Friday, March 6, 2026

WARM, Joe


Ah shit, forgot to tell you, I finally booked that session with a therapist. Like, a real one, not one that I made up for the purposes of self-analyzing my emotions during a Record Club album review. An actual human being. I think the blog has gone about as far as it can go in terms of providing comfort for me. What I'm finding is that I might need someone in my life to not only listen to what I'm trying to say, but also be professionally obligated to give me feedback. There are a handful of people who might read a particularly maudlin emo-drenched blog post written by me on Puke on Your Birthday, but there is no one here or in my life generally who would feel obliged to respond to it, at least not in a way that is going to include constructive feedback. Not even Pam, who doesn't read this blog all that often but finds herself in my presence more often than anyone else in this world, really knew what to do about it. She lends a sympathetic ear when I come to her in the evening and say that I feel sad sometimes and I don't really know why, but that sympathy can really only stretch so far. And she's not paid to address emotional wounds, just physical ones (nor does she really have any desire to consider those physical wounds she so ably dresses as figurative symbols of anything else). So it eventually gets to the point where she's like, dude, I'm not the person to talk to about this shit anymore. Which makes sense, to a degree. Especially since the option is right there, for a nominal fee, paid through my very good government insurance. So I finally signed up. It'll be nice to force someone to listen, I think, mostly since I am so accustomed to making sure people are very aware that they don't have to listen to me, that I'm not important, that nothing I say is anything they have to worry about, don't worry about the blog, just something way off to the side here, don't look if you don't wanna look, don't listen to what I have to say, it's not worth it. Instead, what would happen if I said, hey, you, listen to me please, I need you to listen, I need you to respond to what I'm saying, I need you to try to understand. In my mind, those needs are addressed by a therapist.

What I like about Jeff Tweedy is that he's been very upfront over the years about using music as a safe space to speak on his truth and reflect on his experience. I wonder if Tweedy has a therapist. I have to imagine he does. I am imagining it because I am imagining he eventually came to the same realization that I did recently, that finding your artistic niche is one thing, but sometimes you just need a little bit more. Let's pull a bunch of numbers literally out of my fucking ass, just to prove a point, and say that 200,000 people have listened intently to WARM. Of those, 50,000 loved that album, and repeated it often at some point in their lives, maybe even in the present tense. Of those, only 1,000 have been in the physical presence of Jeff Tweedy, and of those, 100 spoke to him or interacted with him in writing. Almost all 100 of those people had the following feedback to provide: "I love the album! It means a lot to me!" Which is a good thing, and probably made Tweedy feel really good inside. But it also means that close to 0% of the people who enjoy this album are able to directly address the emotional wounds that Jeff Tweedy is making bare on WARM. That's fine too. This art is "for the fans," as they say. This is our right as music listeners, to take the music and make it our own, make it important to us. But that means that Jeff Tweedy's intentions don't really mean all that much, and what I'm proposing now is: how does that make him feel!?!

(It's funny, because Tweedy traffics in the idea of "shadow self" throughout this album, i.e. meeting someone who is just like him, his twin or whatever, and that's basically what the Fake Therapist bit has been whenever I employ it here on the blog. I'm not actually talking to a therapist, I'm just talking to myself. Which, yeah man, is a good way of getting insight, I'd argue.)

I like the album because it really does feel like a man who is doing his best to write his truth. There are some subtleties and some figurative language, but there's not much to weed through. Here is a song about feeling guilty. Here is a song about feeling sad. Here is a song about feeling lonely throughout your life. When Tweedy says that this is a safe space, he's talking about the listener's emotions, yes, but he's mainly talking about his own emotions, and how he has leaned on the fact that expressing your true emotions through song has a way of healing. Which is good, if a bit trite, I suppose. What I've been thinking about through this fresh batch of 20 WARM listens is that maybe sometimes that's not enough for Jeff Tweedy the human being. Or is it? I don't know. I don't want to project.

I'm going deeper into this "he's just like me!" line of thinking than I normally do because of the line in "Bombs Away," right there at the beginning of this album full of basic heart-on-sleeve lyrics: "It's hard to say what I've been through should matter to you." I can empathize with this feeling, the puzzlement of knowing that you need to say something about yourself, process your truth through words and through art, and yet at the same time have this conflicting feeling that people won't care and why bother trying. Does what I've been through matter to you? It's tough to answer that one in the affirmative. I don't think that anything that I've been through matters to anyone. That's where the therapy comes in, though: my insurance is paying someone to pretend to care, in 50-minute blocks, that what I've been through matters to them.

There are limits to empathy. This is what Jeff Tweedy says when he's explaining the song "I Know What It's Like." The line is: "I know what it's like to not feel love." Basically: no one knows, or could possibly ever know, what someone else is going through—the other shoe never fits—and so how can we possibly express true empathy? How can we say that we know what it's like, when we never could? And, on the flip side of that, how can we speak our truth and ever expect anyone to truly know what the fuck we are even talking about? He says the phrase "testing the limits of empathy," and I focus on the word "testing" in that phrase, not the word "limits." We need to test the limits, it is our duty. We must continually speak our truth, and when it doesn't feel right, pay a goddamn therapist to hear our truth. And, more importantly, we must continue to try our best to hear others, even if we'll never truly know, we must try, we must listen and do our goddamn best to relate, to lend an ear, to, yes, EMPATHIZE. And if the people in your life aren't usually down for talking their deep truths, maybe build a whole goddamn blog, call it a "music blog" as a feint, force people to write on it, and sift through all the actual music criticisms to get at the goddamn beating heart of their truth, see it right there on the blog, in black and white.

Now the problem is... I mean, the music is fine. How's that for music criticism that completely ignores the truth?! The problem is that speaking your truth in an extremely personal way does not always result in the most exciting art. Compare WARM directly to any Wilco album, and it's going to shrivel slightly. That's because there are more people in the room while recording for Wilco. More truths are added to a Wilco album, and the truth gets stronger, and more varied, and more interesting. WARM is just one dude putting himself out there, with no filters. Occasionally, that results in something worth noticing, like the singalong chorus of "Let's Go Rain," for instance. But more often than not, the focus becomes the words the man is speaking, and the music drifts into the background, and, yes, of course this is ACTUALLY an album review, and so we must dock points for the fact that the music itself, the music that we can manage to peel away from the deep dark truths attached to it, is a little lacking.

But then the problem becomes the fact that now I'm saying that WARM is just okay, just fine, overall, as a piece of art, and so how do you think that would make Jeff Tweedy feel, to lay bare your motherfucking truth and hear some asshole say "Um, I think that one-third of the songs on WARM are completely forgettable, and it'll never stack up to the music from your main gig"? The assessment is true from a music criticism standpoint, but it completely misses the point from a human being standpoint. The whole reason that Tweedy needed to strip away all the good stuff from Wilco and make something sort of light and insignificant musically was because he needed an outlet for his innermost feelings, because that makes him feel good, helps him emotionally. I'm saying I get it! I'm saying that I, more than anyone else that I know, I understand what it's like to feel this deep burning desire to just write and write because it's the only thing that even comes close to helping. And so why shouldn't he write such an album? Where the focus can be on what he's saying and what he's feeling as opposed to, like, having a single distinguishable guitar lick?

I suppose that's the bargain to take when you become a relatively successful musician. You make art, but you immediately give it away. And you can tell yourself something like "this one's for me," put your own name on it, gently tell your bandmates it's a solo album, pour your own heart into it, make clear that this is coming from a place of truth, your truth and no one else's, you can do all that, but at the end of the day, the album is still for the listener, and you, the artist, will never, ever find true satisfaction from the endeavor. How could you? Everyone is listening to your art and just thinking about themselves. That's how art works, to be certain, but still. Today, I'm thinking about Jeff Tweedy the human being, and hoping that he's gotten a true listening ear outside of this whole music thing. From listening to WARM, I can tell it's something he would benefit from. I know this because I'm listening to WARM and I'm only thinking about myself and I'm testing the limits of empathy.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments: