Thursday, March 12, 2026

Never Seen It #297: Days of Wine and Roses

You remember how it really was? You and me and a blog—a threesome. You and I were a couple of bloggers on the sea of blog, and the boat sank. I got hold of something that kept me from going under, and I'm not going to let go of it. Not for you. Not for 400 movies I've never seen before. Not for anyone. If you want to grab on, grab on. But there's just room for you and me—no blogging threesome.


Days of Wine and Roses
1962
Blake Edwards

Alright gang. Sit down, pull up a drink, and scroll down to see what we thought of this one.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Catherine

They are not long, the days of wine and roses:
Out of a misty dream
Our path emerges for a while, then closes
Within a dream.

Who picked this bummer of a film?? Whoops.

All I knew when I made my selection was that it was a Jack Lemmon-led '60s romance. Fun! ...I was wholly unprepared to meet the Sid and Nancy of the Lawrence Welk set.

In retrospect, it's a perfect title. Along with the poem, it really captures the fleeting euphoria alcohol can bring before it takes a sharp turn to misery. Or at least a slow, numbing joylessness leaving you nostalgic for how you used to feel. But it was painful to watch.

God, I hate Joe Clay. I hated witnessing Kirsten be corrupted turn after turn by such a useless BUM. 

In brief:
  • She wants nothing to do with him so he bullies her into a date.
  • She's perfectly happy sober, he doesn't understand or accept that, so he TRICKS her into drinking.
  • She's trying to be a good mom but it makes him insecure to be the only drunk one so she dives into oblivion with him as an act of loving solidarity.
  • She's succeeding in her sobriety, he's tempted to jump off the wagon, so he drags her along.
  • Then it's too late. He gets sober again, she can't. He gets better, and she's a lost cause wandering out into the darkness to drink herself to death. Sammen i himmelen, I guess. It's not fair. No amount of checks to her father will correct all the damage Joe has done.
I like to imagine a Christmas Carol-type pivot in the movie where we find out this is all just a bad dream brought to Kirsten by a benevolent ghost to show her what a train wreck her life would become if she lets Joe in. She wakes up before she ever gets on the boat, gleefully chomps on a little chocolate bar, and the credits roll. Trust your instincts, KA.

While I watched, I kept vacillating between two opposing takes: This a poignant, fascinating and accurate presentation of substance abuse, and this is kinda like Reefer Madness for booze.

When Joe ends his nursery-smashing bender in a straight jacket, gnashing his teeth at a horde of needle-wielding orderlies, I couldn't help but think we needed to rein it in just a bit.

Then he meets Jim, his AA sponsor, and their conversations are deep and unexpectedly raw and capture so much of the complicated psychological aspects of alcoholism and I was rapt.

Overall, I think the message of the movie was a little too on the nose for my taste. For a similar story that approaches alcoholism and marital woes without feeling like a neon sign blaring ALCOHOL IS BAD, I'd say Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? is the way to go (maybe an unfair comparison, but it felt relevant).

Deciding a rating for this has been tricky because I don't think it's a bad movie whatsoever, but it did flirt with a bit of melodrama and I didn't really enjoy myself watching it AND I don't think I'd necessarily recommend it to anyone so I will reluctantly say 2.5 Brandy Alexanders out of 5.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Sunny

I realize I enjoy myself a good alcoholism/addiction-based media. Leaving Las Vegas, Another Round, obviously IJ if we bridge to books. I sometimes wonder why the personal appeal; I don't spend too much time on the thread, afraid I'll pull apart the whole sweater. Zach said a line in MMM this week that stuck with me ("But we've all been alcoholics at some point"), and even if it's not literally true, there's something spiritually right about it.

I was initially a little worried about this movie—the age, the length, the opening song. Was this going to be a slow and boring two hours? Or worse, overly preachy?

The opening is bizarre enough. What's this guy do exactly? Sort of an early Epstein slash Pete Campbell type? But somewhere around the Peanut Brittle scene and the elevator diatribe, I clicked in for the next hour forty-five.

The movie feels more modern than I first gave it credit for. The pacing was fast. The acting was superb. Lemmon and Remick, obviously, but I also enjoyed the Dad and the AA sponsor from 12 Angry Men. I dug that huge swaths of time would pass without much explanation, giving enough credit to the audience to fill in the gaps and get "Oh, they've fallen down another couple notches."

That pacing cuts both ways—one hour into the movie they're getting clean and working with the dad, but the audience knows there's half a movie left. It's inevitable the relapse, and we're just waiting to see how. Turns out there'd be like half a dozen more relapses. And there's definitely real power in those scenes. I cringed hard and felt the pain during the greenhouse trashing, the motel room concession, and the final apartment scenes in a way that a lot of media comes short in producing.

Two lines from Remick's character in particular stuck with me. Early on, when Lemmon is asking her why she doesn't like booze, saying it can make her happier, she says she's "already happy." I believe she genuinely means it, despite being a secretary living in a roach kingdom. There's a certain envy I have there, but I guess we all start like that don't we, as babes?

And then in that last scene, when she says she needs to drink because she can't deal with how "dirty everything looks," and the Substance make it pretty again. I can relate to that. It's both shocking and totally believable how someone's mind could change that dramatically in ~7 years and how they were taken on a ride nearly outside their control the whole time.

It's interesting that in the '50s/'60s drinking was everywhere (not like it isn't now), especially in well-to-do society and white-collar work. Like Mad Men, Lemmon mentions how he knows plenty of people who drink more than him, but didn't have this down-spiral happen to them. Moreover, it's interesting to see here a time where AA is ~30 years old, still rather looked down upon, and alcoholism isn't a disease but rather a failing of will. Remick's reaction to the program both felt real and hard to watch. I think I read on Wikipedia that Lemmon, Remick, and the director Blake Edwards all ended up going to AA in the years following the movie. There's some sympathy for poor souls to their social trappings. The sad/ambiguous ending closes the circle in that this definitely wasn't overly preachy; actually, quite grounded for and in its time.

Together in Heaven! 4/5

P.S. Somewhere around the third act, the score really clicked, and I kinda get why Mancini won the award, even if I think that opening song's stupid.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

Well fuck, man. The timing on watching this one is pretty good. My sober-versary is this Sunday, and I'll be celebrating three years sober, so it's definitely been on my mind. I did not know what Days of Wine and Roses was about until maybe 30 minutes into the viewing, so I did not have the foresight to plan this blog post to be published three days prior to March 15th, on a Thirsty Thursday no less. Total fucking coincidence, and a welcome one. I don't believe in god and I don't believe in fate, but sometimes it's nice to just sit back and marvel and the wonders of the universe, and how the pure fucking randomness of it still manages to smile down upon you.

That's something I would probably say at an AA meeting, that bit about fate vs. randomness and the juxtaposition not really mattering at the end of the day. I would say that if I went to AA meetings, which I don't. I have, but I don't currently. I am 100% pro-AA, and I believe that it works. I also believe that if you can get through sobriety without it, then that's okay too. It's cool to know that I always have that as an option. I've pulled the trigger on AA as an emergency option exactly twice. The first time was on March 15, 2023, Day 1, or rather Night 1 I guess, an 11 PM meeting with a bunch of Northeast Philly hoagie-mouthed dudes. Figured I should start out on the right foot. It was nice saying my piece, talking about that voice in my head that told me that I should probably stop or else I'm gonna be dead soon, because everybody understood what I was talking about. The second time was on May 15, 2023, Day 62, before my graduation from Penn, when I knew that I would feel like a huge piece of shit that day for not celebrating "the right way" and honestly for feeling like a fraud for the degree I was receiving since I earned it mostly while intoxicated. So I fit a quick meeting in at like 7 AM, and the two other people there understood exactly what I was talking about, and then I went to graduation and felt like slightly less than a piece of shit and managed to not drink.

There are some good stories that you'll hear in AA, I'm sure. The ones I've heard were pretty normal. My story is nothing special. I don't have an exciting or retrospectively comedic rock bottom. I just made a decision to stop drinking after a lifetime of too much drinking. That more or less feels like this other Joe's story too. He got too drunk too many times, had some mildly amusing (to the observer) mishaps (like the greenhouse scene, yikes!), and finally reached the point where he had had enough. The trick is that the story doesn't have to be exciting for it to be impactful. The idea that there are other people out there just like you is enough. Even if the characters are fictional! Even in a movie as melodramatic as Days of Wine and Roses! It's still helpful!

(I'm glad I didn't know what the film was about, or else I think I might have approached it more guardedly. It honestly did not occur to me that this was a Movie About Alcoholism until, hmmm, maybe when the house caught on fire? Which is pretty late into the film. Look at the poster at the top of the blog post and you'll see that the themes were pretty well-known to contemporaneous audiences. I actually only added this film to the list because it sounded like the Japandroids song "The Nights of Wine and Roses," which I looked up was actually named after The Days of Wine and Roses by the Dream Syndicate, which is named after the same poem as this movie.)

While watching, I was concerned that perhaps it had too much of a After School Special vibe to it, too much pontificating by Joe and by Joe's AA sponsor about the evils of alcohol. It wasn't subtle. Kirsten goes from getting tipsy off one drink to having a beer at breakfast and destroying her home. Joe goes from getting taken off an account due to boozing to getting thrown in the psych ward. There's this thing that alcoholics who have not yet admitted they have a problem do when they say "oh, well I'm not THAT bad," and I think this movie probably provided a lot of wiggle room for a lot of alcoholics in the 1960s. I watch Joe and Kirsten and I can say truthfully that I was never this bad... but I can also say truthfully that I was bad in other ways, and that I have a problem, and that I cannot drink anymore or else I'll die. I just think the movie would've been more effective if it had been more subtle and casual about the substance abuse issues.

But see, here's where AA comes back in. It doesn't really matter. I'm not taking anyone else's inventory, including a movie's. It's not my place to say if something or somebody is "too dramatic," it's still a true-to-life story of alcoholism, and because of that, I appreciate hearing it, and I can identify. I can identify with a lot in this movie, it's true! Mostly Joe's fear of drinking, how some of those final drinks feel like he's allowing himself to be consumed by a monster, and he knows it, and the shame and fear and intertwined. That part didn't feel too dramatic to me at all. That felt grounded.

Something else that hit close to home, I guess in the contrast to my own experience, was when Joe's sponsor was like "your wife's gonna be miserable now! she lost her playmate! booze was your meeting ground!" I don't think that's true in my life, but it's definitely a fear that I have, still, however unfounded. I don't think that booze was my and Pam's "meeting ground," I don't think our relationship was ever built on that, and so right now it still feels solid to me, maybe even more so without beer soaking the foundation. But I do worry that I'm not as fun to people anymore. There's nothing much I can do about it, but I still feel bad. I don't want to be a wet blanket (or a "friend of the milkman," as Kirsten puts it, hilariously). I don't want people to feel weird about drinking around me. I don't want Pam to think that she can't have a great time with me like we used to do. I'm trying my best, and I'm half succeeding, but the fear remains.

Shit, my bad, gang. I'm getting way too far into the weeds on this one. I haven't really talked about the movie, just my personal reaction to some of the themes the movie has brought up. Hopefully there is some engaging discussion beyond what I've had to say about the Joe watching and the Joe being watched. Jack Lemmon is so fucking good, isn't he? I haven't seen too many (I think Some Like It Hot and Glengarry Glen Ross, plus JFK which was basically a string of 100 cameos by famous actors), but I love his nervous, manic energy. It was pretty interesting to watch him and Lee Remick attempt to play drunk characters, since that's generally tough to do, but Lemmon especially, since alcohol is a depressant, and Jack Lemmon is the living embodiment of an upper drug.

Some of the best moments in the film were just watching these characters exist mired in their own fucked-up ways. Drinking in the bedroom, stumbling toward the liquor store across the lake, the intense sadness of Kirsten alone in that motel. Those felt real. Otherwise, I'm acknowledging that this movie was corny as fuck. I'm saying that I thought it was over-the-top and maybe a little too preachy and outdated in the way that it had to explain in detail was AA was and what it means to be an alcoholic. I've seen public service announcements with similar tones.

And yet, if you're the type of person who has had sobriety on his mind a lot lately because of a personal anniversary, and you still struggle with the idea of sobriety even as the sobriety itself seems pretty intact at this point, and you are in a film club and you stumble across a movie during this time of the year, completely by chance, the time of year when maybe you need to hear someone's story, since hearing stories are always helpful, no matter how lame, no matter how cliché, you're just the type of person who needs to hear it, and finds comfort in it, in the idea of finding empathy in this space, even the fictional space in a movie, then, well... maybe this is a good movie for you.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 3.33 pukes out of 5

Destroy every pot in the greenhouse to find the comment section.

(NEXT TIME: Our final small group of the month gets together to talk Babel... and speak in different tongues, I'm assuming...? That's just a guess, I know literally nothing about what this movie is about.)

10 comments:

Joe K said...

Thanks for indulging me today, folks. I'm sorry that the timing worked out the way it did and you had to hear some blabbering from me! But I really do appreciate this movie in ways that I might not have if we watched it some other time in the year or some other time in my life.

Joe K said...

As to the on-the-nose / after school special / Reefer Madness-esque of it all, I meant to mention but forgot that the movie ending with the word BAR reflected on Joe's face was probably THE moment that indicated it was a little too on-the-nose. Like, dude, if you're a struggling alcoholic, maybe don't move into an apartment whose window literally flashes the word BAR in your face every night?!?!

Joe K said...

I LOVED Catherine's take about Kirsten being the true victim here, and I think there's a lot of truth to that. I saw myself too deep in Joe's shoes to be able to see Kirsten's POV on this one, so it was a good reality check on me (as a viewer).

However, I think if Kirsten actually did find herself in AA one day, she might find that there is very little room for blaming other people, and that any mistake she made, no matter Joe's role in it, she's gonna have to own for herself. Which is a really tough pill to swallow, I know!

sunny said...

Hey, you try finding a two bedroom apartment in downtown SF on a recovering drunk's salary

sunny said...

Yeah, absolutely. Kirsten was the victim of so many circumstances seen and unseen in this movie, and that's probably the biggest tragedy of all.

And you're right that being the victim doesn't get you any recovery or help in and of itself

Joe K said...

He couldn't have been like, hey, listen, I'll take literally any other apartment in this whole complex, just not the one that literally has my greatest fear flashing into the window with big flashing neon lights????

Catherine said...

That is tough, but you're right! Ultimately personal responsibility is the only thing that'll save her at this point. It's also a really haunting reminder for Joe that some of your worst mistakes can't be rectified. He'll just have to live with that reality forever even if he makes all the right choices for himself going forward.

Catherine said...

While we're sharing, I've gotta admit when Kirsten says, "I will just use my willpower and not drink and that's the end of it!" I related in a very squirmy, don't-look-at-me sort of way. It's so easy to say you're going to abstain then toss that notion out the window as soon as someone says "wanna grab a drink?" or a holiday comes up or it's a gd Tuesday and you feel like it. It's tough and I appreciated this movie for addressing it.

Joe K said...

Thanks for saying this. You're right that Kirsten had an uncomfortable knack for dropping hard truths in this one. The ending got me pretty good too, when she was saying that the world just looks so much dirtier while sober. I identified so hard with that one. How shit seemed so much more vivid and exciting while drunk. And how hard it is to accept that real life isn't as exciting.

Joe K said...

Another thought I just had while typing that one is this. AA is awesome but I think sometimes within AA there's this feeling of "no one understands this thing like we do." Which is not true, based on watching this movie. Kirsten understands it just fine, and who knows if she'll ever set foot in a meeting. There's a kinship between everyone who has ever picked up a drink, no matter what happens after that.