The problem is the internet, of course. Yeah, sure, it's great that we can make all these connections that we would not have otherwise. But spending time online also makes you aware of the existence of the "bad takes." Does it surprise you that boygenius, a team-up of three white queer female millennials-bordering-on-Gen-Zs, would inspire some premature vitriol online? It should not. That annoys me, but it also annoys me how hyperaware I'm made to be of the backlash to the backlash. The "timeline drama" or whatever the fuck. The endless war between grumpy skeptics and ignorant stans. The need to hash and rehash every "big" pop culture event with a myriad of strangers. I hate it all. I take broad steps to remove it from my life, but clearly I'm not doing a great job of it, if I am at least a little bit aware of the fact that boygenius has received a lot of praise and a lot of criticism and none of it seems to be about the goddamn music at all.
Okay, so what exactly is my responsibility here? I'm not gonna sit here and repeat anything that random jabronis on the world wide web have been chattering about for the past month. You don't need to hear the PR pitch about how "these are three women taking down the patriarchy by actually being friends with each other, in public!" and you also don't need to hear about how this PR is "actually a desperate attempt to paper over the fact that this music is basic as fuck, and like why do we feel the need to even say this about women artists anyway." Tear it all down. I don't want to hear any of it.
My responsibility as some dipshit blogger writing his 221st album review in as many weeks is to let you know how I feel, and that's really fucking hard when the dull roar of the internet threatens to encroach. Like, okay, for example, think about this:
I am comfortable in saying that I have liked Phoebe Bridgers before she became, like, actually popular and well-known. Puke on Your Birthday's first mention of the artist was in 2017's Top Songs list (in retrospect, it should have been "Scott Street" and it should've been higher on the list, but my point remains). She was nominated for the Grammy for Best New Artist at the 2021 ceremony. While I take issue with this category more than any other shitty Grammy category, it probably does act as a good measuring stick for an artist's popularity. I.e. you have to be pretty well-known to be recognized in this way. So it's been weird in one of those "I knew her first!" sort of ways to see her blow up in the manner that she has. I'm not saying that I "discovered" her or anything, but there was a measurable leveling up from the indie rock sphere to something approaching pop stardom.
And that's fucking weird, and that makes me feel at least a little self-aware. I almost feel this subconscious need to "take back" some of my Phoebe fandom, because of what such a fandom would connotate—that I condone the so-called "sad girl musician" movement, which I don't. I wouldn't even fucking know about such a thing if it wasn't for the internet and our collective need to put stupid labels on shit. The issue with labels like that is twofold. One, you get pigeonholed—the record is not "sad girl music," and yet the assumption is that it is anyway, since Phoebe Bridgers is a key ingredient. The label is reductive. boygenius is more than that. Two, you start to get artistic vultures who are going to jump into that trend and make a lot of money on the backs of it—Olivia Rodrigo comes to mind, whose SOUR has aged pretty poorly already, and whose "drivers license" would not have existed were it not for people (mis)interpreting the art of Phoebe Bridgers.
Then it's kind of the opposite for Julien Baker and Lucy Dacus, for me anyway. They are empirically less popular than Phoebe Bridgers. Also important to note that, personally, I have never been able to connect to their respective solo work like I have with Bridgers, despite the fact that I have tried really hard to get there with a total of five LPs between the two of them. And so what to make of the fact that Baker and Dacus so thoroughly overshadow and overpower Bridgers on the record? I can't in good faith say that they are better musicians or artists in any objective or subjective sense. So I'm left blaming the internet. I wouldn't even have to think about the power dynamics at all if I didn't know anything about these incredible women. I could just enjoy the goddamn music. Which is why we're all here, ultimately.
Theoretically. Note that I've already spent over 800 words talking about boygenius without actually speaking to the music itself. I will get there, maybe. But I think it's important to know where I'm coming from here, because that is going to taint some of my opinions. Know that I am aware of where the battle lines have been drawn. Know that I feel compelled to choose a side. Know that I feel sick to my stomach that I have that awareness and I have that compulsion. I wish my take on the record could be pure. I wish my reaction to the record was a reaction to the music and didn't have to also be a reaction to other people's reaction. But that's what happens when we boot up the computer or smart phone and subject ourselves to the horrors of the internet.
Anyways, I don't think even the internet could stop this from being a great motherfucking album. Let's all just relax a little bit and talk about some good moments. How's that sound? Or have you not had enough of my stupid extraneous ramblings yet?
The good thing about the record is that, unlike boygenius EP, it's less clear whose songs are whose. It's not always "this is clearly a Phoebe song" or "this sounds like something Lucy Dacus would write" or whatever. Sometimes, but not always, especially when they pass the vocals back and forth (like in "Cool About It"). Feels like a group effort and not a compilation of disparate artists, which is helpful in the cohesion of the record.
On the other hand, there are the "big moments" scattered around the album, either songs or parts of songs, that definitively belong to only one of the three members of boygenius. As mentioned previously, I found that Baker and Dacus had more of those big moments, which is interesting (up to a point). Maybe this is because the first three songs released (and the three that soundtrack the film) are indeed labeled by lead artist, and Baker's "$20" is the clear winner, followed closely by Dacus' "True Blue" (though Bridgers' "Emily I'm Sorry" does have that sneaky staying power that the best Bridgers songs have, and the slow-song-vs.-monster-truck juxtaposition is classic Phoebe).
I mean, "$20" is just a fucking revelation. This sounds nothing like anything Julien Baker has ever done before, and I love it in ways that I could never seem to love her previous work. The thing just moves so hard, with a stomping guitar that would not sound out of place a large outdoor amphitheater this summer. The big guitar comes back in "Satanist," which sonically appeals to us cretins who back "Possum Kingdom" as one of the unheralded masterpieces of mid-'90s grunge, but which also slots nicely into Baker's constant themes of struggling with a childhood under the oppression of religion.
Lucy Dacus doesn't rock as hard, but that might not have fit as well as it clearly does Baker anyway. She soars in her balladry instead. "True Blue" is one of the prettiest and most powerful songs on an album full of them. It succeeds in rhythm, with those big tom-tom hits. It succeeds in specificity, with the undeniably Dacusian line of "You say you're a winter bitch / but summer's in your blood." It succeeds visually—this is a family blog, so you don't want to hear the positive opinions I have about the end of the "True Blue" video, but you should know that those positive opinions will live in my head forever. All of it adds up to a song that I'm comfortable saying is the best thing that Lucy Dacus has ever done.
I think her "Leonard Cohen" is fucking hilarious. I am also aware that this was one of "those songs" that caused "controversy" online. I'm sorry to go back to that well, but it's important here because those stupid takes can fuck right off—this song is great. I am saying this as someone who is so indifferent to Leonard Cohen as an artist that I might as well just say that I hate him at this point. His music sucks, and I cackled when Dacus both found poignancy in his lyrics and in the same breath reduced him to being a "horny old man." I love it. This is Lucy Dacus flexing. Kill your idols! Do it!
I'm not leading up to a conclusion in which I state that Phoebe Bridgers is a negative presence on the record, by the way. Say what you will about how Bridgers' pop near-stardom has strained the relationship between artist and audience, but then take what you just said and shove it up your ass. "Not Strong Enough" is probably the best song on the album, at the end of the day, and it is indisputably a Phoebe Bridgers song. It might be the most Phoebe-est Bridgers-est Phoebe Bridgers song of all time. Let us not deride her for lacking big moments otherwise; let us instead praise Phoebe Bridgers for sharing the wealth, even in her own hit song.
Yeah, there are some slow, pretty movements that lack some of the pomp and circumstance that these three artists can consistently provide. the record isn't perfect, but what album is, really? Tough to hold that against them when there are this many big moments stacked on one single album, by a supergroup, no less. It's easy and enjoyable when you focus on the big moments, and fun to think that all three women contributed their best selves to what could have easily been a forgettable side project. The only difficult part is the constant fucking noise surrounding a release like this. I say: fuck 'em. I think it's a great album, and, beyond my beautiful friends and loved ones who deign to share their opinions in this intimate music-and-writing club, I don't want to hear the dumb fucking online takes that anyone else comes up with.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
Now that we've dispensed of the musical opinions and distilled those opinions into a grade, let's take a risk and contribute one of those awful extraneous online takes to the general discourse. This maybe isn't necessary, but I'd like to walk you through my thought process when confronted with the very real and necessary task of playing "Fuck Marry Kill" with the members of boygenius.
The problem upfront being that I respect all three women artistically and personally, and were it not for my utter disdain and discomfort at anything resembling a parasocial relationship, I'd probably even say something along the lines of "I am in love with" all three of them, especially after a week spent with the record. So I don't know who I'd choose to "kill," because none of them seem right for that designation. I can definitely say that Bridgers is the woman at the bar I'd be afraid to even approach at the bar because I'm so intimidated by her overall looks and demeanor and gestalt, but that Dacus would be the woman that ultimately I'd try really hard to go home with, since she is also attractive and perhaps better suited, proportions-wise, to my own tall/larger frame, and so, attractive in that way too, and plus I guess for some reason I assume she would be a more generous lover, which also makes her more attractive (which is probably an ego thing on my part but let's not get too deep into the Freudian shit right now). I'm not trying to be creepy here, I swear, I'm just speaking my cold, hard, hetero male truth, and attempting to speak it in a respectful manner (though maybe not possible when playing FMK). And not to forget Baker, who is the coolest (wait for it), and is more, like, handsome, who would instantly be more of a bro to me than an object of attraction, who would be a great friend, whom I would feel I could be myself around, especially with the grounded knowledge that, as the only straight-up lesbian of the trio, she would never be attracted to me, and so that takes the pressure off, like I would never get nervous around Julien Baker like I do women who count men as at least part of their general attraction palette. But so what does this mean in the context of FMK? Would it make more sense to "marry" Baker or "kill" her? Is the prospect of marrying me more or less horrifying than the prospect of dying, for Baker herself? And what, do I "marry" Phoebe Bridgers because I have had a crush on her for longer, or does that make sense for Lucy Dacus, who would clearly be a better wife? If the bro code requires that I'm not choosing "kill" for Baker, then who gets the hypothetical ax, given that "marry" and "fuck" both make a lot of sense for Bridgers and Dacus, each for different reasons? Could I ever stand to live in a world in which Phoebe Bridgers is seriously considered the "K" in FMK, even though it starts make a fucked-up sort of sense in this particular triplicate? Can't I just not kill anyone? Does this ruin FMK? Can we include boygenius' bassist Jay Som? Do you see now how the internet has ruined me?

No comments:
Post a Comment