Fuck! I can't believe I forgot about Ms. Robinson in the "RECORD CLUB CONNECTIONS" section of the Sunday write-up. Ed Sheeran has five albums named after math symbols, and I completely disregard that a previous RC alum was literally a math teacher. My deepest apologies for the omission.
How about you? Were you thinking about math while listening to this album? Or something else? What do we make of this Eddie Sheeran guy, huh? Let's chat in the comments about it.

18 comments:
Challenging myself to rank Ed Sheeran opinions today from most favorable toward Ed Sheeran to least favorable toward Ed Sheeran. Here's where I'm at, let me know if I'm off-base in any way:
1. Melissa
2. Brittany
3. Nate
4. Joe
5. Zach
6. Sunny
7. Gloria
But the important thing is: everyone, even those with negative opinions, were willing to give it a shot. That's cool! It's cool to explore little-known artists, and it's also cool to explore artists so popular that they are household names. I have never listened to an Ed Sheeran album before this week, and even though I didn't necessarily LIKE the album, I feel like I'm better for knowing it.
I liked Gloria's thoughts about the lyrics being non-specific (something that I was thinking about while listening to Katy Perry a couple years ago). I think she's right to question them, and I think she's right to say they are generic. But also! The question of "why doesn't this feel like it's actually about anything?" was answered by Melissa's review. It's about nothing so it could be about anything, and that feels good when you then take a lyric and apply it to something that is important to you, e.g. love and marriage. Ed Sheeran is popular because he allows a wide swath of people to take his lyrics and gives them the tools to think that those lyrics are about them. Which is cool, especially in certain contexts, like two awesome people getting married!
Nate's Sheeran vs. Mars comparison is actually pretty interesting to think about in this context. They are both certified Pop Stars, but I do think I see a difference between the two in terms of how much each allows himself to be emotional vulnerable (or is willing to engage in a facade of emotional vulnerability). Ed Sheeran is blatantly shooting for those tears (a male Adele if there ever was one), but Bruno Mars, even when he goes sappy, never lets you forget that he's doing on this for show, he's a performer, he's not actually sad. I'm not saying one is better than the other, but I think personally I would disagree with Nate and say that I prefer Bruno Mars' showmanship vs. Ed Sheeran's gentle take on male fragility.
Got some mentions of some bonus tracks this week. Obligatory FUCK BONUS TRACKS. I usually note the existence of bonus tracks in the Sunday write-up, but I stopped doing that, because there's just no stopping the streaming services from spoon-feeding you the bonus tracks, whether you read the Sunday thing or not.
SCENE REPORT: JOYCE MANOR / MILITARIE GUN / TEEN MORTGAGE / COMBAT - WEDNESDAY, MARCH 25 - BUFFALO, NEW YORK
The venue has several names and I am unclear at the moment which is the correct one. Corporate partnerships are only for the benefit of their customers. What matters is its a former church reimagined as a concert hall and it probably holds 1000 people at max capacity. It held about 750 Wednesday night. Surveying the crowd gleans useful details; the Sabers are doing well, teens love emo, folks in their 40s love a stepped-on painter's cap and a tie-dye shirt. Lite beer for $3, don't tell western NY America is in decline.
COMBAT: They're young and they'll get there, but what they possess in the ability to recreate the Bomb The Music Industry experience, they lack in stage presence.
TEEN MORTGAGE: Hard men playing dirtbag rock to a soft room. Better on record, but still pretty fucking good.
MILITARIE GUN: Touring for two years straight will make you good, and they were really fucking good. Closing your set with "Do It Faster" and "B.A.D.I.D.E.A." is how you make lookie-loos into die-hards.
JOYCE MANOR: Unexpectedly a band with so many hits that they can play 25 songs, still leave off a bunch of smashes, and deliver a crowd-pleaser. New songs slide in great, "Catalina Fight Song" still levels a room like a glacier.
I think that’s fair. It’s a choice. Do you want insight into someone else’s story or do you want to project your own story onto it? It’s like when main book characters are vaguely written so you can project yourself onto the character
I probably was the least favorable review, but I didn't hate it. It just didn’t really say anything to me 🤷🏼♀️
*squinting* this is about right, though I'd need to know Joe from every age's opinion to have a full view
fuck bonus tracks
A good analogue, and an interesting thing to think about when approaching an album (or a book)
Hell yeah. Teens love emo.
@ Gloria — I agree with your implication that it's better when there's more specificity. Mostly because "applying it to you" can still be done even when it's ultra specific. E.g. how many songs do you love and it's like "well I know it's about X, but when I hear it, it's about Y to me." The value in vagueness is that it's just open to a wider audience, I think. Which can be a good thing or bad thing, depending on what you think about pop music.
@Sunny —
2014 Joe: would hate it
2017 Joe: would hate it
2019 Joe: would hate it and write a hyperbolic review about how much he hated it
2023 Joe: would hate it but would get really stressed about how to write a review that isn't hyperbolic but is instead fair and reasonable
2026 Joe, i.e. the only Joe whose opinion matters at this time: it's a pretty okay album!
@ Nate — Gotta check out these Teen Mortgage folks, they're the only ones I don't already have a (positive) opinion of.
Apropos of nothing else, has anyone been watching the Afroman case?
Gotta dig the outfit
Oh shit, the Joyce Manor dude fucked up his voice at this show! Said: "my voice was totally fucked up for the show... sounded awful." Based on Nate's positive opinion, sounds like Joyce Manor is a tough self-critic.
If Pat hadn't agreed to the RC bit for next week (TBA), then I was gonna slot an Afroman album in there (which, probably ironically, would've drawn Meme Pat into the fold anyway).
Post a Comment