Monday, August 12, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 114: Joe

Prompt: "The song that should've been playing out of Lloyd Dobler's boombox instead of that stupid Peter Gabriel song (i.e. I gave her my Song Challenge prompt and she gave me a pen)"

Selected by Joe


"The Writhing South"
Say Anything
...Is a Real Boy, 2004

So I read the emo book. Where Are Your Boys Tonight? by Chris Payne. It's an oral history of the third-wave emo music that was mainstream-popular in the '00s. I guess it's time to shoehorn my thoughts into a blog post. I wouldn't recommend trying to write your thoughts about a book three months after you read it. It makes for a poor experience for everyone involved. But I learned about the book through Yearlong Song Challenge, and it makes sense that the only all-caps GREAT song that I discovered via the book would be a song coming out of Lloyd Dobler's speakers in Say Anything..., since the name of the movie and the name of the band are the same (minus the annoying ellipsis), and plus Max Bemis' bipolar disorder puts him on the same level of emotional stability as the madman Dobler himself, and so, hey, why not talk about some fucking book while we're here. It just makes sense.

I thought the book was fine. I often wondered how self-aware the book was in what it was doing. In taking all the characters from this specific movement at this specific time, and letting them tell the story, there was a sense that the story was made to be a lot more important than it actually was. If your only understanding of Hot Topic-core is from this book, then this music is going to seem like the end-all-be-all of emo music. It makes sense from an emotional standpoint that those involved are going to hype up this thing that they built, I'm not saying otherwise. I'm just saying that the book and its author did very little to rein it in or give any sort of perspective on this thing, and that was to its detriment. Sure, the postscript gave a perfunctory mention of the other third-wave emo stuff that was going on at the time, the real good stuff, the American Football et al. that blows most of the Panic! bullshit out of the water, but that mention felt more like an oopsies than any sort of genuine attempt at reaching for the truth.

On the other hand, I enjoyed the mythmaking at play here. I always do. So what if these emo has-beens are puffed-up bullshitters? I love hearing a group of people talking about the good ol' days. There's passion at work here, and I felt that passion. It probably made me dislike this particular subgenre of music, like maybe the mythmaking spoiled it for me in some way. But as a story, I liked hearing the myths. I don't know if that makes sense. Let me try again: you ever learn how to do a sleight-of-hand magic trick? You're more knowledgeable, and it's neat learning, but it strips away the magic. I liked learning all about Fall Out Boy, but learning about Fall Out Boy made and vague potential for magical listening experiences completely disappear. I think I hate Fall Out Boy now.

I recognized the name of the author, Chris Payne, and was delighted to find that he had written a great piece on Stereogum in the recent past about My Chemical Romance's debut album. When I read that anniversary piece (prior to reading the book), I hadn't heard the album yet, but I knew right away this dude was speaking my language. He was talking about how the music was important because it told a story, and that story becomes your story, the audience's story. I love that, and I think about that all the time. I almost wish that Payne had taken that same mindset and applied it to this whole "scene" himself instead of letting the members of that scene tell their story. The best thing about music is how you can insert yourself into the story. This is what makes music important. And I thought that Where Are Your Boys Tonight? unfortunately did a great job at removing the audience from that story, which made the whole thing feel disconnected.

I wonder if the exclusion of Gerard Way was intentional on his part or on the author's part. Maybe both, or maybe the latter on in retrospect. Because: it worked. It allowed all the other characters (including his brother Mikey) to build Gerard up as this sort of mythical figure. Every book needs a hero. Had the book allowed that hero to speak, he would've seemed just as pedestrian as the rest of these jabronis. Instead, we allow the hero to exist slightly to the left of the screen, mysterious and exciting and legendary.

Probably the thing I'll remember most from this book was something that came out as almost an aside, but still resonated with me enough that I've thought about it a lot in the past three months. There was a lot of talk about Gerard Way's struggles with alcoholism, and how he decided to get sober. Again, this is all from outside perspectives, since Gerard was not interviewed. And I forget who said it (maybe Mikey), but they described the sobriety as "gaining a superpower." It's simple and maybe a little trite and probably obvious to most people, but it was honestly something I really needed to hear this summer.

Because, like, I have spent so much time in the past sixteen months worried that sobriety has stripped something away from me, has diminished me in some way as a person. I do think in some ways that's absolutely true, but if the self-outlook is a matter of optimism, then I was stunned by the description of sobriety as a superpower, how taking something away can actually make someone stronger. I don't even know if this is what was meant in describing Way in this way—I think it had more to do with a description of Way getting angry with douchebags in the audience, and how he felt empowered to call 'em out because he was of clear mind—but it's still helpful for me to think about it this way. I've thought about it in pretty much every social interaction I've had this entire summer, and have felt the confidence swell as I remember Gerard flourishing in sobriety and being described by his friends as "having superpowers."

But that's me inserting myself into the story, and we've already established that this is not what Where Are Your Boys Tonight? is about. So that beautiful interlude with Hayley Williams describing growing up in the scene and thinking fondly about the halcyon days of Warped Tour without letting that nostalgia act as an albatross as the years go by (I think she describes it as something like "it was a beautiful summer but there will be plenty more summers afterward")... I get the sense that we're supposed to be taking this all literally, and not really believe that the book is attempting to make some grand statement about life itself. Which is a shame, because I really did benefit from some of these stories about how time presses on us as the years stack up, and the emotional affect of being so far gone from the stories you're still telling, and all that stuff. I don't think that's what Payne had in mind here. Which is fine. It's whatever.

But it should not be a surprise that the one album that I downloaded in the wake of reading this oral history was the album that was described within that oral history as one that serves as a meta-statement on the scene itself. ...Is a Real Boy, I'm told, is both an emo album of that era and also about emo albums of that era. I like that, and I appreciate the album (and really appreciate how "Wow, I Can Get Sexual Too" is a bonus track, since it is undoubtedly one of the worst songs of this scene or any scene ever). It's whiny, but in a way that you can just tell is slightly parodic and contains heaps of self-awareness. Rather than get defensive about third-wave goth-adjacent emo music all sounding like this, it instead leans into the curve.

Even though it's been years and years, I think it's probably comparable to the movie Say Anything..., in that I felt, at least at the time, that Say Anything... was both a cheesy teen rom-com and also had something to say about the characters that you'd typically find in a cheesy teen rom-com. I was a teenager too, and I also misinterpreted signs of love and romance and betrayal in some now-cringeworthy ways (e.g. Ctrl+F "Lloyd Dobler" HERE). That's part of growing up, and I think it's important to have documentation via art that is self-aware of that process. Say Anything and Say Anything... are self-aware in that crucial way. "The Writing South" would be a terrible song for Lloyd Dobler to play to the supposed love of his life, and that's what makes it perfect.

Decent book, though. Thanks for the recommendation, Sixers Sisters.

5 comments:

Gilson said...

Wait are there now two emo books? Nothing Feels Good is the OG

Joe K said...

Ooh, that looks good. I could do with some more info about first-wave emo. I guess Where Are Your Boys Tonight? is more of a sub-genre book, being about a specific kind of emo, rather than an overview of its history. "The Emo Book" being more of a descriptor of the emo book that has been mentioned a half dozen times now on this blog.

Joe K said...

I couldn't fit this short anecdote into the blog post, so I'll write it in a comment. Around 2011-2012, I sorted paperwork at a medical supply company. The highlight of my year there was filing a receipt for a customer literally named Diane Court who had ordered an EpiPen. (The fact that this was a highlight says a lot about how much I disliked that job.)

sunny said...

Hearing about the emo book Where Are Your Boys Tonight? so much this summer, it feels like it's going to become part of a Slumdog Millionaire style plot in the future.

Maeve said...

I am thankful for this review that I have been waiting for for months.