Friday, October 18, 2024

Manning Fireworks, Joe


This is fine. Okay? It's fine. Fine. I like it. It's fine. I like it and I like listening to it and I think it's fine. Manning Fireworks by MJ Lenderman—totally fine. Nothing to write home about in flowery language, but also nothing worth complaining about to friends while you complete the weekly ritual of the catch-up phone call. Fine.

I like that he purposefully pushed back against the idea of this being "dude rock," Lenderman did, in some interview at some point. That makes it fine too. I am a dude and I like rock and I like dude rock but let's not be reductive here. Let's not limit the audience. Let's also not limit what can be defined as "dude rock," since this album is only fine, and to say it is some epitome of the phrase would be to limit what I hope is a limitless genre.

F — fine

I — I think it's fine

N — no, I don't think I'd use a different word than that, thank you

E — especially not something stronger than fine, in either direction, since fine seems to be perfectly fine

Manning Fireworks sounds like everything that you could possibly place under the umbrella of "dude rock." (I feel like people at one point called this "dad rock," but we are hopefully finally at the place when we can admit that that phrase was even more limiting than "dude rock," and should be relegated to the dustbins of music criticism history.) In that way, it sounds like nothing you've ever heard. Which is fine, in both ways.

There are turns of phrase that tickle me, but not because they are meaningful, more, like, fanciful, or clever, or weird. That makes it fine. There are many mid-tempo guitar-led rock songs, which is fine, because I like that, and sometimes I don't need to be challenged. There are some baffling decisions, like the six minutes of guitar feedback, which is fine because it's at the end, and easily skippable if life deems the skip necessary at whatever juncture you find yourself faced with it. Fine. All fine. Whatever. Fine.

I think MJ's vocals are fine. I don't think he's got a lead-singer voice, which is fine, because rock doesn't require you to have a lead-singer voice in order to be a lead singer. There are many better rock outfits who have worse-sounding vocalists, which is fine, since we shouldn't really compare here. It's also fine that Wednesday is a better fit for MJ Lenderman, since he doesn't sing in that one. The fact that Wednesday lead vocalist Karly Hartzman put on an all-time classic vocal performance on their "Bull Believer"? Totally fine for MJ. It's fine that they dated. It's fine that art gets all twisted like that. It's fine that there are no "Bull Believer"s on Manning Fireworks because how could there be? It's fine. It's fine.

Let us not devalue the word "fine." Fine used to mean of high quality. "Fine leathers" and "fine china" and what have you. In today's post-meta-ironic culture, it seems that we've taken "fine" and made it less fine by that definition, and reversed it like an old T-shirt, inside out, making it to mean "average," or "mediocre." Which is fine. Who cares. Picture a sweaty Robin Williams in late-'50s boys' private school professor outfit, gatherin' the youngins 'round and whispering that fine doesn't have to be fine, that fine can be extraordinary, if you use the right synonym (and if you use "fine" then you might risk not getting laid etc. etc. etc.). Dead Poets Society references in a music review are fine too, if used sparingly. Would've been better if Rip Torn was in that one. Oh well. It's still fine.

This is fine.

F — fine

I — it's nice not needing a thesaurus when describing Manning Fireworks, so thoroughly is it just fine

N — not not fine, which is a fine way to say it's fine

E — every time I hear "Wristwatch" I think that maybe there's a chance that I'm being too dismissive, that this is more than fine, that fine is insulting, that fine is some big joke, like a big joke balloon and all the air is let out of the joke balloon in a big wet fart of a noise of a deflation and now the joke balloon is lying there completely empty of all air I mean joke(?), a small shriveled limp joke balloon, fine because it's served its purpose, fine not like leather or china or sand or lace but fine in that it's just fucking fine, man, it's fine, it's average, I hear "Wristwatch" and I think that this is approaching perfection in how it makes loose jammy rock shit sound so goddamn tight and essential and then we hear that damn "She's Leaving You" again for the 87th time and it's fine but it's not more than that it's just fine it's fine it's devoid of meaning it's fine it's catchy but empty calorie catchy fine fine alt-country fine Drive-by Truckers almost but more fine just fine okay fine.

I like the idea of MJ Lenderman writing down random phrases that come into his mind and then trying to stitch them together. That's a fine idea. It explains the arbitrary bullshit scattered all over this thing that sounds great until you examine it and try to figure out what it means and realize it means nothing except for what you inject into it yourself which is fine but do ya really wanna be served a blank canvass and have to do all the work yourself I might ask. Sure: fine. I think he's fine at what he does. I think it's fine, how he pulls it off here.

I think it's fine how I don't seem to be connecting with it in the way that other likeminded, rock-minded dudes of the dude rock scene seem to be connecting to it. I can't tell if that's reactionary on my part, or something's missing from me, or something's missing from Manning Fireworks, or what. That's fine to not know. It's all fine. I get pleasure from this music. I like listening to it. I just don't understand why it's been given the royal treatment, the hyperboles written from the Steve Hyden types, the breathless YSC entries. I wonder if something can only be special if it's rare. I wonder if MJ Lenderman regrets being this popular within this specific niche. I wonder if he thinks he's more than just fine, or if he prefers the fine to the more than fine. Either way: fine.

F — fine

I — I think we're almost through here

N — not for nothing, I think fine is just fine, and not the insult it might seem like it is occasionally

E — except I don't know that there is any other word to describe Manning Fireworks, even if fine really does come off like a criticism. It's whatever. It's fine. I can listen, and have listened, to this album four times a day for a full week, and I can imagine a future in which I continue to listen to it far beyond the Record Club obligations. Fine is good. Fine can feel good in certain contexts. Fine is good on a bus on a fall day as the leaves hit the big broadside windows on their way down. Fine is good if you're inclusive to all the non-dudes welcomed into the dude rock circles. Fine is good if you don't wanna be bothered with figuring it out and instead just wanna feel. Fine is fine. I don't care. I'm not upset. It's a good album. It's fine. Fine.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

2 comments:

Nate said...

Yeah, but why do you think it sucks?

Joe K said...

I don't think it sucks. I think it's fine. For proof, please see my review, above.