Love Actually is one of those movies that is way less complex than it wants to be. Sure, all these characters are intertwined in a myriad of ways, some more clever than others. But at its core, Love Actually is just a series of morality plays. Each story has a good guy and/or a bad guy, and we sit back and watch to see if these characters make the right decision or the wrong one. Oh, and this all happens in December, technically making this a Christmas movie.
It's a great film! Pam and I definitely include it in the half dozen Christmas movies we watch every year. But, man, year after year, I have the same complaints about this film. Mainly, there are characters that make me angry. And there are a lot of characters!
Let's play judge and jury and determine whether the main characters are COOL, or are a DICK. Because I myself am totally a good person and totally am able to judge these fictional characters on their morals and merits.
It's a great film! Pam and I definitely include it in the half dozen Christmas movies we watch every year. But, man, year after year, I have the same complaints about this film. Mainly, there are characters that make me angry. And there are a lot of characters!
Let's play judge and jury and determine whether the main characters are COOL, or are a DICK. Because I myself am totally a good person and totally am able to judge these fictional characters on their morals and merits.
Jamie — COOL
I can't think of another instance in movies or TV that depicts someone being cheated on, and then the person that was cheated on acts so... rationally? We don't get to see the scenes in between the exposure of the unfaithful wife and the retreat to the countryside, but by the time Jamie sets up shop with his typewriter in a secluded cottage home, it appears that Jamie has made peace with the shitty hand he was dealt. Basically, there was a part of his life that wasn't working, so he said fuck it, and moved on. And he was rewarded for his prudent behavior.
Aurelia — COOL
Not much is known about Aurelia, but I think that's kind of the point. Jamie literally can't verbally interact with Aurelia, but somehow they are able to make a human connection, and they find a way to fall for each other anyway. Aurelia is shown to be good and simple and kind. Definitely worth learning Portuguese for.
Sam — DICK
My rating might be harsh, but there's something extremely off-putting about a ten-year-old kid speaking so strongly about "love." I get that that's the point, and possibly the humor in the situation, that a preteen is able to so eloquently explain his feelings. But the idea of performing a huge gesture for a girl that you don't know and have never spoken to and still somehow are "in love with" is creepy in any context, ten years old or no.
Daniel — COOL, I GUESS
I'm more on the fence about this character than any other character in the movie. Yeah, supporting his child's wild misconceptions about love is irresponsible parenting. But Daniel is obviously in mourning, and I can't really blame him for trying his hardest to form a connection with the only immediate family he has left, even if the bonding they do involves trying to get his ten-year-old stepson laid.
Billy Mack — RELUCTANTLY DICK
I'm reluctant with this rating as well, because Billy Mack is legitimately funny in the movie, and I really did appreciate his "Dirty Uncle" shtick he employs throughout. But his humor is derived from cutting other people down. Whether it's his manager, an unseen boy band, or his audience's tastes in general, his humor is negative and degrading, and always at the expense of others. Maybe I see too much of myself in Billy Mack. It's challenging and rewarding to gets laughs from creating something. It's cheap and easy to get laughs from tearing something down. Billy Mack, late-movie redemption notwithstanding, employs too much of the latter. Hilariously, mind you, but still.
Joe — COOL
In Joe, we have the personification of the constantly abused. I mean, I can sympathize with him, getting constantly berated for being overweight by his ostensible "best friend." But he takes that shit like a champ, at the end of the day he realizes that Billy Mack is just being an asshole for kicks, and not because Billy genuinely dislikes him or anything. I think Joe is COOL because he understands the complex nature of male friendships, and is willing to forgive Billy when he goes too far. (And, almost as importantly, can dish it out when he needs to.)
Colin — DICK
This dude is fucking insufferable throughout the entire movie. His one and only goal is to fuck women, but he goes about it in the crassest way. For example, when he is "hitting on" the chick at the wedding, it ends up just being insulting. Colin's big plan is to go to America because it will be easier to fuck women there. So he goes to America, and sure enough, he immediately fucks like four women at the same time. I don't know what aggravates me more, that Love Actually seems to be rewarding Colin for being a dick, or that in real life, his plan to use his British accent to get laid would, in actuality, probably work.
Harry — DICK
This one is obvious, and everyone knows it. Love Actually knows it. The audience knows it. Harry's wife knows it. Even Harry himself fucking knows it. Though we never actually see Harry cheat on his wife with the hot young secretary, it's heavily implied. Even if he didn't actually hook up with Mia, and the extent of Harry's crimes were just that he bought Mia an expensive necklace and his wife a fucking jazz-concept album by Joni Mitchell, even if that's the worst Harry did, then the disproportionate gift-giving is essentially a metaphor for the state of his marriage and his tendency to break good things. Harry made the wrong choice. He followed his penis, not his heart.
Karen — COOL
I admire Karen in the same way I admire Jamie, though their respective situations are a bit different. Karen has a strong and probably correct suspicion that her husband is cheating on her. I mean, the dude fucking flaunted that shit right to her face at the Christmas party, flirting with Mia the whole party while Karen watched from afar. Karen did the right thing by calling Harry out on his shit regarding the Christmas gifts. Did she do the right thing by staying with Harry even after all his bullshit? I don't think that's for the audience to determine. Whether Harry made amends or whether Harry continued to fuck around, I think we need to trust Karen's judgment on this one, and hope that she made the best choice for herself primarily, and also for her family.
Mia — DICK
I mean, there's not much to say about this one. Mia was obviously aware that Harry was married and monogamous, and yet she was incredible conspicuous when it came to making it known her desire to fuck him. I'm not letting Harry off the hook here, obviously. But Mia knew what she was doing was wrong, and judging by the smile on her face as she puts on Harry's gift necklace, she simply didn't care that it was wrong.
Rufus — COOL(???)
It's never explicitly stated at any point in the movie, but I feel like Rufus might be an omniscient character. First, he takes forever to put Harry's gift together. It's played for humor and tension in the movie, but what if Rufus is taking a long time on PURPOSE?! He wants Harry to get caught, to try to prevent him from going down the wrong path. Then, Rufus shows up again out of nowhere and distracts the airport security while Sam runs past to profess his love. Again, was it just coincidence that Rufus stalls to change the narrative for a character? Rufus' knowing smile says otherwise. He knows what's up.
Prime Minister — DICK
I totally get the idea of not wanting to shit where you eat, so the act of firing his worker Natalie because he likes her makes sense on some baser levels. Even if we are granting the Prime Minister this, it doesn't make what he did any less dickish. How about this for an option: Um, TELL Natalie that you like her, and that's why you need to transfer her to a different department, so he can ask her out on a date? Seems a lot better than sending a lackey to give her the news and keeping her in the dark about it. And is Love Actually trying to say that the Prime Minister makes up for this egregious error in judgment just because he (poor guy!) has to knock on every door on a long street to find Natalie? How about trying to respect her in the first place?
Natalie — COOL
Natalie, to her credit, plays the whole thing off pretty well. I think the movie is trying to make the case that Natalie is a relentlessly upbeat person, and that she would be a good match for the Prime Minister because of this. Forgiving someone for their shittiness is a good thing. Making sure they never do it again is better. Natalie isn't a doormat.
U.S. President — DICK
In the era of #metoo, the US President's sexual inappropriateness with Natalie is especially appalling. Not only that, but I get the sense sometimes watching this movie that the Prime Minister maybe even resents Natalie a little bit for it? Like, say you're Natalie, and then the fucking leader of the free world, this creepy old dude, is whispering sweet nothings in your ear, who wouldn't be uncomfortable? I don't blame Natalie for looking scared for her life. I'm glad the U.S. President got his comeuppance eventually; I'm sad that his comeuppance arrived through vague international political statements, and not, like, a public outcry that the President was a scumbag. (Though, our current president is an alleged sexual assaulter and alleged rapist and bragged about sexually assaulting women on tape, and he doesn't seem to have to face any consequences, so what the fuck do I know.)
John and Judy — COOL
Speaking of consent, here we have two lovely unassuming strangers, who are literally rubbing their naked genitals in each other's faces, and still they manage to maintain a basic level of human decency and respect. No problems here.
Sarah — COOL
I think we are meant to assume that Sarah is less cool than she is throughout the movie, because she is constantly bombarded with calls from an unknown party. Is this his husband? Boyfriend? If she's already shacked up, why is she also so in love with Karl? The questions are answered, and it turns out Sarah is a saint after all. The calls she receives are from her mentally unstable brother, and she accepts the emotional burden of having to talk him down from his episodes, because family comes first.
Karl — DICK
And for most of the movie, Karl is built up as the "ideal" for Sarah, from Sarah's perspective anyway. He is good looking and unassuming and seems nice and genuine. However, Karl earns his DICK status when he does not take kindly to Sarah's prioritizing her brother above all else. So Karl, instead of saying something like, "Wow, I totally understand, it sounds like this is important to you, what can I do to help?" instead he just gets all mopey that he didn't get his cock wet, and pushes Sarah away. Like, we get it dude, you have six-pack abs and women want to fuck you all the time I'm sure, but the woman who is hopelessly in love with you just needs a little emotional care, and you can't commit to that? DOUCHE.
Juliet—DICK
Juliet just got married to the love of her life. Everything is great. There's one small problem though. Her husband's best friend, Mark, is such an asshole. Like, Mark makes it very clear to Juliet that he doesn't think very highly of her. Which, yo, I totally get that this would upset Juliet. She seems like a nice person. But then, when it turns out that Mark is actually in love with her and comes to her house to profess his love while Juliet's husband is right the fuck upstairs, well then, that's where all the sympathy for Juliet ends. Not only does she NOT shut Mark down right away, but she smiles and encourages the dude. She actively hides the whole thing from her husband. And she then gives him a kiss, which on top of this probably not being cool with her husband, also gives Mark false hope, and REWARDS his creepy behavior.
Mark — HOLY SHIT, HUGE DICK
I think the biggest problem I have with this whole thing is twofold. Obviously, this was shitty behavior on the part of Juliet a bit, but definitely shitty behavior on Mark's part primarily. So from a liking/disliking characters standpoint, I dislike Mark the same way I dislike Harry. However, the more important reason that this makes me uneasy is that the movie itself, Love Actually, gives Mark a pass for his creepy fucking behavior. As if Mark muttering "This is it, I'm done, no more" absolves him of his previous sins. If the point of the whole movie is to say that love is messy and complicated, then sure, this would fit that bill. But the movie makes explicitly clear its thesis statement: Love is empirically a good thing, that it's "all around," that it heals, etc. So the whole arc with Juliet and Mark seems like a gigantic misstep. Anyways, fuck Mark.
NEXT WEEK ON PUKE ON YOUR BIRTHDAY: We explore the character dynamics of Valentine's Day and New Year's Eve!!!!



















No comments:
Post a Comment