Puke on Your Birthday, fuck yeah!
Comin' again to save the motherfuckin' day, yeah!
Puke on Your Birthday, fuck yeah!
Watching 200 films I've never seen before is the only way, yeah!
Comin' again to save the motherfuckin' day, yeah!
Puke on Your Birthday, fuck yeah!
Watching 200 films I've never seen before is the only way, yeah!
Team America: World Police
2004
Trey Parker
Fisher, a familiar face around these Never Seen It parts, is back to talk about a movie of his choosing. We each blindly sent four questions to each other, and I've compiled the questions and answers below. Thanks to Fisher for hanging out!
FISHER: What is your sense of the level of difficulty involved in the production? Does this movie earn points on its application of craft alone?
JOE: My sense—both from reading about it, and just assuming—is that puppetry is extremely difficult. I think Parker said that it occasionally took like four hours to get a shot of one of the puppets taking a sip of his drink? I dunno, man, I wouldn't have the patience for that. As with any painstaking attempt at art, there's mad respect involved.
I don't know if I necessarily needed this to be a movie with puppets. Yes, there were plenty of jokes that worked only because they were puppets, and I appreciated those. But did it add to the value of the film? I don't know. I do know, however, that this film probably would not have been on this Never Seen It list if it hadn't stood out in this particular way. It's not just "the political satire from the South Park guys," it's "the political satire from the South Park guys... that was made with puppets, for some fucking reason!" Good or bad, I don't know. But memorable? Hell yeah.
JOE: How have the politics of this thing held up? Like many people my age (but certainly not all), I was generally aware of politics in 2004, and had a superficial dislike of George W. Bush, but I don't know if I could've watched this film and "got" what it was trying to do. So I guess my question is, can you "get" it in 2024, and can whatever you "got" apply to "politics" today?
FISHER: Seventeen-year-old me was scarcely interested in politics. But I also disliked Bush and also couldn't tell you why. I'd say I do "got" it now. And I would say I "got" "enough" of it back "then" in 200"4". That's fun.
I'd say every theme on the surface of this movie is a cynical bug up the asses of Parker and Stone. Global policing, celebrities complaining and soap-boxing, gov't incompetence, megalomaniacs, etc.
I say the politics apply then and now because I say everything I mentioned above is also a bug up my ass. I perceive greed as being the root of all evil. Not very literally *all*, but for ease in speaking I'll say it is. I'll say what they're satirizing in this movie amounts to greed and willful ignorance.
FISHER: Are you surprised it was not a box office hit despite South Park being five years strong? Are the puppets mostly to blame?
JOE: I've said it before and I'll say it again: all matters of "how much money this thing made" always feels a bit outside my wheelhouse. Yes, a film's status as success or flop or whatever can certainly be part of the narrative. But to make any sort of judgment based on dollar signs seems crass and artless. I watched the film, and I would've thought the same way about it that I do now if it had made 4x as much money (or 4x less).
That being said... yeah, I guess it surprises me that it wasn't a success. If only because, ya know, I was familiar with some of the concepts in this film (e.g. I've heard people sing the America fuck yeah song, like in high school), and I'm not really one to know of niche movies like that. At least I wasn't in 2004, anyway. I mean, yeah, it probably could've been something to do with the puppets. Maybe people just hate puppets. Weren't most of the Muppet movies commercial failures too?
JOE: Funniest bit? Least funny bit? I was kind of shocked how many jokes worked well simply by doing something like: "this is funny because it's a puppet doing it."
FISHER: Least funny bit—maybe Michael Moore. I'm raking my brain for stinkers, but this film ain't got many.
"Funniest bit" is crazy. Too many. "I'm not from Hollywood, I'm not going to fuck your mouth, and my time is extremely valuable!" The empath teammate. The croissant lined streets in the opening. The Panama Canal victims all screaming some form of "No me gusta!" Puppet sex. "If you don't believe me... well... I'll put a Jihad on you, too." Gary in the back of the terrorist jeep being chased.
And just laughing at the audacity of the whole thing. The gamble and the chutzpah involved in making something people want to see, but using puppets instead of people. Dear God.
FISHER: Is it too edgelord to be respectable?
JOE: Maybe! "Respectable" feels like a loaded word that I don't want to touch. I respect the idea of this movie existing at all, and I think even the basest, crudest humor couldn't affect any respectability (especially if the film is so self-aware of its crude humor like this one is).
Probably the most "edgelord" joke is the fact that they changed the "Screen" in "Screen Actors Guild" to "Film" and repeated the new acronym ad nauseam. I get why some audiences in 2004 would find it funny, but we are way past that twenty years later.
I don't know if something like the vomit gag would be considered "edgelord," or maybe even the long puppet-sex scenes, but those worked a lot better for me. Probably because they aren't at the expense of anyone else except the puppets themselves?
JOE: I'm not the morality police, and I'm not going to make a judgment as to whether the racism in this film "works" or not. But I was wondering your thoughts on that. There are funny bits in this film that are undeniably racist. E.g. Kim Jong Il's pronunciation, the bit where they "transform" Gary by basically putting him in brownface and pasted-on facial hair. How does this work? Is it because of the targets? Does it have to do with the joke ultimately being on the dumb Americans who are making these jokes? A combo of the two?
FISHER: My honest money says it all works and mostly for the reasons you've described. The mock-Asian voice obviously sticks out. I'm cool with it because I don't see it as a threat. Hindsight is proof for this movie, but generally I think old-timey stereotypes are in play. When something has been recognized as offensive by society for decades, then I suggest it's fair game. What one does with that very delicate material is entirely up to them to succeed or crash and burn.
But I don't think we run the risk of blackface or ching-chong-ping-pong returning to the fore. If the very occasional piece of media exhibits taboo material in a clever way, then I say we're better for it.
FISHER: Did they balance their satirical targets? Did it feel too focused on one kind of societal culprit?
JOE: I'm less concerned about balance. Like, I don't necessarily think it's a problem that "dictator with violent tendencies" and "movie stars with big egos" were given equal weight. That's the audience's responsibility to distinguish between the two, and if you're walking away from Team America under the impression that Michael Moore is comparable to Kim Jong Il, then that's your fault, not Parker and Stone's.
I did find it interesting, and admirable, that the film was completely devoid of any satire of George W. Bush. I had read that they avoided it because satire of George W. Bush was already so prevalent at the time, and I believe them, and probably agree. What new take could you possibly bring to the "Bush is a moron / Bush is a war criminal" topic that hadn't already been brought within the three years after 9/11?
JOE: Do you agree with a recent definition of satire (as found on PoYB) as "something that's funny that doesn't make me laugh"? Why or why not, based on your amount of laughter while watching this film?
FISHER: Oh my good goodness I must most certainly disagree. Watch the business card scene from American Psycho. That's all you need in order to reject this definition. I laughed at a wide range of things, satirical ideas and sight gags a'plenny. We know satire when we see it. Don't think that hard on it, everybody. Everybody, relax.
JOE'S GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: I feel like I'm aware of The Terminator more than a lot of the movies on this list, just through pop culture osmosis, but still, I've never seen it!

1 comment:
Holy shit, I did not realize that today was the film's 20th anniversary until right this second. An absurd coincidence that I swear to god I did not plan.
Post a Comment