Friday, May 24, 2024

empathogen, Joe


I guess would say I have b i g f e e l i n g s about the "nepo baby" conversation. Regrettably. There are absolutely more important things to worry about than all that nonsense that nerds on the internet obsess over. But were I forced to comment on it one way or the other, I might be inclined to say something like: whether nepotism is okay or not okay is totally dependent on the outcome. Yes, the children of famous people have more opportunities than the children of social workers and nursing professors are going to have. But if those opportunities lead to art that is at the very least interesting (to say nothing about being good), then I don't think that "nepotism" is necessarily an insult that is warranted. Let's save that for the hacks who squander their unfair advantages on artless trash.

WILLOW, at age ten, used her connections to the entertainment industry via celebrity parents Will and Jada to release and promote a song called "Whip My Hair," which found success. I've never heard it, or at least don't think I have, but my assumption has always been that it was a cheap flimsy pop production that became popular because her famous family was able to connect her with strong songwriters and promoters and it peaked at #11 on the Billboard Hot 100 because of those connections, and NOT because of her own abilities. To be clear: no ten-year-old should be expected to have the fully-formed talents to become a full-fledged pop star, so this is not her fault, but still.

If WILLOW's entire career continued on the trajectory established with some one-off viral pop hit, then sure, sling that "nepo baby" term around. It would probably be warranted, but only because the non-unique was unfairly elevated due to familial connections. But here we are, fourteen years later, and if you're one of the handful of people who checked out the 24-year-old WILLOW's new album, then you already know that that ain't how the story went.

empathogen is an utterly fascinating record. I don't know if that's because of the context or despite the context, but at a certain point, it ceases to matter. Taken in isolation, I really like the sounds here. "Art pop" is probably the right way to describe it, as a sort of catch-all to something that defies genre. I hear jazz influences and I hear R&B influences and I hear indie rock influences and I almost hear prog-rock influences (in its purposefully complex time signatures and rhythms). It's a really fun listen on its own.

Contextually speaking, it's weird enough to justify the means through which we arrived here. You can say nepotism but only technically. She's known because her parents are really known. Okay, fine. But just as being born into wealth and fame expands your opportunities, so too does it restrict them in some ways. There are a billion mid-tier struggling artists who are making barely adequate art, but what asshole is going to call them on it? They are just some person. Their anonymity protects them. WILLOW has no such protection. If the music she was making was just simply pretty good in a normal way, then we'd have every right to call her a nepo baby piece of shit. Making art as the daughter of famous people means that your art has to be really good for it to be worth anything. And I'd argue that the truly amazing part about empathogen is that it meets those expectations and then some.

And the really freeing part about being a fan of this album is that there is no pressure on us, the listeners or fans, to really do anything about it besides sit back and enjoy its twists and turns and bizarre hooks. If this was one of those aforementioned struggling artists who broke through and created something worthy of admiration, then I might be inclined to worry about whether their sterling work was going to be enough for them to pay their utility bills, and I'd set about attempting to get other people to listen to their excellent art and become fans and support this artist so that they have the means to continue making more worthy art in the future. But none of that has to happen here. WILLOW is already well-off. She'll be fine if the three people in Record Club who review her album are literally the only people on earth who bother to check out empathogen.

And, like, just picture what it takes for someone to create something unique and worthy of affection when you don't have that external motivation, ya know? WILLOW doesn't have to do anything. She could fuck around and make "Whipping My Hair Again" for the rest of her life, and she'll be no worse off for it. Instead, she chooses to make this. This charming, strange, alluring art-pop album. I dunno, man, I appreciated it.

Think about all the cool components of this thing. The way she draws out the sense of size and scope in "b i g f e e l i n g s" in 7/4 time. The way that she rips the baton out of St. Vincent's hand by giving her an entire song ("pain for fun") and then outdoing her in a song ("run!") that could've been straight off of Strange Mercy. The way every song sounds like WILLOW doing something new with her voice (e.g. how "the fear is not real" goes from ethereal moaning to breathless staccato over a tough drum groove). The way that Jon Batiste, of all fucking people, starts the album and manages to NOT sound like the dorkiest asshole in the world. The way that the parts that slow things down (e.g. "ancient girl" or, um, "down") still manage to feel essential in their brevity. The way that the feel and flow of these songs are so unpredictable (e.g. "between i and she" switches between like three different styles, and sounds like a mutant Olivia Rodrigo song while managing to sneak in what I'm going to choose to see as a Los Campesinos! reference). The way that the album art is a very silly and kinda brave(?) attempt at making literal the "attempt at showing one's true self" that maybe not everyone in her position would make. The way that so much of this manages to be catchy even in its weirdness.

The "nepo baby" conversation is unfair to pretty much everyone involved. It's unfair to the common folk, that we lose out on opportunities because rich people let their rich children jump the line. It's unfair to artists who didn't ask to be born into wealth, and some who find that they need to go above and beyond to make art that is worth discussing. It's probably even a little unfair to the rich and connected parents of those artists. Not that I'm shedding a tear in any scenario for Will Smith specifically, who, again, would've been just fine even if his children became worthless money-sucking slugs. But I'm talking about some shared sense of empathy I feel, in a very general sense, for all parents who just want what's best for their children. I am not rich or famous or well-known or well-connected, but if there is a way for my kids to benefit in some oblique way from my existence and the menial work that I've done leading up to this point in our lives, then you can bet your ass I'm gonna make sure my kids benefit from that. And far be it from me to get in their way.

I guess I can understand the opposite too... I'm thinking now about the rich father who purposefully keeps all of his own life's spoils away from his children, makes them get a shit job as a teenager, makes them experience the suffering of the common man, because they believe that it "builds character." In many ways, that hypothetical father is probably correct. Suffering does build character. But on the flip side of that coin, I don't think the lack of suffering necessarily precludes someone from having character. You know what I mean? If you don't, check out empathogen. WILLOW is, by all accounts, a human being who will never want for anything in her entire life, and will never suffer, not really. And yet, she is able to make this album, somehow. This bafflingly beautiful half hour of music. There's wonder in that too, I think. How a person like that makes an album like this. You wonder, and you revel in that wonder, and you enjoy. But you don't sling "nepo baby" shit around, because it ain't warranted here. The outcome is just too good.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: