Record Club covered this album exactly five years ago. I gave it another listen this week. Here are some thoughts.
Essentials
Erika de Casier
Week 37: October 13-19. 2019
Here's another one I had to redownload after deleting it from my iPod at some unknown time. Probably the end of 2019, if I had to guess? At that point, Record Club was still getting its feet wet. I didn't feel about every album like I would today—that they are important because they are Record Club albums. I can retroactively feel that way about Essentials. (It's even in the goddamn name!)
I am rereading all the reviews like I usually do (not hard when you were averaging 2.667 a week), and I will say that I am liking this album a lot more than the reviews, especially mine, would indicate that I would. I don't know if my mind is warped from doing RC for almost 300 weeks in a row now or what. But if I had a do-over (which I guess I do right this second, technically), I would say that this is a real nice album, and fun at times.
Like, okay, my big point was that it was a "knock-off" of '90s R&B pop, which, yes, is definitely true. But probably the wrong way of looking at it. I can substitute "knock-off" with "homage," perhaps. Clearly Erika de Casier is a fan of this music. She's doing her own thing, twenty to thirty years later. She's putting her own spin on it, or maybe just half-spin, but still. It's old and it's new. And there's value in that.
So I would mirror what Nate said about this being "not for me," but frame that in a more positive way (not to say that Nate was wrong—the review as a tribute to his cousin's taste in music is beautiful, and the negative review for de Casier does nothing to tarnish that). This is not for me... but also, it's fun enough that I wish it was. I wish I loved '90s R&B pop and could appreciate the sounds that Erika de Casier layers on top of it. I'm almost there, but not quite. I'm lacking in historical perspective, that's all.
Like, I wonder if there was any sense that she was purposefully taking these sounds to an extreme at any point. I hear something like "What U Wanna Do?" and the tinny synth is SO LOUD and I just wonder if she is purposefully foregrounding a lot of the stuff that might be in the background of a Destiny's Child song from back in the day. I think that's pretty cool. I was thinking about this too during the occasional but very prominent "pop!" sound in "Space." It's noticeable, but in a good way. Still not "for me," but I like it nonetheless.
All that talk about "spa" was just me not knowing how to describe music. Which is fine. I have grace and patience for my former self. That's how it should be in your 37th album review. That frantic grasping for the right description calms in time. I would be perplexed to hear Erika de Casier in a spa. I would be perplexed to find myself at a spa, but that's a different story.
Big story here is that I'm glad Erika de Casier is in my life. Again. She left and then returned when the time was right, when I was more mature. Bump it up to at least 3 pukes out of 5, fam.

No comments:
Post a Comment