Tuesday, October 29, 2024

A Year of Blind Spots: Bad Girls

Joe is working through an arbitrary and unpublished list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


Bad Girls
Donna Summer
1979

Donna Summer occupies a weird little corner of the story of Joe and Pam, and at this point it's impossible to disentangle her from our history. I don't repeat the tale in full detail, but here's an in-case-you-missed-it summary. We met on the night of the Masque formal. The annual tradition of the Masque formal was... well, there were a lot of rituals, as theater kids are known for that sort of thing. One of those rituals is that the last song of the night is always Donna Summer's "Last Dance." Corny pick, because theater kids are corny. Me and Pam were getting to know each other, and we're gonna go out to the bus to hang out, ya know, and I'm like, let's go after this song, and Pam, being impossibly cool, and a skeptic of all corny theater bullshit, hears one note of this corny-ass song, and whispers in my ears: "Let's go to the bus." That was all she wrote, folks.

So my and Pam's relationship started about ten minutes early because Pam hated a Donna Summer song, basically. Not that knowing anything about Donna Summer would have changed my path of destiny; I could have been Donna Summer superfan #1 and I would've thrown her under a goddamn train if it meant making out with a pretty girl. But I really didn't know anything about Donna Summer. Ostensibly, this was my third time hearing "Last Dance," as it was my third Masque formal. Though two years prior I had been mostly likely been too busy preparing to lose my virginity to hear the song. So maybe it was sophomore year when I said to someone, in between sips of jungle juice, "hey, so what is this song again?" And so for basically the last fifteen years, my only context with this artist is that her one song is some dumb fucking theater bullshit.

Bad Girls does everything it can to smash that context into smithereens. It almost gets there. The myth is too durable for it to ever disappear, but I'll cop to the idea of loving this particular Donna Summer album enough that I'd listen to it in full, as opposed to turning it off immediately so I can make out with my wife.

For one, there is a lot on here. It's a double album, and its sound is purposefully large to begin with. It's not all widescreen disco, but that is the bedrock on which the rock elements and sappy ballads rest. It's monstrous. Donna Summer and Giorgio Morder pretty much through one last party for disco, a funeral reception more explosive than even Disco Demolition Night.

Second, there are hits that I immediately recognize. They are right there at the beginning. "Hot Stuff" is one of those songs that has been totally wrung out by commercial pop culture (e.g. you can hear it soundtracking a Capitol One or Lay's Potato Chips TV ad pretty easily in your mind if you wanted to), but still has an immediate impact, if you can distance yourself from that. Right away, it's like, okay, I know this, this chick is not just "Last Dance." And then the title track comes in with its toot toots and beep beeps and you start to get the sense that this is going to be 80 minutes of straight hits.

It's not, though, and so, third, there's variety here. For better or worse. I'm on record in saying that pop albums benefit when they eschew the ballads in favor of all bangers. I don't think that happens today with the Found Drama artists, and I guess it didn't happen in the late '70s either. I prefer the bad girls over the sad girls. No worries. Sometimes, like in "Dim the Lights," the sad morphs into the bad. If not, usually the next song goes hard on the Eurodisco and it's a palate cleanser. The sappy ballads are hitches but not album-ruiners.

The big takeaway, contemporaneously, was that this was more of a "rock" album than a "disco" album. So, fourth: it's disco, too, but I guess it was enough for rock critics to give it its just compliments in 1979. Rolling Stone apparently claimed it was the only other good disco album besides the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack, which is pretty funny. I feel like I discussed this idea when we listened to Parliament for this column—genre still exists but it's less important. I'd rather discuss texture than classification. I don't care if it's rock or disco, but I do care if it's slow rock or fast rock or slow disco or fast disco.

I am also (fifth) enjoying the "concept" of Donna Summer empathizing or role-playing as a sex worker on this album. See it on the cover, see it in a lot of the songs (but not Donna Summer in 1980, who by then had converted hard into Christianity and started to rebuke her own music's themes). I would also call this "corny" if I stripped away the context, but within that context of my choosing, it fits perfectly. It's a role that Donna Summer plays beautifully. It's theater, baby!!

But we've already discussed that on the blog too. It's just interesting to bend nostalgia toward the music, and not the other way around. Donna Summer was there at the beginning, and here she is, found in a different light, through the act of listening to music. Music is powerful like that.

No comments: