Tuesday, April 25, 2023

Never Seen It, #102 of 200: M*A*S*H

We're back to Never Seen It, after a long Oscars nap, plus a bit of distracting homework that has mostly gone away forever now. For those just joining us: there is a list of 200 movies I'd never seen before, and I'm slowly (we're talking years at this point) working my way through it. More than halfway now, so let's keep it moving. Once a week hopefully. Leggy fingers crossed.


M*A*S*H
1970
Robert Altman

You should know that I've never watched M*A*S*H the TV show either, so I can't speak to that. Well, okay, that's a partial lie; longtime readers will note that I watched the pilot episode back in the summer of 2017, and wrote briefly about it. But that was six years ago and it feels longer than that, so I wouldn't take what I wrote as scripture or anything. Note that I said at the time that I was going to start watching the show in earnest. Clearly that never happened. "In my free time," haha, yes, what a concept. Remember free time?

I think that's how this film ended up on my list. I'm familiar with the existence of the long-running and extremely popular TV show because I live in America and I have a pulse, and so, like, what's the deal with the movie? It was a popular movie at the time too, so popular that it must have been a surprise to see the TV show, throughout the 1970s, eclipse the film so thoroughly in terms of cultural significance.

From what I've read, the general conceit is the same—this is a medical unit during the Korean War, and the characters goof around in between conducting life-saving surgery to American soldiers (or perform surgery in between goofing around, whatever). The actors are different (save for Radar, played by Gary Burghoff in the movie and for seven of the eleven seasons), but the character names and roles are the same (at least at the start of the series... I don't doubt a lot changed over the course of eleven years).

I can't imagine there is anyone who "prefers" the film to the TV show. Seems a bit like apples v. oranges to me. Two hours of film and around 120 hours of television—they serve different purposes in one's life. An event versus a lifestyle, etc. A movie might be a great way to spend an evening, but a long-running TV show means something to people.

Not that a movie can't do that too, I guess... Really, I guess I'm inching my way toward saying that I really don't think that M*A*S*H (the film) has aged all that well at all. That's an unfortunately thing to say for a plethora of reasons, not the least of which is that I want to love every movie I watch, and I just couldn't do it with this one.

The big problem is that it wears its misogyny on its sleeve. There's just no other way to put it. It's just right fucking there, unavoidable to all except the true cretins. It's there from the moment we see Hawkeye roll into camp and accost a female nurse at the lunch table, and it continues through an absolutely vicious "prank" campaign against Major Houlihan. Broadcasting her having sex toes the line of decency, but the whole thing with her getting exposed in the shower is nothing less than sexual assault. Yikes.

You hate to throw the baby out with the bathwater, but sometimes that's just how it goes. I could say something like "Well, the parts that didn't involve sexual assault were actually quite hilarious," and I wouldn't be lying. Donald Sutherland as Hawkeye and Elliot Gould as Trapper are the masters of deadpan, almost to a fault. I also liked how it randomly morphed into a football movie for the last like 20 minutes of the fucking film. But it's also really tough to say that I can enjoy Hawkeye and Trapper goofing off when 50% of that goofing off involves using their power as camp leaders to commit sex crimes.

I feel differently about this film than I did Blazing Saddles (for example). The source of the humor feels slightly different. With Blazing Saddles, it was funny at the time because it was purposefully attempting to be "edgy," like, wink wink nudge nudge, isn't this so ballsy that we're making these racist jokes and getting away with it? With M*A*S*H, I dunno, it felt like they didn't rely on being edgy. These are just jokes that were once funny, and no longer are. Both aged poorly, but M*A*S*H's jokes that aged poorly were mean-spirited, whereas Blazing Saddles' mean spirit was baked into the entire preceding. Feel free to say that I don't know what I'm talking about, because maybe I don't, but I'll say that I laughed at the jokes in M*A*S*H that still hold up, but I didn't laugh once during Blazing Saddles.

Still, no excuses, no excuses. Interestingly, our boy Roger Ebert made a compelling excuse in his review from 1970. Basically, he acknowledged that some of the behavior from the men in the camp was mean-spirited (he uses the words "cruel" and "heartless"), but that this was supposed to signify the way that the surgeons during war are expressing their frustrations regarding the war itself. So he's saying that Hawkeye's behavior is excusable because he hates the politicians who put him there and so he takes it out on Hot Lips Houlihan. Definitely sounds like logic that would ring true in 1970. Definitely not logic that I would take seriously on any day of the week here in 2023.

There's really no excuse, except for the fact that this movie was made in "a different time." That's not really an excuse either, though. You know that already. It's not an excuse, but it is a fact. We know better now, 53 years later. We know that it's kinda icky for this behavior to happen and for a film to be in on the joke. It would be different if M*A*S*H was, like, condoning Hawkeye and Trapper for committing sex crimes, but this is a comedy, you see. We're supposed to laugh when they pull that shit. 

Like I said, I laughed at a healthy amount of this movie, but the misogyny thing was way too distracting for me to be able to recommend M*A*S*H to anyone. There's a version of M*A*S*H that gets it right, but this isn't it. Maybe the TV show gets it right? I have to imagine that a network television sitcom didn't feature Hawkeye forcing his camp hookup to give the dentist a handjob to prove that the dentist wasn't gay... but what the fuck do I know.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: No idea what The Master is about. I just know that P.T.A. directs and it features Phillip Seymour Hoffman and it was ranked as like the best film of the decade by multiple critics. Let's go!!!!

No comments: