I'm a blogger. I blog about 200 movies I've never seen before... in this little town called Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The last four years, I've been at Puke on Your Birthday. I was a blogger. Back home, I tell people what I do for a living and they think well, now that figures. But over here, it's a big, a big mystery. So, I guess I've changed some. Sometimes I wonder if I've changed so much watching these films my wife is even going to recognize me, whenever it is that I get back to her. And how I'll ever be able to tell her about films like today. Ah, Saving Private Ryan. I don't know anything about Saving Private Ryan. I don't care. The movie means nothing to me. It's just a name. But if... you know, if watching these 200 films and writing about them, if that earns me the right to get back to my wife, then that's my mission.
Saving Private Ryan
1998
Steven Spielberg
1998
Steven Spielberg
I fucking loved The Fabelmans, but there are days in which I wish I'd never seen The Fabelmans. It was just too effective in explaining Steven Spielberg's love of making movies. It was so deft in showing a man who knew the secret alchemy in creating movie magic. I fucking love the idea of movie magic, and how there are certain films that make us forget who we are and instead completely and totally pull us into a brand new world. That's the magic, and Spielberg is one of the best to ever create that magic. But The Fabelmans showed us the why and the how, and that was important too, and so now... it's like, whenever I watch a Spielberg flick, I can't stop thinking about how that magic was made. It's created this distance for me. Ironically, appreciating the magic act has made it harder to let the magic take me away.
Saving Private Ryan is an epic war drama. It might be the epic war drama of my lifetime. I knew this going in, and I wasn't surprised by the fact that it felt very real and in its realness was brutal and raw and made me gasp on multiple occasions. This is what war is truly like, and through a master filmmaker, we get to experience it—experience the pain and anguish and brutality—is if we were practically there. I know people give the framing device of old man Matt Damon in the graveyard a bunch of shit (and I apologize to Epimemeology Pat if I'm stepping on your toes by mentioning the meme), but his crying became my crying, because that shit felt earned, man. Tough to watch three hours of soldiers dying in continuously heartbreaking fashion and not feel it within you.
The problem, I guess—and this is definitely a me problem, not a movie problem—is that I can be taken out of it by thinking too much about the wonders of "how this movie was made." I can't just take the magic at face value like I used to. Now I'm watching the bonkers Normandy invasion scene and I'm distracted by the sheer size and scale of the efforts it must have taken to film the Normandy invasion scene. I'm thinking "wow, this is fucking impressive!" And it is, don't get me wrong. But that's not what I want out of a film-watching experience. I want to be full immersed. If I'm thinking too much about how good a filmmaker is at immersing an audience in his world, then that means I myself am not immersed.
It seems like a contradiction, but it's not. It's more of a symptom of being interested in movies. It's a gift and a curse. A gift because good movies are so fucking fun, and I love watching films that really go for it. It makes me feel alive. But a curse too because the more I know, the less I'm able to forget what I know. For a sixteen-year-old Joe who does know jackshit about movies, this would've blown my fucking mind. As a 35-year-old Joe who doesn't know much but definitely knows a little more and absolutely devotes more of his brain's space to the art of film, I really fucking enjoyed Saving Private Ryan, but I can't say that I was fully taken by it. It was a worthy experience, to witness the sheer force of this all-timer wartime classic. Of course it was. But I don't walk away changed. I instead walk away impressed at how well the movie was made. There's a big fucking difference there.
If there's room for an extremely light criticism to be lobbed toward this excellent film, it's here, in this space. I don't think Saving Private Ryan did enough to rock my world. I expected excellence and visceral thrills, and I got them, and then some. But I don't think about war any differently than I did prior to viewing, and I don't think about movies any differently than I did prior to viewing, and I don't think about the human condition any differently than I did prior to viewing. This isn't my fault and it's not Saving Private Ryan's fault. The very best films are able to touch some deep part of my soul and cause my sense of wonder to explode. Saving Private Ryan didn't do that. Instead, it gave me a more basic sense of wonder—the wonder of how such a great movie is made.
I think, ultimately, the very very very best films are going to make me forget about all that, and just allow me to experience the movie as if it was a part of me all along. Saving Private Ryan exists separately, and only as a testament to how big and grand and amazing widescreen movies can be. My criticism is an understatement, on purpose. Sometimes it's okay to sit back and marvel at how well a movie is made, and how huge the effort must have been to make it. Spielberg, in my mind, is peerless in his ability to make this kind of movie, the kind that we might crassly refer to as "popcorn films." And if the purpose of this column is to learn the ART OF FILM, then maybe Steven Spielberg is the director I would look to as the guy to get me there. I'm just saying, I wish he didn't have to underline this fact with an autobiographical film about this very subject. But what can ya do.
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
STRAY THOUGHTS: Seriously, there were so many fucking little moments that made my mind think "oh shit, what a masterful filmmaking decision by Steven Allan Spielberg," e.g. the dead fish on the beach, the blood splatter on the lens, the shaggy dog story told by Private Ryan before the big climax, the wild cameo appearances by A-listers, the down-and-dirty wartime fighting like Mike throwing his helmet or the knife fight with Adam Goldberg, no subtitles, the framing of Giovanni Ribisi church monologue, how some pedestrian punches are thrown while the camera is waaaay back and how some dialogue is captured waaaay up close, fuck man, a thousand little moments that could constitute their own blog post in total; and by listing them, I wonder for the 150th time whether these write-ups are too removed from the text and whether I should concentrate on writing more about the films than my experiences with the films; or if it makes more sense to just have people comment with their own thoughts and allow that space to become what other people need, if other people need more from me or from this experience; took us two nights to watch this, obviously, but in between, I looked up Tom Sizemore to find out, and was not disappointed; I also looked up, after the complete viewing was over, about all those details on how each shot was made, Wikipedia had all of that, and that didn't disappoint either (and, if you too are interested, then I suggest you head over to Wikipedia instead of expecting PoYB to repeat everything written there, which would be boring to me); I have never seen Shakespeare in Love so I cannot comment on the 1999 Best Picture award, but maybe one day!
NEXT TIME: With these 148 movies (plus Slacker and West Side Story, which were watched out of alphabetical order), we are officially 3/4ths of the way through Never Seen It! I am going to finish this shit before the end of 2025, I swear to fucking god! The last quarter of our journey begins with Saving Silverman, a film that PoYB contributors Pam and Fisher both want to comment on, it sounds like.

3 comments:
Saving Private Ryan came in #9 on the Tom Hanks Tuesday rankings.
Interesting review. I was expecting you to speak more about how oversaturated you feel War movies have now become and this would be no exception in your mind. Every year it seems like we need to have at least 1 war movie nominated for best picture. What is your opinion about that after watching this film?
Yeah, I hear you, and I agree. I'll go ahead and call myself a war film skeptic. I think we can categorize this under PoYB's Motörhead Theory—in the same way that you can't blame Motörhead for all the speed metal bullshit that it inspired, you also can't blame Saving Private Ryan for inspiring at least one Oscar-bait war movie every year.
Tough to hate a film when the craft is this impeccable, though.
Post a Comment