Tuesday, December 5, 2017

2017 in Review: The Year's Best Songs

This is the soundtrack to my 2017. Whether I was riding my bike through the blistering cold, drinking along the Delaware River, washing the dishes, sick on the couch with a hangover, driving around the city with my beautiful wife, at work on a boring Tuesday afternoon, or shooting the shit with friends at a house party, these songs were there. These songs make me happy, make me feel, make me content. I hope you enjoy these songs as much as I did this year.

HONORABLE MENTIONS

These 45 songs were not elite enough to be ranked, but they are great fucking songs, and they deserve to be mentioned here.

"Bad Luck Again" by the Rural Alberta Advantage ... "Baybee" by Jay Som ... "Brickwall" by Fred Thomas ... "Cumberland Gap" by Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit ... "Death and Destruction" by Low Cut Connie ... "Fish Fry" by Slaughter Beach, Dog ... "Green Light" by Lorde ... "Had It All" by Hater ... "Haunted House" by Ryan Adams ... "High Speed" by Single Mothers ... "High Ticket Attractions" by the New Pornographers ... "I Don't Ever Wanna Leave California" by Allison Crutchfield ... "I Had a Hat" by Dropkick Murphys ... "I Want U" by Alex Lahey ... "Ignorecam" by Pissed Jeans ... "Little Silver Cross" by White Reaper ... "Living in the City" by Hurray for the Riff Raff ... "Los Ageless" by St. Vincent ... "Lost Out in the Darkness" by Hiss Golden Messenger ... "Love Is Love" by Woods ... "Makin' Excuses" by Mister Heavenly ... "Mary" by Big Thief ... "No Known Drink or Drug" by Japandroids ... "Over Everything" by Courtney Barnett and Kurt Vile ... "Painting a Hole" by the Shins ... "Picture That" by Roger Waters ... "The Pilot" by Clap Your Hands Say Yeah ... "Planes, Chest Pains, and Automobiles" by Iron Chic ... "Play the Field" by Partner ... "Procession" by Beachheads ... "Radio Kids" by Strand of Oaks ... "Reindeer Games" by Oso Oso ... "Replica" by the xx ... "Run to the City" by Ted Leo ... "Running" by Bully ... "Sensitive Guy" by Baio ... "Stained Glass" by Real Estate ... "Tangerine" by Beach Fossils ... "Tear It Down" by Spoon ... "Till Death" by Japanese Breakfast ... "Tinseltown Swimming in Blood" by Destroyer ... "Total Entertainment Forever" by Father John Misty ... "The Underside of Power" by Algiers ... "A Wall" by Downtown Boys ... "100 Years" by Vagabond

RUNNERS UP

TOP 25 SONGS OF 2017

25. "About a Bruise" by Iron & Wine

I fucking love when bands that I've traditionally not really cared for all of a sudden put out an album that I'm crazy about. Iron & Wine did that to me this year. I've always found Sam Ervin Beam's music to be a little boring, but Beast Epic is so full of life, I can't get enough of it. "About a Bruise" is probably the best track here. It's just so soulful.

Iron & Wine


24. "Hard Times" by Paramore

There are certain tricks in music that always get me, and "Hard Times" has one of them. When the whole band is jamming, and all of a sudden they stop for a beat and all hit the same notes at the same time. Love it. That one moment makes this song worth it.

Paramore


23. "Follow the Leader" by Foxygen

Foxygen's 2017 album, Hang, in my opinion, is just basically one big Fuck You. The way I see it, Foxygen read the reviews for 2014's ...And Star Power, which most likely all classified the album as scattered, difficult, borderline unlistenable, and they were basically like, "Alright, fuck you guys, we're gonna do an album that is the complete opposite, dripping with schmaltz, impossibly corny, you didn't like noise freakouts well then how about a fucking ragtime tune?" You know what, though? It worked. Fuck the critics.

Foxygen


22. "Expect the Bayonet" by Sheer Mag

Compared to, say, 2016, I don't have too many "protest songs" on the list this year. I think maybe it's because I spent pretty much every single day of 2017 psychologically hurting when I thought and read about the state of my country, and I needed music to be an escape, rather than have it feed my anger. Exceptions abound, including this fucking ripper from Sheer Mag. When I'm ready to gear up and protest the next trump atrocity, "Expect the Bayonet" is gonna be the soundtrack.

Sheer Mag


21. "The Heart Is a Muscle" by Gang of Youths

Go Father in Lightness is just one of those albums on which every song is a fucking hit, and so I went back and forth on what song was "the best" out of all of them. It was tough. And despite the fact that "The Heart Is a Muscle" comes dangerously close to a song I would expect to hear on 104.5 FM (104.5-core is my least favorite genre), it's just too infectious to pass up.

Gang of Youths


20. "Hey Kids (Bumaye)" by Run the Jewels

Gotta love classic Run the Jewels. Basically take a heavy rap beat, and then rap over it, rapping about two themes exclusively: Fuck the Man Let's Burn This Shit Down, and My Dick Is Huge. A great Danny Brown verse doesn't hurt (a rapper I've never heard of before this song, because I'm not good with rap, but I guess if I needed to try rap again I'd go with Danny Brown just based on this verse alone).

Run the Jewels


19. "Creature Comfort" by Arcade Fire

In my mind, Arcade Fire has yet to put out a bad record. If you read any of the reviews for their newest, Everything Now, you'll find that many people disagree with my opinion. Compared to Funeral, sure, it's not great. But that's not a fair comparison. The album has a lot of redeemable songs, chief of which is "Creature Comfort." Tell me this ain't a good song.

Arcade Fire


18. "Let 'Em Talk" by Kesha

I never thought I'd be listening to a Kesha song and confusing it for a Los Campesinos! song. I also never thought I'd ever listen to a full fourteen-song Kesha album and pretty much enjoy every single track. I love being wrong about artists. You go, Kesha.

Kesha


17. "Amen, So Be It" by John Moreland

"The best Bruce Springsteen song not written by Bruce Springsteen" is the most accurate description I've heard of this song, or any song, all year, so let's just leave it at that.

John Moreland


16. "Want You Back" by Haim

Be still my heart. No amount of derision or mockery from my loving wife will ever quell my Haim fandom.

Haim


15. "You're Dreaming" by Wolf Parade

One of my favorite things about Wolf Parade is how great the two frontmen complement each other. Dan Boeckner is more straight ahead rock but his solo music can get a little too gritty sometimes. Spencer Krug is more prone to flights of fancy and his music gets way too bogged down in weirdness. Together, they elevate each other. Would "You're Dreaming," a Boeckner tune through and through, reach the same heights without Krug's wild keyboard playing? Probably not.

Wolf Parade


14. "Silver" by Waxahatchee

Goddamn, something about those "ooo OOO" hooks really get to me. No one does this shit better than Katie Crutchfield. "Silver" was my song of the summer.

Waxahatchee


13. "The Flinch" by Dave Hause

"Regret is like a street beatdown." This is Hause's call to live life with courage, to live life to the fullest. Take every opportunity, he's singing. Don't flinch.

Dave Hause


12. "DNA." by Kendrick Lamar

I don't get excited about rap verses too often, but the ending of "DNA." is probably the most excited I've been about rap since the middle of "Swimming Pools (Drank)."

Kung Fu Kenny


11. "I Miss Those Days" by Bleachers

I'm just a complete and utter sucker for songs about nostalgia. Clearly, based on the title alone, this song is just that. Corny? Yes. Pretty much everything Jack Antonoff does is corny. But fuck, it's catchy and fun and I can totally empathize with the nostalgia he feels for the good ol' days.

Bleachers


10. "Lookers" by the Menzingers

Ditto the above parts about nostalgia.

The Menzingers


9. "Would You Rather" by Phoebe Bridgers

Being a veteran of playing the fun, drinking version of "Would You Rather," I was caught off guard by how depressing this song is. Bridgers is so good at creating those songs that are in equal measures sad and wistful. A guest turn by Conor Oberst lifts this song to another level.

Phoebe Bridgers


8. "Day I Die" by the National

Marriage is a choice you make every single day, both parties. This is Matt Berninger's promise to his wife that he will continue to choose marriage and he wants to choose it all the way up to his death day. I'm making that same promise. I hope Pam feels the same way (replace this song's lyric of "I get a little punchy with the vodka" with maybe "I get a little horny with the gin" and you can see the challenges Pam faces with me, but she chose marriage this morning so let's keep this thing going?!).

The National


7. "call the police" by LCD Soundsystem

This is the only song on the new LCD Soundsystem record that sounded like "classic" LCD Soundsystem. Which makes it a great song.

LCD Soundsystem


6. "Lower Order (A Good Laugh)" by Propagandhi

I feel bad when I choose the outlier on an album as its best song, because I know it's not the best representation of the band. Still, it's hard to resist such a great song as this, on an album of otherwise normal hardcore songs that I could give or take. Not that Propagandhi, like, tones it down or anything, but this song is definitely the most melodic and least brash on the album. And it's an impassioned plea for vegetarianism, no less!

Propagandhi


5. "Bobby" by (Sandy) Alex G

(Sandy) Alex G does a lot of good shit on his album Rocket, but the best trick might be making you cry. Something about "Bobby" tugs at my heartstrings so hard. It's a devastating account of a loveless marriage, sung duet-style over a rambling banjo and moaning fiddle. I know "I'm Crying" memes were killed when people started describing Adele's music in that way, but for real you guys, I cried a few times this year listening to this song.

(Sandy) Alex G


4. "Tara" by BNQT

BNQT is the self-described "poor man's Traveling Wilburys," with members from Midlake, Franz Ferdinand, etc., and they are the most hit-or-miss band I listened to all year. Some of their songs are just plain fucking awful. But when they hit, they fucking hit. "Tara" is a fucking blast, sung by Band of Horse's Ben Bridwell. It's the best kiss-off song that the Band never recorded. Bridwell's high falsetto has never brought me so much joy as it does during the year's best lyrics: "Fuck me? / Fuck you too!"

BNQT


3. "To Know Your Mission" by Jens Lekman

Me and Pam saw Jens last spring in concert, and he was one of the most sincere and genial artists I think I've ever seen perform in person. If any other artist sang a song like this, it would just come off as lame and corny. Jens Lekman is just so upfront and upbeat about everything, that singing about "knowing your mission" in life is just the best goddamn thing. I couldn't relate, because even at this age, I still do not know what my "mission" is. But based on this song along, I can imagine knowing is the best goddamn feeling in the world.

Jens Lekman


2. "God in Chicago" by Craig Finn

"God in Chicago" is my second favorite song of the year, but it's honestly less of a song and more of a short story laid over a piano piece. Goddamn it's a beautiful story, though. Finn quotes Kerouac in probably the best song from the Hold Steady, but "God in Chicago" indicates that he may just BE Kerouac.

Craig Finn


1. "In Chains" by the War on Drugs

Adam Granduciel's lyrics are usually too obtuse for me to figure out. I'm sitting here even now trying to make heads or tails of "In Chains," and what Granduciel is trying to tell me. In many ways, though, maybe I don't need the lyrics to get the message. "In Chains" is the year's best song by a mile, and it's the year's most emotional, most powerful, most heart-wrenching.

Between the drums that just keep chugging along, the simple piano melody that comes in and out, the baritone sax that steadily rises, the music itself all comes together and creates such an intense sense of longing. Put it this way: me and Pam drove home from Doylestown one night, down a bunch of roads that were pitch-black dark, and "In Chains" was the perfect soundtrack. It's the music when you're lost in life, and maybe you don't even know what you're looking for.

And those feelings permeate throughout the song (and your ears) for the first five and a half minutes of the song, until suddenly, it changes. The drums stop their 4/4 and go into a staccato kickbeat at the 5:36 mark. Granduciel's voice strains and bursts with intensity: "I can feel it ALLLLL" and you can feel that we're reaching the climax here, the tension can be cut with a fucking knife, the drums continue with the kicks of the bass drum, two more measures now, and then: "Gimme truth!!!" And then that drum fill, and then the harmonica brings us home.

That's the answer. Truth. It's the skeleton key that unlocks the otherwise obtuse lyrics. It's what the singer is looking for in the song. It's what we're all looking for, really. And when the answer is finally found, the truth, then the harmonica solo becomes a celebration. The sense of longing is finally relieved. It's fucking cathartic.

This all sounds really stupid when I write it out. I realize that. I'm not that great at translating my deepest, almost subconscious feelings into written word, especially when it comes to music. After reading my bullshit year-end lists for like seven years now, you should know this already.

But you should know too, you guys, that "In Chains" made me feel things that I didn't even know were inside me. 2017 was a year that was confusing and frustrating and had some great fucking times but also made me question myself and who I was and what I believed in. "In Chains" perfectly captured my year in a seven-minute song.

The War on Drugs

No comments: