"Sympathy is a knife (Remix)"
Charli XCX ft. Ariana Grande
from brat and it's completely different but also still brat
2024
We're deep into October and it's sincerely looking like this song from brat is gonna be sitting at the top of the PoYB Best Songs of 2024 list. I've written some words about it already; I'm gonna write some more in December even if it's just Top Three or something. I don't need to write words now, because, when I say "this song," I'm not talking about this song that's embedded in this blog post. That's a different song. It's completely different but also still the same song.
It was a brat summer for sure, but summer is over. brat has been rereleased in remix form. I liked brat the first time around, and I don't necessarily need to listen to new versions of the songs that are still hitting me so goddamn hard, even this far past Labor Day. We listened to the remixes once; it's not for me. That's okay. It's weird that a certified A-grade pop album has stuck around this long anyway, and I can't really expect a dark mirror version of it to be just as impactful. Beyond the breathtaking and incredibly ballsy Lorde feature in the song about Lorde, I think we can say that brat and it's completely different but also still brat is still brat but it's too completely different to be still brat.
That Lorde feature still sounds like "Girl, so confusing," is the thing. If you listen to "Sympathy is a knife" featuring Ariana Grande, you get completely different vibes than the o.g. "Sympathy is a knife." It strips everything nervy and electrifying and courageous and humbling about the first one and gets kinda lazy with it.
Whatever. Look, now that brat summer is over, Charli XCX did the only reasonable thing she could do. She killed brat. It was a ritual sacrifice. It was a regal send-off. She shot that flaming arrow into the sky and it landed on "Sympathy is a knife" and I stood on the shore and, with one single tear slowly falling down my cheek, I saluted a life well lived. It was worth it, oh, so worth it.
No comments:
Post a Comment