Wednesday, October 30, 2024

Never Seen It, #173 of 200: The Texas Chain Saw Massacre

The blog post which you are about to read is an account of the tragedy which befell a group of one youth, in particular Joe K***. It is all the more tragic in that he was young. But, had he lived a very, very long life, he could not have expected nor would he have wished to see as much of the mad and macabre as he was to see that day. For him, an idyllic list of 200 movies he's never seen before became a nightmare. The events of that day were to lead to the discovery of one of the most bizarre crimes in the annals of American history: Puke on Your Birthday's Never Seen It.


The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
1974
Tobe Hooper

Review by Dwyer first, and then my essay below that.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Dwyer

I'm not a horror or "scary movie" kinda guy. For the Halloween season, sure, I make an effort when I can to watch the so-called classics I've never seen before (and for the ones I have seen before, I may rewatch). But once Halloween is over, that's it until next October. I usually find the horror genre to be the lamest and weakest genre compared other genres of film. That's obviously not the case for all horror films. I certainly have seen very good ones in the past like The Shining, The Exorcist, and Halloween to name a few. Other than those, I find horror movies to be well-made but kinda silly (The Conjuring), creative and fun (Scream), or flat-out fucking stupid (Saw). However, The Texas Chain Saw Massacre may have been the first horror movie I've seen that was truly terrifying.

Going into this, I was expecting a shock horror film with lots of gore throughout. I was wrong, and in fact, I don't recall seeing much blood until the final five minutes. This was everything you would ever see or experience in your worst nightmare. So many holy shit moments stand out. The five-minute chase scene that felt like 20 minutes. The haunting ten-minute dinner scene with cannibals laughing as their victim screams. And of course, the final image of Leatherface dancing his way into our own minds as the most terrifying entity in horror movie history. 

I don't think I'll ever watch this again. But there's something to be said for a movie that truly scares the shit out of you. Probably a good thing this was low budget. It was way more effective because of it.

DWYER'S GRADE: 4.5/5 stars

~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I am no horror film afficionado by any means, but I think at this point I have seen enough of them to be comfortable about what I like or don't like. It's easy to trace the evolution of my opinions because, due to the nature of this blog project, I have documented proof of various check-ins I've done with some of the heavies of the genre, and can check back on what I wrote whenever I want. Blogging is helpful for many reasons, and using it to track growth is just one of them.

Though the following films are not the only films on my Never Seen It list that I'd consider "scary," I would argue that these are the five so far that could comfortably call themselves "horror films." In alphabetical order: The Blair Witch Project, Friday the 13th, I Know What You Did Last Summer, It Follows, Psycho. I'm not 100% sure (since I make a habit of avoiding any information about upcoming films), but this might be the last horror film we cover in this installment of PoYB's movie column (depending on what 28 Days Later is about, I guess). I won't bore you with any sort of "summary" of my feelings, but I think it might behoove us to look back, just a little bit. At the very least, use the previous horror films as a comparison point to our understanding of The Texas Chain Saw Massacre. [Editor's note: Dwyer's essay made me realize I forgot about The Shining. Oh well.]

My reaction to the ending of the (pretty short!) film here was this, verbalized to Pam as proof: "I loved how they explained nothing." And I do still hold that opinion, a couple days after watching. I thought the character of Leatherface was vivid and surreal, and I appreciated the fact that they didn't give him a name, that they didn't try to give him some tragic backstory, that they didn't try to claim that actually it was him that was abused originally or some shit, that there were no magical amulets or ancient curses, that this was all just pretty much random fucking happenstance.

Five kids run out of gas at the wrong rest stop, and then get killed for their troubles. Three of the five kids go into Leatherface's house, so they are walking into the danger, and the other two huff and puff their way into the dark woods toward the house before Leatherface catches 'em halfway. My point is that the villain isn't seeking these kids out. They are, instead, accidentally seeking him out. They walk right into his web. He reacts poorly (murder), but you can't say that there was motivation there. Nor was there justification, of fucking course. There was nothing. There were victims, there was a fucked-up dude who was down to kill, and they met in the middle based on pure fucking coincidence. There's something charming about that.

Though I realize that this is somewhat contrary to the big claim I made for I Know What You Did Last Summer. In that August 2022 blog post (I Know What I Wrote Three Summers Ago), I explained that I enjoyed the film because it dared to make you think about whether the villain was right. In other words, it spelled out exactly why the killer was doing the killing, and even kinda sorta made the case that there was justification to be found there. To repeat a point I make to much—this isn't what makes it a good film, necessarily, but it is what makes it an interesting film, and one worth watching. (For the record, the 3/5 pukes score for IKWYDLS makes me think that I liked it but didn't love it.)

I suppose it only works if you put in sincere efforts to make it work. That villain has strong motivation, strong enough to potentially flip our sympathies (almost, if not quite). Friday the 13th didn't do as good a job. There was a hokey backstory about the kid drowning, and his mom taking revenge (I think?). I thought that was a bad movie that made sense to watch because of how much it informed the genre. All the tropes were born there. Couldn't save what was ultimately a corny plot and haphazard film structure. Psycho was worse, regarding "explanations." 98% a great movie, the ending flopped, because an extraneous character tried to explain it to us. That wasn't necessary. Just let the mystery be, and you have yourself a perfect film.

A theme that runs through Blair Witch and It Follows is that maybe it doesn't matter if it makes sense or is explainable or not, as long as it's a well-made film. I had issues with the plot mechanics of It Follows, but there were certain filmmaking decisions that made a big impact on me (e.g. the decision to put some scares in the corner of the screen or in the background of a tracking shot). Blair Witch felt so fresh in its lo-fi creativity that I was more than willing to forgive how terribly it was made (since it was kinda the point, no?). There was very little focus on the "how did this happen?" of the plot in both of these films, which make them similar to Chain Saw Massacre. We're not watching the why, we're just watching the what. Assuming the what is well-done, then it justifies the lack of why. Does that make sense?

Look, I don't know if The Texas Chain Saw Massacre was "well-done" in the way that I'm talking about there. A sense of amateurishness certainly pervades, but it's fifty years old (as of the beginning of this month, it was exactly fifty years old), so that's excusable. It's old, it's supposed to look old. The actors aren't professionals and so they aren't going to be the best actors. The film is breaking new ground in so many ways (like Friday the 13th, it created so many now-established horror genre tropes), and so it's a bit shaky, but that's to be expected for someone blazing a trail without a light out ahead. 

And the plot is simplistic, to its benefit. The film is only 83 minutes long, and maybe 15% of that is Sally Hardesty getting endlessly chased through the dark woods by a chainsaw-wielding Leatherface. And you know what? That's fucking incredible. I don't need to know about Leatherface's childhood. I don't need to know why he doesn't want to give up on the chase. He's just out there killin'. He's gonna kill Sally. That's all anyone needs to know.

Where did this family of cannibals come from? Let the corpse-fucking IP bullshit nineteen other Leatherface fucking prequels tell you about that. I don't care. And neither does this film, the original. They are just there. And they are horrifying. So many visuals are sticking with me, no matter how obvious they were done with an independent film's budget. The grandpa sucking Sally's finger, the truck driver throwing the wrench, the multiple jumps through windows, the bug-eyed hitchhiker with the port wine stain, that goddamn meat hook, Franklin getting chainsawed out of fucking NOWHERE, and of course, the final fade to black as soundtracked by Sally's insane laughter. To me, a good horror film provides visceral imagery like this. There doesn't need to be an explanation. You remember the good stuff.

At the beginning of the post for The Blair Witch Project, I posed a question: does a horror film have to be "scary" to be a successful film in the genre? Years later, I realize that this is too simple of a question. For almost my entire life, I've defined "scary" too literally, and then tended to dismiss horror films because they didn't actually provide for me the emotion of fear. I so rarely experience fear in that way—the kind that releases cortisol and adrenaline into the bloodstream, etc.—that it would be unfair for me to expect a goddamn fictional movie to somehow do it for me. But just because I don't get jumpy all that easily doesn't mean that art can't affect me in other ways, ya know? I think I knew this since Blair Witch, but at this point, we can mark it down as fact. "Scary imagery" can be thoughtful, creative, visceral, intense, artful, gruesome, gory, unforgettable. It can be all that and more, without actually being literally scary.

When Leatherface popped out and chopped up Franklin, my reaction was "holy shit!" This doesn't mean I was scared. It wasn't even a jump scare for me. But I was excited, ya know? It was a surprise. Genuinely surprising. It was against expectations, because Franklin had been built up as an important character, and he was casually murdered in the dark and forgotten about. It was artful in the way that you could tell it was gory but the gore was kept just off camera. And it was visceral due to the sheer volume of the scene. Two bloodcurdling screams plus the incessant, violent whine of the chainsaw, plus, sure, my own "holy shit," all added up to a noise that puts a bullet through that moment.

I am guessing that, when people say that they "enjoy horror films," they are saying that they enjoy these emotions that are wrapped up in the unique experience of watching a "scary movie." It's not that it's literally scary, but more so that many other emotions are heightened, and that can be fun, in a way. I know I'm not writing anything new here. What I'm doing is putting to rest the old, outdated theory that snobby teenage Joe held close to, the one where he said "I don't like scary movies but NOT because I'm scared." Take that old Joe and chop him in half with a chainsaw. Horror films are fucking great.

As long as they are well made, and aren't too corny, and find ways to surprise, and create tropes or put a new spin on them instead of just repeating them, and, I don't know, make me remember them in some way. Not an easy task. I didn't say that I liked all horror films. But I love the good ones. This was a good one.

JOE'S GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Oh lordy, being terribly behind on the blogging this week is a TERRIBLE time to commit to watching the almost FOUR-HOUR religious(?) film The Ten Commandments. Maybe I'll like it. Maybe I'll have wished that I was chainsawed to death instead.

3 comments:

Kait said...

I just watched this movie this morning. Thought for years I had already seen it but I hadn’t. I loved it. Joe, read your post and while I agree the movie didn’t really spend time diving into Leatherface’s motive/backstory, I think it’s pretty obvious in the family dynamics. The family all comes together for that dinner and we see Leatherface straight up afraid of his uncle? I think that’s an uncle. Some older family/authority figure, and it makes you wonder, how much of this was Leatherface taught? Like his terrifying brother said, they’re a meat family. Always been in the business of meat. Makes you wonder how the hell they all grew up full knowing grandpa was a serial killer, as well. I agree though that I enjoyed how the movie just showed you what it is, placed us right there in that family and in that house and here’s a day in the life, folks. Wonderfully chilling!

I also think the brother is just as, if not more terrifying than Leatherface. His whole performance in the van was so unnerving, and his giddiness, and him mocking Sally at the dinner table? So scary. I also totally thought grandpa was dead until he started sucking on Sally’s finger.

I have some thoughts about how this film portrays disability - especially the friends/sally treating him like a burden. And then Leatherface has an intellectual disability arguably the brother does as well? Using disability as “scary” is nothing new and I won’t be the one to write on that when I imagine that’s dissected heavily on the internet. Just something that stood out to me in this film.

The set, the props, the chase scene - holy shit did I love it. I would have LOVED to work on the set design here. They did such a good job at creating a terrifying home for this family and for the friends to stumble upon. Good good stuff.

Kait said...

Ope* when I say treating him* like a burden I mean Franklin. Not Leatherface or the brother.

Joe K said...

Damn, that's such a good point. You're finding a space in between the binary I presented of "knowing the backstory" and "not knowing the backstory." How you can maybe not know it but also infer it. Now that you say it, the inferring probably makes it a scarier film, right? How it hints at things and because it's a horror movie, you infer the worst, scariest version of the truth. Which is a lot scarier than "here is a history of this family's butchering business from 1936 to 1973."

I also appreciate your thoughts about ablism in this movie. Overall, I just really appreciate the fact that you came back to an old blog post and wrote some thoughts after you watched the movie. Feels cool that there's a space where we can have conversations about a piece of art months or years after the fact. Thanks for this.