Prompt: "An otherwise great song with a really annoying intro or outro"
Selected by Joe
"Off the Record"
My Morning Jacket
Z, 2005
I slightly regret this prompt, because I talk a big game about respecting the artistry of the artist and the choices they make when they are creating art, and yet the existence of this prompt tips my hand that there are certain scenarios in which I really do wish that the artist had made a different decision for my own personal selfish benefit. I hate The Big Playlist because it kowtows to the algorithm, and it's lazy, and it's disrespectful toward the artist who labored to create something precious that you are now destroying, etc., etc., etc., but yeah, sometimes I make playlists for parties or gatherings.
There are rules that disqualify otherwise deserving songs from making such a playlist, and it's a bummer when a song isn't eligible because it's got a long intro or outro that would damper the mood, even if the meat of the song is more than worthy. I always think about this song from My Morning Jacket when I consider the rule, since, for some fucking reason, My Morning Jacket decided to take what would otherwise be an excellent three-minute banger and tack on two and a half extra minutes of a much more low-key jammy noodling exercise at the end of the song.
I get it. I get that My Morning Jacket is a jam band masquerading as a indie rock band, and that extended outros like this one betray their true intentions. I get that the outro here probably makes it a more interesting song, and enjoyable in the same way we cheer for bands when they come out for an encore because we just don't want the good times to end. I get that complaining about it in any context is paramount to me disrespecting My Morning Jacket, which is not my intentions, especially when talking about a song from my favorite album of theirs. Still, though, I can't help but regret grieving all the countless moments that I lost out on in both my previous life and occasionally current life too, all those small moments during large parties that are anchored by a steady soundtrack of uncontroversial indie rock bangers, all the times I could've lifted a red plastic cup in toast to "Off the Record," some of the best shit that MMJ ever pulled off, moments that couldn't happen because of that damn outro, whose decrease in volume and energy would've thrown the party's tempo into complete disarray.
There are rules that disqualify otherwise deserving songs from making such a playlist, and it's a bummer when a song isn't eligible because it's got a long intro or outro that would damper the mood, even if the meat of the song is more than worthy. I always think about this song from My Morning Jacket when I consider the rule, since, for some fucking reason, My Morning Jacket decided to take what would otherwise be an excellent three-minute banger and tack on two and a half extra minutes of a much more low-key jammy noodling exercise at the end of the song.
I get it. I get that My Morning Jacket is a jam band masquerading as a indie rock band, and that extended outros like this one betray their true intentions. I get that the outro here probably makes it a more interesting song, and enjoyable in the same way we cheer for bands when they come out for an encore because we just don't want the good times to end. I get that complaining about it in any context is paramount to me disrespecting My Morning Jacket, which is not my intentions, especially when talking about a song from my favorite album of theirs. Still, though, I can't help but regret grieving all the countless moments that I lost out on in both my previous life and occasionally current life too, all those small moments during large parties that are anchored by a steady soundtrack of uncontroversial indie rock bangers, all the times I could've lifted a red plastic cup in toast to "Off the Record," some of the best shit that MMJ ever pulled off, moments that couldn't happen because of that damn outro, whose decrease in volume and energy would've thrown the party's tempo into complete disarray.
Note that the official video for this song on My Morning Jacket's official YouTube channel completely excises the outro, which I'm choosing to believe that MMJ knows that sometimes even making the completely correct decision can be seen as a fuck-up to some people. I refuse to download this bastardized version of the song, though, even if MMJ is ostensibly saying it's okay, because I that's how seriously I take this shit. The version that I know and love is on an album that I know and love and it's five minutes and thirty seconds and no one, not even Jim fucking James himself, is going to convince me otherwise. I will cancel every party for the rest of my life if it means that the real version of this song continues to exist.
And, like, let's be fucking real here, how often am I making party playlists these days? No, instead of worrying about all that nonsense, I get to rest and relax and with peace and solitude put on Z and listen to a great motherfucking album and marvel at the extended coda of "Off the Record," in private, a secret, just for me. Music can be good in a vacuum too, and doesn't always need to be functional for your social-emotional needs.
In the spirit of this song in its full, coda-extended glory, I will now tack on a completely unnecessary but hopefully worthy postscript of my own to this blog post.
And, like, let's be fucking real here, how often am I making party playlists these days? No, instead of worrying about all that nonsense, I get to rest and relax and with peace and solitude put on Z and listen to a great motherfucking album and marvel at the extended coda of "Off the Record," in private, a secret, just for me. Music can be good in a vacuum too, and doesn't always need to be functional for your social-emotional needs.
In the spirit of this song in its full, coda-extended glory, I will now tack on a completely unnecessary but hopefully worthy postscript of my own to this blog post.
I remember every single person who has ever touched my iPod during a party. That's like rule fucking number one. Don't touch my iPod. Don't change the fucking music at someone else's party. It's fucking insane that I need to spell this out. It's one of the most selfish things you can do. I design a playlist to play in support of the party itself. When you change the music, then you are insisting that the focus is directed toward you yourself. There is so much ego in that decision that it makes me sick. I made the playlist so that you don't have to think about the music (or me). Touching the iPod is an act of violently pulling the spotlight toward yourself. I hate it. Every single time that it's ever happened to me is burned into my fucking brain forever.
I won't name and shame here, though. No one who is writing for Yearlong Song Challenge has ever done it. Nate touched my iPod once, but it was actually excusable. This occurred at Sam's bachelor party, right after Zach had sex with the sex doll. I had my iPod going but someone, without my knowledge, switch the shuffled playlist from Summer 2015 (approved party music) to Music from 2015 So Far (not approved party music), which meant that eventually a Science Club song popped up, right in the middle of a game of LCR, so I don't blame him for fixing the mistake that someone else made. Not that the music from Science Club itself is a "mistake"—as painful as this will be for Nate to hear, that band had some great tunes—but rather I would never purposefully put anyone in the position that they have to hear their own voice coming out of the speakers during a party, since that betrays some basic tenets of the party playlist system, mainly "no distracting songs." Plus I was drunk and living the good life and had just won like $250 from LCR, so it's all good.
I won't name and shame here, though. No one who is writing for Yearlong Song Challenge has ever done it. Nate touched my iPod once, but it was actually excusable. This occurred at Sam's bachelor party, right after Zach had sex with the sex doll. I had my iPod going but someone, without my knowledge, switch the shuffled playlist from Summer 2015 (approved party music) to Music from 2015 So Far (not approved party music), which meant that eventually a Science Club song popped up, right in the middle of a game of LCR, so I don't blame him for fixing the mistake that someone else made. Not that the music from Science Club itself is a "mistake"—as painful as this will be for Nate to hear, that band had some great tunes—but rather I would never purposefully put anyone in the position that they have to hear their own voice coming out of the speakers during a party, since that betrays some basic tenets of the party playlist system, mainly "no distracting songs." Plus I was drunk and living the good life and had just won like $250 from LCR, so it's all good.
The only other time I'm comfortable writing about here was already implicated on the blog, last summer, when Dwyer wrote about the Smiths, and totally misrepresented me in that blog post, on purpose because he was trying to stir shit (and, ya know, I'm not denying that I deserve that on the blog, since I don't miss a single opportunity to link to Dwyer's Joker Impression on this blog, because I know it upsets him). Yes, I was asked by Dwyer to make a playlist for his Hoboken gathering. Yes, our pal Alex, right in the middle of the gathering, took the aux cord out of my iPod and put it into his phone, and decided to play Smiths songs for the rest of the night. I remember it clearly because I told you at the beginning of this postscript that I remember every instance of this happening over the past twenty years.
I also remember chilling at the Chestnut Hill McNally's sometimes after that incident with Dwyer and Alex and Pam and having a nice chat about the Smiths, and Alex expressing surprise that I like the Smiths, since I had roasted him so thoroughly in Hoboken a year prior over his decision to play the Smiths at a party. Of course it wasn't that band's fault. Maybe the Smiths aren't generally good party music across the board, but there are more than a couple songs that I would place on a playlist without losing sleep over it. It was the fact that SOMEONE TOUCHED THE PLAYLIST THAT I MADE SPECIFICALLY FOR THIS PURPOSE that pissed me off. And I know Dwyer knows this, and he knew it before he wrote that blog post last year, because he was there eating Schmitters at McNally's with the rest of us. Dwyer is probably lucky that he isn't doing YSC, because then I would've included a song for him last Thursday, and I probably would've tried to find a song called "I Cummed My Jeans at the Strip Club."
If I ever have a party again—which, who knows—then I implore you not to touch the music. Take your indie rock medicine and be glad that I'm not forcing you to listen to two-and-a-half-minute jam band coda bullshit while you drink your beer and eat your charcuterie.
If I ever have a party again—which, who knows—then I implore you not to touch the music. Take your indie rock medicine and be glad that I'm not forcing you to listen to two-and-a-half-minute jam band coda bullshit while you drink your beer and eat your charcuterie.
1 comment:
This choice for this prompt is the most correct you’ve ever been.
Post a Comment