zauner is Philly-semi-famous had anything to do with it. Like, if someone truly disliked this album but also knew that Zauner's music is popular, then it might become "well then it must be ME who is wrong" and be more forgiving/optimistic because of that. But then also she's not popular enough for anyone to dismiss her outright like they might a Swiftian-type pop star. So you're left with the middle ground no matter what your gut is telling you.

3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?

This is my favorite question to answer, especially when everyone basically agrees with one another. Here is one thing that I disagree with from each review, in chronological order: from Rachel's, the term "main character"; from Gary's, that his nephew's band was awesome; from Keelan's, that I would listen to anything besides hardcore screamo music while cleaning the house; from Pam's, that it's called "Men's Book Club" (it's called Boys Book Club, and this is important because I don't want anyone thinking that this is an MRA-type thing); from Sunny's, that the phrase "Little Big League" is catchy for any reason other than the fact that it shares the name of a 1994 family sports comedy; from Sean's, that his shoebox is filled with anything other than dirty stiff rags that he's hiding from his wife; from Sam's, that J-Brekkie is shoegaze; from my own, that I'll lose 40 pounds this year.

Other than all that... there were a few things that I agreed with ultimately but would have never thought about it in that specific way. E.g. Gary's thing about lost friendships, or Sunny's comparison to Hop Along. Fuck what I disagree with. But the stuff that I didn't even realize I agreed with until it was written? That's the reason I love reading your reviews.

4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?

Here's something I was thinking about while rereading all the reviews—there wasn't a single person out of the eight who came to this week having ever listened to Little Big League before. I feel like that's pretty rare, no? There's usually someone like "I used to listen to this when I was younger and it's better/worse because of that!" or whatever. I feel like that's an overdone perspective, but an important one nevertheless, and it was missing this week. Someone check on Nate.

5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?

I think it was a good way to start off the year. Nothing too heavy, but also nothing that you couldn't take seriously if you wanted to. I just regret that I cannot invite my wife to Boys Book Club.

6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?

Nah, you guys were great. Keep the reviews coming. It's more fun when I hear from you!

7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?

Well, I didn't get any negative feedback regarding any of the little changes around Record Club for 2023. A few album suggestions have been received and placed in the queue. We'll see how it goes!

No comments: