Prompt: "A song where the protagonist tries to do something but fails"
Selected by Joe
"Slide 2 Me"
Drug Church
PRUDE, 2024
kind of sort of adapted from an email between friends
[Q]?
You're right, this was real good. I am legitimately curious what exactly in this interview you feel would make me angry, though. Or if you are just saying that because you know the accusations of it "making me angry" will be the thing that makes me angry. I've typed too much about cancellation. Now I need you to tell me about me, and I will correct you if needed. What in here do I disagree with?
[Q]?
I mean, we can joke around about me being angry, but I hope you know in truth that I'm not really "angry." I'm appreciative of the chance to discuss this stuff, for one. For another, I do feel strongly about this, so sometimes that comes off as anger. Ozzi even says this in the interview! "I care about this shit and to my friends it just sounds like anger." It's not!
Sidenote: "Shithead" is, in my opinion, more specific than just people generally being shitty. For me (my choice), it's sexual/domestic abuse and explicit/conscious racism. The distinction is important. Someone can just be an asshole and that's not necessarily disqualifying.
[Q]?
"Catch a subfraction of their stink" is another way of saying that I would be judgmental of that person, in that case. But I honestly am not trying to be judgmental. Yes, I personally believe that I would feel uncomfortable engaging in these specific cases. Yes, I find it hard to empathize with people who don't feel uncomfortable. But Not Being Judgmental is a goal for me. If I've judged, that means I've failed. But it gets tricky because our shared passion is talking about music, right? And so when it comes to this particular choice, there's a huge disconnect. I don't know how to say "I don't listen to that because the dude beat his pregnant wife" without it sounding judgmental. But I can't just ignore it, ya know?
[Q]?
[Q]?
Yeah but see that's where I think that me and Drug Church guy disagree. I've honed my thoughts in the hour since I've read the interview.
1) He posits that to accuse someone of being abusive (or implicitly accuse them of being abusive through the act of not listening to the abuser's music) is IRRESPONSIBLE, that it's reckless, whereas the act of listening to good tunes because they are good tunes no matter who the artist is, that is the RESPONSIBLE thing to do. Yes, of course there are moronic new-age puritan assholes online who are going to irresponsibly throw around those terms in the hopes of getting rid of an artist. But I personally try really fucking hard to be responsible about this, to think about it. I think about it too much! I'm not reckless! I care so much about music that it hurts, and losing a band I love is like chopping off my goddamn arm. No consideration from this dude for people like me.
2) He also implies that the term "abuser" is used as libel against someone who is not an abuser, and that when that happens, the libel, that shit sticks. Does it? He provides no examples. Can you? I'm thinking about the Dan Boeckner thing discussed in the RC@5 Operators thing. People no doubt read that and called him an "abuser." I don't consider that to make him an abuser, and you don't either, and I have had heard nothing about Dan Boeckner being "cancelled" or people actively trying to "cancel" him or have given even one personal second of my time to the notion that I'm not listening to Wolf Parade anymore. Where are all these people whose lives were ruined because they were falsely accused of being an "abuser"? Another implication that people are reckless with this shit. Seems frighteningly close to the conservative argument of "FAKE NEWS!"
[Q]?
[Q]?
I don't want to be judgmental about people listening to music they wanna listen to. I am NOT judging Patrick Kindlon because he listens to nazi bands or whatever. What I AM judging Patrick Kindlon on is basically calling me a liar and a fraud, even though all I ever wanted to do was to listen to music and feel good while listening to it.
[Q]?
[Q]?
No of course I don't judge other people for what they listen to. That feels like projection. But again, I don't really know how to frame my personal feelings about the music I listen to and the music I don't feel comfortable listening to anymore without using language that could be seen as judgmental. Every time I write about this, I trip over myself with protestations of "I swear I'm not judging you, I'm talking about myself!" to the point that I feel kinda pathetic every time I even bring it up at this point.
[Q]?
[Q]?
That's what Kindlon is saying. We disagree on this. We obviously listen to music differently. When I listen to music, I need to trust that the artist is relaying some sort of truth. Not factual truth, more like: emotional truth. And that trust is lost if the artist is a rapist, or has expressed beliefs of wanting to exterminate minority populations, or something like that. How could I listen to that music, in that context? No matter how great the music is?
And I think where we disagree here—me and the Patrick Kindlon types—is whether it's okay to turn that question around and ask: "How can you listen to it?" We are NOT arguing about whether it's okay to listen to the music. Yes, it's okay! Do what you want! But Kindlon et al. takes it further than that. He seems to be saying here, in this interview, that not only can he listen to whatever he wants to (which is true), but also, I am not allowed to ask him about it, or else I'm a stuck-up liberal pussy who is trying to silence him. Which is fucked up, and wrong, and ignorant. That's the problem I have with it. Do you see the distinction?
[Q]?
Hahaha, yeah man, it's fucking great. I don't know if that counts as irony. But I love it. Maybe one of the best albums of the year, we'll see. It's hitting a sweet spot though.
[Q]?
Because what has Patrick Kindlon done to make me feel uncomfortable about it? I've already explained my terms, ad nauseam. Being a fucking prick in general terms is not disqualifying, emotionally speaking. Even if he was actually part of this conversation, right now, hypothetically, say he's right here, getting CC'd on this shit, and he chimes in and says "hey Joe K*** you sound like a little fucking bitch and I don't want you listening to Drug Church because you're a cancel-happy cunt and this album wasn't made for people like you," then I'd still like the album, because that's some good inflammatory and safe rhetoric that adds to the art. Being an asshole is fine. Being a rapist or a racist is not. Huge fucking difference. But now I'm repeating myself.
[Q]?
[Q]?
Probably the one about the protagonist failing. "Slide 2 Me" has a good hook about the protagonist attempting to rob a liquor store and getting shot for his efforts. The money line is "he's been waiting his whole life." Referring to the liquor store clerk who shoots him. Pretty interesting idea there, one that I think about a lot, how a function of conversative fear of others is this sort of wannabe hero shit where they daydream about someone trying to do them harm—i.e. someone justifying their fears—so that they have a reason to do harm back.
[Q]?
See, that's the funny thing. I feel like this is the reason I am able to connect to the themes on this Drug Church album so much. I find kinship in Kindlon's ability to see life from that angle. That nuance. There are some people that would say "oh yeah, fuck that robber, he deserves to die," and there are some people that would say "society is fucked that we put some people in the position that they feel like they need to steal to survive and put other people in the position that they are so bloodthirsty that they'll take any chance to kill someone"... and then there are people who take a more holistic view of the situation. Approach it without judgment. That's what this is! That's what we're talking about! Kindlon is refusing to judge. When he's gruffly singing from that viewpoint over some heavy guitar riffs, I really like it. I really like the music, and the story within that music. It fits well with my own worldview. The thing we disagree on happens outside of his music. There's tolerance, and then there is the tolerance paradox.
[Q]?
I dunno. Something like that.
[Q]?
See, that's the funny thing. I feel like this is the reason I am able to connect to the themes on this Drug Church album so much. I find kinship in Kindlon's ability to see life from that angle. That nuance. There are some people that would say "oh yeah, fuck that robber, he deserves to die," and there are some people that would say "society is fucked that we put some people in the position that they feel like they need to steal to survive and put other people in the position that they are so bloodthirsty that they'll take any chance to kill someone"... and then there are people who take a more holistic view of the situation. Approach it without judgment. That's what this is! That's what we're talking about! Kindlon is refusing to judge. When he's gruffly singing from that viewpoint over some heavy guitar riffs, I really like it. I really like the music, and the story within that music. It fits well with my own worldview. The thing we disagree on happens outside of his music. There's tolerance, and then there is the tolerance paradox.
[Q]?
I dunno. Something like that.
[Q]?
Yeah, man, pretty much everything I write is gonna end up on there eventually in some form.
[Q]?
I do not care about journalistic standards. It's a dumb blog.
[Q]?
Do you even have access to an octagon? Or is that a reference that I don't understand?
2 comments:
These are your peers and you've just got to deal with it.
[Q]?
Post a Comment