This album was just alright. I'd give it a solid 2 out of 3 genius stars... meaning it's not an album I'd likely revisit, but it's not one I couldn't tolerate if someone was playing it.
The first song, "Without You Without Them" started out as a nice soft preamble to the rest of the album. Full of gratitude and appreciation for past generations, boygenius really gave me a sense of their strengths vocally; some great harmonizing going on here. With a lot of repetitive chorus, I got the feeling that the band was warming up; no errant squeaks or cracks.
Then comes "$20," picking up strong rock vibes. The lyrics seem to carry over from the previous song in a couple thematic ways: references to family role models, and parents who are encouraging exploration and risk taking. I thought "$20" had to do with paying for gas to keep a car drive adventure going, but I am not diving too deep into the lyrics this time to try and validate this hypothesis. The song ends with a car...
The car reference seems to keep on with "Emily." This is where the album appears to take a bit of a turn away from the whimsical adventure previously sung about, but there is still a theme of exploration in this song and throughout the rest of the album. It seems the narrator is upset about misaligned expectations with a friend/lover—a situationship. Perhaps all the adventuring has created an attraction that is not feeling mutual. Pretty classic of an album about love, but I did not expect this from the title of the album. There is a lot of regret in this song, but also forgiveness. Perhaps this leads back to the first song about gratitude. All relationships have an impact on who we become and who we are in the moment, even relationships that feel fraught at times.
The situationship continues with "True Blue." Some themes of exploration on the beach, but a lot of emotional undertones take over any whimsical adventures. The love being received seems interpreted as "tough," but with some appreciation that this tough-love approach brings a sense of security and value of commitment. Maybe this has to do with the reality that one has to grow up someday and take accountability. Or maybe that we're conditioned to, but there is that pull back to childhood whimsy. I think the writer/narrator of this song is confused, because why would he/she/they say they let go of fights, but feel the need to reflect on the letting go? Are they just tired of the fights?
"Cool About It" reinforces the situationship going on here. But maybe there is some other circumstance that is causing a rift in this relationship. The adventure appears to continue, through what appears to be a date-night. However, it appears there are resentments or lack of communication—avoidant or anxious behavior that is not making this date-night very fun. At this point, the relationship feels like it's going to fizzle out.
"Not Strong Enough" feels like a negative self-narrative being told. Perhaps the character being represented by boygenius is losing his/her mind from the drugs taken in "Cool About It." There's some lyric about lowering expectations, which carries from the last song's theme (being "cool about it," but not really). I like the electronic solo in this song.
"Revolution 0" is where I start losing interest. The song is too soft for me. I'm just as worn out as this character seems to be.
"Leonard Cohen" — I like him and what he stood for as a cynic! But beyond the title, I didn't care for this song.
The rest of the album feels like the situationship is starting to truly transition. One partner seems to be moving on—to "rewrite" life—while the narrator wants to be a part of the next chapter. I honestly can't remember if this was the end of the album (this is where my notes end), so I'll leave the review here.

No comments:
Post a Comment