OK OK OK I need to get something out of the way before I start my review in earnest. Am I absolutely batshit, or does "Cool About It" remind you of Simon & Garfunkel's "The Boxer"? I swear, I can't not hear it and I want to make sure I'm not having some kind of sonic stroke. But also if it's intentional, I think it's a brilliant move and ode to musical storytelling. If unintentional, then, well... most singer-songwriter roads lead to those guys anyway. Okay, back to our regularly scheduled writing...
In the first few listens, I thought of the record as a mostly top-heavy winner, but with more time spent, I found myself jamming harder to the latter end. It's giving mid-'90s alt rock and I mean that as a sincere compliment. I'm glad I kept pushing to listen longer and deeper.
Truth be told, I find the opener "Without You Without Them" to be a bit twee, and dare I say, gimmicky? Which is an easy turn-off considering boygenius' most famous star, Phoebe Bridgers, is one of those celebrities that fans have a weird parasocial relationship with. It feels a little "we knew you wanted this." I was a bit skeptical anyway going in because all of my husband's Gen Z cousins are obsessed, and I was worried I might not get it. But then again, I'm a huge fan of famous sad dads the National. I fall for their end-of-show "Vanderlyle Crybaby Geeks" schtick every single time. You do you, sad gals!
What I love most about this album is it feels stripped back and raw without losing any true quality of the work. The songs are good enough to stand alone without too much production or excess noise. It's just written, orchestrated, and performed really beautifully. And it never feels like three different artists collaborating on an album. They are a sum, not just the parts. boygenius has a true singular voice and vision in the album. Albeit, a totally heartbreaking one.
A personal favorite is "Strong Enough," which really solidly answers the question, "do we need men?" No! (Just think of how many times the women of boygenius speak in the first person as men in this album. HNNGGGGGG) And "We're in Love"... are you freaking KIDDING ME? How dare you make something so hauntingly familiar, and yet singular? How dare! I wish I had "Anti-Curse" in my late 20s. Suffice it to say, it lived up to my much cooler younger cousins-in-law's hype, and then some.
If nothing else boygenius, MUNA, Maggie Rogers, etc., are proof that we don't need more Coachella, we need another goddamn Lilith Fair.

1 comment:
"Bring Back the Lilith Fair" is the take of the week.
Post a Comment