Tuesday, March 17, 2026

Film Club Holiday Special: The Wind That Shakes the Barley

I studied blogging for five years, Dan. And now I'm going to blog this man in the head. I've known Chris Reilly since he was a child. I hope this Puke on Your Birthday we're fighting for is worth it.


The Wind That Shakes the Barley
2006
Ken Loach

Let's see who answered the call on this highest of holidays.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I was listening to the Wolfe Tones and I was thinking that maybe it's time to learn maybe even one single fucking thing about the history of Ireland, something besides... the Titanic, I guess? That's a joke (especially since that's Northern Ireland, the Titanic), I'm talking more, like, a history of violence, hardship, war? My thoughts about motivating myself to learn about this subject were interrupted when my phone buzzed, with Sean E. asking me whether I'd ever seen The Wind That Shakes the Barley, and that he had half a mind to force whoever he could to watch it for an off-list Film Club endeavor on the blog. The timing was good. I learned the basics from this movie, as I was hoping to.

More of my thoughts about Irish heritage etc. in that Wolfe Tones album review this Friday, I'm sure. For now, let's concentrate on the movie itself, the filmmaking of it all. Was it a good flick? Fuck yeah, this movie was relentless. I was on the edge of my seat throughout. And I think my ignorance worked to my advantage on this one, now that I'm thinking about it. Had I know about the general chain of events from the Irish War of Independence into the Irish Civil War, maybe it would have felt uninspired, and maybe some of the ideology espoused by the characters might have felt cliché or something. But I didn't know about anything, so it was genuinely fascinating to watch the gradual steps that the major players took to go from English/Irish violence to Irish/Irish violence. I thought it was a really effective exercise in proving that life is relentless cruel, and that sometimes there are no happy endings.

It's definitely a story-first film, in that I was moved by the plot but there was not necessarily anything about the filmmaking itself that moved me. I could probably pick a few moments if I thought about it. I thought the director had a good sense of how to use distance when it came to violence. Teddy had his fingernails snapped off, and the camera was right up in there. But then when Sinéad is tortured, the camera is far away, mimicking the distance that her allies are witnessing it from, which made the violence feel surreal and made the viewer feel helpless. Let's see, what else... the film made good use of the scenery, with all those lush hillside environments, the flowing grass and wide open sky. Oh, and I liked how natural the monologues felt. I'm talking about the speeches, like the political speeches between allies in back rooms. The actors were allowed to make minor mistakes, repeating words and stumbling over syllables occasionally, which made it feel real and not staged.

All that to the side, the real value in a movie like this is the history behind it. I'm not expecting that The Wind That Shakes the Barley is 100% accurate, but I'd like to think it painted an accurate broad picture of Ireland in the early 1920s. The best movies take you out of yourself and place you somewhere else, and I really did feel that way sometimes while watching this one. At the very least, it'll give me something to think about today as I sip on a non-alcoholic Guinness and wonder what it's all about.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Sean E.

Watching The Wind That Shakes the Barley left me with an uncomfortable realization about who I would probably be in that moment of history. Like most viewers, I want to imagine myself as Damien, the idealistic doctor played by Cillian Murphy: principled, uncompromising, and willing to reject the treaty because it falls short of true independence. But the film quietly suggests that many people, myself included, would be more like his brother Teddy, who ultimately supports the treaty. Not because he loves it, but because after years of violence, sacrifice, and loss, the small step forward feels like the only realistic path left. It's a sobering recognition: wanting the purity of principle while knowing that compromise might actually be the wiser choice.

The film's title, drawn from the old Irish rebel song "The Wind That Shakes the Barley," carries a layered meaning. In the song, barley refers both to the grain growing in Irish fields and to the rebels buried beneath that soil, since barley was said to sprout from the pockets of fallen fighters who carried grain with them. The "wind" that shakes the barley becomes a haunting metaphor for the cycles of rebellion and sacrifice that ripple across generations. The film mirrors this idea: the struggle against British rule gives way almost immediately to another tragic conflict among the Irish themselves.

One of the most powerful aspects of the movie is its attention to class politics, something that is often overlooked in discussions of Irish independence. Beneath the fight for national freedom lies a deeper question about what kind of society Ireland should become. Characters like Dan and Damien push not only for independence from Britain but also for land redistribution and a more socialist vision of Ireland, one where workers and small farmers have real power. The film suggests that the treaty debate wasn't simply about nationalism versus compromise; it was also about whether independence would fundamentally change the social order or merely transfer power to a new Irish elite.

Another strength of the film is its focus on ordinary participants in the struggle. Unlike movies such as Michael Collins, which center on famous revolutionary leaders, this story stays firmly grounded among rank-and-file members of the Irish Republican Army. These are farmers, railway workers, and young men who didn't necessarily plan to become revolutionaries but were pushed there by circumstances. By staying with these "average" fighters, the film makes the conflict feel both more intimate and more tragic, because the consequences of political decisions play out directly within families, friendships, and local communities.

Perhaps most striking is how vividly the film captures the daily indignities of occupation. Small humiliations: forced haircuts, arbitrary beatings, and intimidation by soldiers all accumulate until resistance begins to feel inevitable. These moments ground the story emotionally. Rather than presenting rebellion as an abstract political choice, the film shows how anger, pride, and a desire for dignity slowly build until violence seems like the only remaining response. In doing so, the film speaks not only to the Irish experience but to the broader history of occupied peoples everywhere.

What makes The Wind That Shakes the Barley so powerful is that it refuses to offer an easy moral resolution. By the end, the audience is left wrestling with the same impossible question as the characters: when is compromise necessary, and when does it betray the very ideals that started the struggle in the first place? The film's tragedy is that both sides believe they are protecting the future of Ireland, and in some sense, both are right.

5 out of 5 pukes

~~~~~~~~~~

Pat

I watched The Wind That Shakes the Barley free on Plex. In order to fully capture that experience, I have included the commercial breaks in my recap.

County Cork, 1920. The movie opens on a crowd of young men playing a contentious game of hurling. This is risky business; the British regime has declared any form of assembly illegal. 

As the men walk away from the match, they are stopped by a British patrol. The sergeant orders the men to strip, for the dual purpose of checking for weapons and humiliating their targets. When seventeen-year-old Micheál refuses to respond to questions in English and punches a soldier, the Black and Tans beat him to death in his family's chicken coop. 

By this point, I have turned on the subtitles because I can't understand a word anyone is saying. Everyone onscreen is speaking English under duress, including the English people. 

At Michael's funeral, Damien O'Donovan (Cillian Murphy) is implored by his friends and brother, Teddy (Padraic Delaney) to join the Irish Republican Army. But Damien thinks the fight is all for nought and elects to leave his home to work as a doctor in England.

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • Amtrak has a sleek new ad campaign and it features... a gay couple enjoying the train?! Woke AF. How did DOGE miss that one? 
  • Jon Hamm for BetMGM
  • Claude AI: New answers to old questions. Especially if the question is "Can I bomb that school?"]
At the train station, Damien sees Dan the train driver (Liam Cunningham) refuse to transport British soldiers. The soldiers respond by brutalizing Dan and the other employees, but ultimately give up on catching the train. Damien is inspired by this small but certain defeat of the British and returns home to join the IRA

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • WeatherTech car mats
  • Tide detergent
  • Tampax
  • A commercial for McDonald's Filet O'Fish narrated by Brian Cox
  • Rita's Water Ice has an app now?!]
The war rages on. Damien, Teddy and company raid and rob a local police station, then use the weapons to assassinate a group of British officers. 

An O'Donovan associate, Chris Reilly, is threatened by his employer to give up information about Damien and Teddy. This leads to Damien and Teddy's capture. At the barracks, the heroes are tortured physically and mentally. Teddy gets his fingernails ripped out, while Damien is subjected to a mock execution. 

(SIDE NOTE: Most of the Irish (Gaeilge) in this movie was beyond my understanding. That said, I did get unreasonably excited when I understood "Teddy O'Donavan is ainm dom.")

While awaiting real execution, Damien reunites with Dan the Train Man. They spent their last few hours bonding over the words of James Connolly and their mutual desire for an Irish socialist republic, free of capitalists, landlords and financiers.

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • Nissan
  • Dawn platinum dish soap
  • Cascade dishwasher detergent
  • Febreze
  • Chili's, which is why you need the Febreze]
Reluctant British troop Johnny Gogan refuses to have Damien, Teddy, and Dan's deaths on his conscience and frees them. In an effort to free their comrades left behind, Damien kidnaps the informer Chris Reilly and Chris's boss, Sir John, intending to hold them for ransom. But when the IRA learns the remaining comrades have been executed anyway, Damien receives orders to kill Reilly and Sir John.

[COMMERCIAL BREAK: 
Damien accepts his duty, though with reservations. "I hope this Ireland we're fighting for is worth it," he remarks before murdering a man he's known since childhood. 

The war goes on and the strain is starting to affect the coalition. When a Dáil Éireann court rules against a local landlord, Teddy frees the defendant because he pays for their weapons. Damien and the other revolutionaries are outraged that Teddy is siding with capital over the people, but Teddy reminds them that social justice doesn't buy bullets. 

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • Always Discreet pads
  • theScore Bet Sportsbook Casino
  • John Kennedy Mazda of Conshohocken 
  • Tillamook Creamery 
  • Claude AI
  • The New York Sirens, who are riding high off the USA's Olympic gold in women's hockey, as well as some other stuff in the zeitgeist.]
The breaking point is coming and no one can stop it. Dan rails against the IRA backing the landlords, while Damien opens up to his sweetheart, Sinéad (Orla Fitzgerald), about killing Chris Reilly. 

Whatever reservations the republicans have about each other, it's pushed aside by the phenomena On Killing describes as "the dark power of atrocity." Damien, Teddy, and the others disguise a comrade as a stranded British soldier in order to ambush and massacre a truck of British auxiliaries. This is absolutely a war crime. 

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • Doritos. There were probably other commercials, but I was frantically googling about international humanitarian law.]
The British decide to fight war crimes with more war crimes. In retaliation for the massacre, Black and Tans torture Sinéad and burn down her family's house. While sifting through the wreckage, Damien, Teddy, Dan, and Sinéad learn that a truce has been declared! And not a moment too soon! Everyone celebrates and Damien and Sinéad bang.

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • Help at Home caregivers]
The party stops once everybody learns the actual details of the truce. Under the terms of the treaty, Ireland will be split into the Free State and Northern Ireland. Both will still be under control of the King. Teddy supports the treaty as a means of establishing self-rule. Damien doesn't; the treaty is insufficiently socialist and supports private welfare over public welfare. Seven out of ten former IRA members agree with Damien and start training for a civil war.

[COMMERCIAL BREAK:
  • Chick-fil-A en Español! For a famously conservative restaurant, they're walking a dangerously woke tightrope. Yes, merely acknowledging that the Spanish language exists is woke now. I don't make the rules.)
A comrade named Rory kills two Free State soldiers. Teddy demands retaliation in order to prevent British redeployment. 

During Mass, the priest says the Catholic Church—which always knew what was best for Ireland—is on the side of the treaty. Damien tells the priest to eat shit and walks out. 

In a sign of just how fucked the situation has become, Irish soldiers are now searching Sinéad's house for weapons. Dan is killed while raiding an armory and Damien is captured. 

Locked in the same barracks where they had been tortured years earlier, now-commander Teddy begs his little brother to inform on Rory and take amnesty. Damien can't, either out of devotion to the cause or his deep shame over murdering Chris Reilly for the same infraction. 

As he is led to the firing squad, Damien recalls: "It's easy to know what you're against, quite another to know what you're for." Damien is tied to post, but declines the blindfold. He wants his former comrades and brother to look him in the eye when they kill him. Damien is shot on Teddy's orders. Teddy informs Sinéad of Damien's death, and Sinéad banishes Teddy from her home. 

To be an Irish-American is to be pulled between two nearly irreconcilable positions. First, there is the reality of Ireland's history. Seas of blood have been spilled over this island about two-thirds the size of Pennsylvania. The story of the Irish people is one of repression, deprivation, and obstinate perseverance, leading to a new (but never guaranteed) era of peace and prosperity. Put bluntly, the Irish were on the ass end of an ass-whipping for centuries and have only very recently begun to recover. To be Irish is to be part of a tradition of overcoming civilization-threatening adversity. 

On the other hand, the story of Ireland is not my story. I'm an American. I was born near Pittsburgh. I have never visited Ireland except for two weeks in 2004. I have lived a life of comfort and security and have not yet had to reckon with a life under occupation or open conflict. I have overcome adversity in my life, but never the type that would destroy my civilization if left unopposed. 

You're left with a reputation for struggle without ever having actually struggled. I have seen this conflict play out around me. Irish-Americans notoriously adopt the trappings of their heritage without ever thinking for even a second about their actual position in the world. It leads to some crazy shit, man. Tiocfaidh ár lá bumper stickers on the back of luxury pickup trucks. Uncles complaining about affirmative action in the 2020s by citing No Irish Need Apply in the 1840s. That one lady at Hanrahan's who bragged about her grandfather buying guns for the IRA, who I'm certain has never looked into whether that's an unqualified good thing. This fucking guy. 

I don't resent my Irish-American identity, but it can be a strange thing to grapple with. I liken it to watching The Wind That Shakes the Barley—a movie about brothers pulled apart by the doomed struggle for a socialist Ireland—while seeing ads for Chumba Casino, Pringles, and all-inclusives in Dubai every fifteen minutes. It's a story of struggle and resilience told to ourselves, only to be unceremoniously interrupted by a soft, squishy, privileged reality. 

I've come to terms with my heritage by treating it as a personal tradition to be respected, not a license that makes me interesting. I no longer treat St. Patrick's Day as a blank check to be a terrible person (contrast with: my behavior on St. Patrick's Day, 2012). I've traced my family tree back to Currabaha in County Tipperary to get a better understanding of why my family came to America (conclusion: no food at home, lots of food in Baltimore). I try to incorporate a little bit of the Irish language into my life. I read about Irish history when I can, but with the understanding that I am not the one these events happened to. 

I am Irish, but I am American first. Therefore, I should start by affording Irishness the same reverence I would to any other foreign culture. Once that respect is in place, I can follow my personal connection and truly love my Irish self. 

But I'm definitely making corned beef and cabbage today. No hesitation about that. That's 100% American, baby. 

~~~~~~~~~~

Use to be that on St. Patrick's Day, I'd have started drinking at breakfast. Instead, this year, I'll be working the comment section of this blog post. Meet me there, in between pints.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

100% this line from Pat, couldn't agree more!

"I've come to terms with my heritage by treating it as a personal tradition to be respected, not a license that makes me interesting"

Pat said...

Thanks Anonymous!

I didn't mention it in my review because I got caught up in some personal stuff, but I liked this movie! I second Joe and Sean's sentiments. This is not just an unromantic portrayal of a war for independence, but an actively anti-romantic one, right down to (as Joe pointed out) the grand speeches being interrupted by "ahs" and "erms."

Weirdly, one of the lines that stuck with me the most was the British interrogator responding to Damien's protests:

“What do you fucking well expect? These men fought at the Somme, up to their necks in vomit, in filthy trenches, while their friends got blown apart in front of their eyes!...”

This does not excuse the crimes of the British. But it does remind us—for just a second—that the people Damien and Teddy are fighting have also been senselessly shattered by the whims of capital. There is no war but class war.

Joe K said...

I honestly just appreciated confirmation that I wasn't the only one who couldn't understand the accents and needed subtitles.

Sean E. said...

The accents are that bad?