Prompt: "A song involving the smoking of one or more cigarettes"
Selected by Zach
"Cigarettes and Chocolate Milk"
Rufus Wainwright
Poses, 2001
I think I've written about Zach Braff somewhere else on YSC—will Joe link to it here? [Editor's note: Here is what popped up on a search.] This song is apparently on The Last Kiss soundtrack, another Braff movie.
Gilson's recent Garden State post got me thinking. I don't think there's another movie that I've watched that is both so cringeworthy and also such a cultural milepost in my life.
Garden State is not a good movie. I wouldn't even say it's aged badly. It was bad when it came out, and it's bad now. The lines in the movie make me roll my eyes. "Listen to the Shins. It'll change your life." No one talks like that!
The whole movie wants to make one big point about remembering and love and the girl you have a crush on who you think you could never get. Zach Braff is fulfilling the fantasies of boys everywhere when Natalie Portman falls for him, with him having to put in nearly no effort. An awesome, beautiful, energetic and into-you girl? It's all that a reserved guy who dreams about getting the girl could have ever wanted.
She's the prototypical manic pixie dream girl, of course. There are few roles that do it better. But the movie just relentlessly hits you over the head, again and again and again, with its DEEP and MEANINGFUL message. Every line of dialogue makes my skin crawl with its cheesiness.
And yet the movie resonates. My issue with Garden State is not its inaccuracy. Because it hits a nerve, and that nerve is correct and real.
This movie opened up indie music for me (and for a lot of people). Listening to music like the Shins did, in fact, change my life! Its soundtrack was an icon, a real gamechanger. I would argue it nearly single-handedly birthed a new era of music—the music that's the security blanket for me. I can put on a playlist of music used in Zach Braff movies and I can feel melancholy and hopeful at the same time. It's nostalgic, and it's right. Natalie Portman's character may be a cliché at this point, but there's a reason why the manic pixie dream girl was a hit for a while. It's a fantasy, and it works. I love her character, in spite of myself.
And none of that gets into my personal connections to this movie. I saw this movie in the first month of my freshman year of college with people from my dorm floor (Hayden Hall Floor 9, hell yeah, what a classic name), a few weeks after the Shins played the annual Orientation Week Mystery Concert, which I also attended. My high school girlfriend made me a mix CD that wasn't really a mix CD—it was just the Garden State soundtrack, burned onto a CD she sent me in the mail from Oberlin, Ohio, when I was missing her in New York. The fact that the movie takes place in New Jersey, of course, only adds to its aura for me.
This movie needed to be made. I just wish it had been made better. If, somehow, that had happened, Garden State would be one of my favorite movies of all time.
No comments:
Post a Comment