The best part about BoJack Horseman is that it's always honest about its characters, especially the titular protagonist. There are never any excuses made for BoJack. Despite mostly trying to be a good person, he fucks up. Occasionally, he fucks up badly. And at least once a season, he fucks up irredeemably. It's a fascinating character study, to see BoJack try to be good, and to believe him, but to also have to acknowledge the terrible carnage he leaves in his wake.
I think if you want to watch BoJack Horseman through the lens of a wacky sitcom, that's possible too—sight gags and shenanigans pack each episode to the brim. But that's up to each viewer, and for some reason (probably because endorphins are released when you're sad, and that feeling can become addicting in a pretty fucked up way) I have always been drawn to the darker side of BoJack, the side that holds the mirror up to the audience and says: This might be you.
I know after rewatching this show again that there is very little distinguishing BoJack from me, except for a great support system and a lot of luck (and the fact that he's a horse, I suppose). The cynicism, the holier-than-thou aggravation, the self-pity, the substance abuse that creeps up on you and steers the whole system off the side of the road, it's all there, sometimes deep down and sometimes bubbling under the surface. I think if you see yourself in BoJack, then there's something wrong. Luckily, the show also provides some answers on where to go from here.
Something New
I saw something snarky online regarding the fact that the New Pornographers and the Hold Steady were releasing new albums on the same day that went something like: "Welcome to 2005." To an extent, the snark is warranted, since I don't think anyone's arguing that both of these bands hit their commercial peak and maybe even their creative peak in the mid-'00s. But dismissing almost two decades of evolution for these two indie rock stalwarts is naive too, because there's a lot to be said about all that time.
It's fair to say that both bands have "slowed down" a little bit with age, and you can see that more so with the New Pornographers' Continue as a Guest. There is very little of the uptempo rockers that we saw on, say, "Use It" way back when. I don't think it's a matter of being worn out, but maybe just a lot more contemplative than they used to be. Something like "Bottle Episodes" has a nice little churn and some really nice syncopated vocal work by Carl Newman, plus a saxophone, so, like, it feels like it might break out and hit another level at some point, but never really does. I think I'm okay with that. This is an old band exploring new sonic textures, and I'm here for the ride.
I have the same mindset for this "new" version of the Hold Steady, but I'm way more invested in seeing where they take it. I put "new" in quotes because The Price of Progress is really the second or third album that sounds like modern Hold Steady. There is less of a focus on classic rock theatrics, and more of a focus on Craig Finn's particular brand of street poetry... I guess that's what you call it, even though "street poetry" sounds lame. It's like, he's still telling these really vivid stories, but the details are heightened even farther than they were back in the glory years. What helps is that the characters in his stories are also well past their glory years, and there's so much emotion to be wrung out of that. And when you can take the best of new Hold Steady and find some semblance of the bar band Hold Steady, like in "Sideways Skull," then shit really pops off.
It's not 2005 anymore, not for my favorite bands, and not for me. But that's okay. It feels like we're all growing up together, and that feels pretty good.
Something Borrowed
I've been thinking about this a lot lately, as I approach graduation, and reckon with the idea of saying goodbye to most people whom I met during the past two years. There are a few friends who are going to stick around (you'll know who they are because their names will probably appear on this blog semi-frequently, because one way I force my friendship on people is to get them to write for the blog), but the vast majority of the folks I say hi to around campus will fade away from my life, save for the occasional coincidental meeting at a grocery store or something.
I have long accepted the fact that people come in and out of your life. That's part of it. I've been at peace with the idea since the first time I saw Stand by Me like 20 years ago. So that's not what this is. This is more of a... reframing, I guess. What if the people who didn't stick around weren't "acquaintances," but rather, "good-enough friends"? I like the sound of that. Dan Kois wrote about the phenomenon for Slate, and spoke to it in the context of his own children, and how they don't seem to have any good-enough friends in their life, due to the ease of finding friendships online that specifically cater to their niche interests.
I don't want to discount those friendships, which, in an atomized age, are fun, nurturing, meaningful—everything you’d want a close relationship to be. Yet it's striking to me how frequently teenagers are able to avoid navigating the awkwardness of real-world connection. As one respondent to a recent New York Times survey of kids pointed out, "When I'm online, I can mute myself, and they can't really see me. I can't just mute myself in real life."
I never had that, and maybe such online friendships of the heart would have changed my high school experience. But I wonder if they would have changed it for the better. I couldn't mute myself with those good-enough friends. They really saw me. I had to learn to deal with them and their Extreme fandom; they had to learn to deal with my fussiness and nerdiness. That was the bargain we made, to have people to hang out with. I wonder what version of childhood, of life, offers more happiness: the one spent with perfect friends whom you never see, or the one spent with good-enough friends who, as I was, are up for whatever.
The whole thing is worth reading, but man, that last line is a killer. I think it's something I'm going to hold onto for another reason too—I'm approaching a stage in my life when some of my best friends also seem to be fading away a little bit. Again, I acknowledge the fact that life gets in the way, so this isn't me being sour about it. I'm at peace with where I am in my social relationships.
But I'm just saying that I'm reaching a point when some of my friends whom I have always held dear are starting to feel like strangers to me, a little bit. They're having more and more experiences that don't involve me, and I'm having more and more experiences that don't involve them, for whatever reason—geographical, being a parent or not, careers and families and level of drinking and on and on and on. I think maybe the idea of "good-enough friends" can be helpful in this context too.
Kois is talking about the switch from good-enough friends to used-to-be friends, but I think there's also a sliding scale from great friends to good-enough friends, and people in your life and slide up and down that scale as time moves on. There are friends in my life whom I used to hang with every single goddamn night of the summer, and now we're lucky if we squeeze in a 30-second conversation at a kids' birthday party. That sounds like a good-enough friend, and that's honestly good enough for now. Who knows where life will take our friendship. Might be that we can be great friends again sometime in the future. But for now, it's worth holding onto those good-enough friends as tight at life will allow... which, admittedly, is not that tight, but still, consider it a long-term investment in the good people in your life.
Something Blue
Daisy Jones & the Six was surprisingly great. I'm not sure if the new Prime series reached zeitgest-level popular, but you have probably heard about it at least. We watched it, and I mostly really enjoyed it. The fake documentary style, with the interspersed interviews and whatnot, worked very well in the TV show format, and the acting was pretty uniformly superb. I think some of the dialogue was stilted, especially in those interviews, and the plot was especially soapy (e.g. Billy's substance abuse storyline was cliché-ridden and miles away from BoJack Horseman's nuance). But man, when the band hit the stage, and Riley Keough is doing the Stevie Nix shtick, this show popped off.
So if I liked the show and I liked when the characters were performing their music, then the next logical question is: Am I going to get invested in the soundtrack? I think the answer is no. Not because the music is bad—some of it was quite good, in fact. Not because it's just Fleetwood Mac cosplay—it is, and yeah, I'd rather just listen to Tusk, but if I like one artist then I'm comfortable liking a xerox of that artist. Not because I don't typically dabble in soundtracks—there are exceptions, especially if it's one band playing all original music (even if that band is fictional!).
I think the real reason is because I'm afraid exposure to the album is going to wear off some of the shine that exists because the television show hit me so hard and so unexpectedly. Daisy Jones & the Six soared because of the delicate alchemy between the acting and "seeing the process" and the "live performances" and the fun music, but listening to the soundtrack strips all that away besides the music itself, which, while fun still, sure, probably can't stand on its own enough for me to be interested. Zero judgment if your mind doesn't work this way, and a soundtrack to a good TV show allows you to keep hitting that pleasure button. But that's not me.





No comments:
Post a Comment