Wednesday, April 26, 2023

RC f/u Pt. 14: Vulfpeck, We Are Scientists, and Shania Twain

It's been a minute since I've grouped together some Record Club alumni and collectively reviewed a few of their new albums. Not that our vaunted RC alumni base hasn't released any new albums recently. It's just that I've mainly been touching base with the ones I'm into through our SO/SN/SB/SB column (like this and this and this), and otherwise avoiding the albums that I don't think I'm going to like. It's all good! We're back today, with three albums and a completely open mind about them. Is a Shania Twain album from 2023 actually worth listening to? Read on and find out!


Schvitz by Vulfpeck
Released: December 30, 2022
Follow-up to: Hill Climber, Week 49

I'll always remember Pam's visceral disdain for Hill Climber. That says more about me and Pam than it does about Vulfpeck, honestly. I appreciate her extreme reactions, those rare times they occur in the context of music criticism, and that was my biggest takeaway. My own review of the album was way more generous. She didn't write one, but her words were something like: "Sounds like some fucking TV theme song bullshit!"

Listening to Schvitz, I started to understand where Pam was coming from. It's possible that I'm just numb to the corniness of Hill Climber at this point, but I'd argue it's more probable that Schvitz is the sound of a band really laying it thick and leaning into their chintzy tendencies.

The whole shtick with Vulfpeck is that they are designed like the Wrecking Crew, which is essential a group of seasoned session musicians. That shtick really comes into play on Schvitz, even more so than Hill Climbers completely instrumental back half. Guest vocalist Antwaun Stanley is on like half the tracks, and he really goes retro and ironically uncool with it. It's all fine. It is! Even the stupid "Earworm," which is too self-aware by half and double the necessary annoying vocal performance. It's not called "Earworm" for nothing!

I'll still argue that a lot of this is fun because it's stupid. As I said in the last review, you gotta understand the conceit. These are real professionals pretending to be goofy cartoon characters in the studio. It's tossed-off by design, because that makes for a sillier time, and ultimately, MORE MONEY. (For example: the songs all have "Vulfpeck" and "Vulf" listed as co-lead artist on Spotify, no doubt to capture the primary search results of those too lazy to type four letters in the search bar.)

I defended it a couple years ago, and I'll defend it still, but I acknowledge now too that the cracks in the facade are starting to show more and more by the day.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 4 (-1.0 from previous review)


Lobes by We Are Scientists
Released: January 20, 2023
Follow-up to: With Love and Squalor, Week 189

It's always interesting when all the RC reviews for a particular album make more or less the same point and reach the same conclusion. For With Love and Squalor, everyone went hard with the outlook of "this is some generic shit from my teenage years." That's true, and I agreed as much in my own review. But that really doesn't bode well for an album from We Are Scientists released in 2023, does it?

So when I say I was shocked how much I liked Lobes, don't misread it; I liked this album mostly because my expectations were rock bottom, and the band managed to shock me really by just being different than Hot Hot Heat this time around, which ultimately isn't that hard. A generous way to look at it: We Are Scientists have improved! A cynical way of looking at it: We Are Scientists have lost their edge by chasing something different and being only kinda good at it!

The youthful bark is gone, replaced by some pretty polished singing. That's fine. It would've been pathetic for We Are Scientists to sound the exact same way they did fifteen years ago. Credit where it's due. It's still pretty catchy, and it no longer makes me wistful of my halcyon teenage years. Thank god!

There are even some pretty good tunes on this thing. "Human Resources" is a legit bid for stadium rocking. "Operator Error" is pretty inoffensive alt-rock in the Foals vein. "Lucky Just to Be Here" sincerely sounds like the Killers (albeit with a less enthusiastic singer, though Brandon Flowers is hard to match). It definitely gets samey and a little boring in the back half, but for a while there, We Are Scientists had me! Even when it goes big 1980s sounding at the end ("Miracle of '22"), they manage to impress.

I don't really know who this is for, other than insane bloggers who insist on keeping tabs on every musical artist who coincidentally crosses path with his long-running music club. Anyone who likes With Love and Squalor is going to hate this. Anyone who didn't like With Love and Squalor is going to ignore it. Anyone who has never heard of this landrock indie also-ran will be confused as to why they can't just find these sounds on the radio instead. But for me, the guy who thought With Love and Squalor was one big walking cliché and yet has hope for artists who strive to keep going decades after their commercial peak, I thought it was pretty okay.

GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5 (no change from previous review, but only because With Love and Squalor was overrated by like 0.5)


Queen of Me by Shania Twain
Released: February 3, 2023
Follow-up to: Come On Over, Week 107

To understand Shania Twain, it's important to understand the intersection of country and pop. Here's where it stands now: "country music" in the traditional sense is now called "Americana," and "pop country" is what mainstream "country" stations play even though it's actually pop and not country. The latter observation about mainstream country has always been the case, however, and so we must consider Shania Twain a pop star, not a country star.

Which is totally fine, and I'm not saying this is detrimental to my perception of her and her music. I loved Come On Over, and I thought it was goofy and serious in appropriate measures, just enough to be a really fun time. I just take issue with the perception that she is a country music star. She is not, and hasn't been since Come On Over sold 40 million copies. All of this is important in only one very specific way: in order to not be completely confused by Queen of Me, you need to remember that Shania Twain is a pop star, and not a country star.

Queen of Me, despite what the Wikipedia genre tag and the equestrian album cover are attempting to sell you, is NOT a country album. It sounds nothing like country. It also barely sounds almost nothing like anything on Come On Over, to the point that comparing them seems wrong. I do think that Shania Twain is still out there having a good time, and that feeling is infectious—e.g. opening track "Giddy Up!", which is basically a disco track. Twain's prodigious use of exclamation points is key for me throughout her discography.

I don't like everything on here, but mostly because I don't like everything pop. Some of this sounds like Adele with a fucking pulse, which automatically makes Shania Twain better than Adele. Worse still, something like "Pretty Liar" has Meghan Trainor overtones, and I am embarrassed. I pray to my higher power that Shania Twain doesn't have a TikTok presence, but my heart is too sensitive to head into the unknown and find out.

"Inhale/Exhale AIR" is the song that comes closest to being "country," but it's more like Taylor Swift's Red is country—a pop sound taking a quick sideways glance at the country that came way before it. Again, not a criticism. It's a good song. But, as with all certified pop music, we take the good with the bad. Something like the robot boogie of "Number One" is really, truly awful, and maybe makes the listener rethink the decision to not just listen to Come On Over again.

Here's the bottom line, in my humble and possibly ignorant opinion. I'm glad Shania Twain is still out there, living her best life. She had invasive open-throat surgery in the 2000s, and yet still sounds (and looks) amazing. Credit to her for trying out some new sounds in 2023. I'm happy if she's happy. I don't need to be completely happy with new Shania Twain music. That's not the focus here.

GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5 (-1.0 from previous review, and Come On Over was slightly underrated, in retrospect)


See you next time for Gorillaz, Miley Cyrus, and Fall Out Boy.

No comments: