Wednesday, March 11, 2026

A Year of Blind Spots: Easter

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


Patti Smith's Easter is the Breakfast at Tiffany's of classic rock. One half of it is a stunning vision of what the medium can be. The other half is shockingly outdated, to the point that it threatens to topple both halves to the ground.

First, "Because the Night." I was aware of its existence, having functioning ears since 1988 and functioning radios almost as long. It's funny, I was also semi-aware that there was a song that Bruce Springsteen and Patti Smith both had ties to, maybe even saw the title of it here and there. But I didn't make the connection until hearing "Because the Night" on the radio a couple months ago. I went from "wow, remember this song? what a song..." to looking up the song's Wikipedia page to having that sudden jarring realization that it was this song, they were one in the same. Wow. Wow.

What a fucking song! Hearing this song again was like that moment in the romantic comedy where the girl takes off her glasses in slow motion and the male protagonist realizes that the one he's been looking for has been right under his eyes the whole time. That chorus! Fuck! I read the Wikipedia page, and saw that Bruce Springsteen had a rough sketch of the song going with the E Street Band, but that a mutual friend suggested to Springsteen that Patti Smith deserved a hit, so Springsteen was like, I have this thing, maybe she can do something with it. She did! It's cool how you can hear echoes of the E Street Band in its sound, but it's far enough removed that no one could ever actually mistake it.

So I was excited to listen to Easter in full, just based on this album alone. Good album! "Glam rock" is probably a good way to describe it, but punk is there too. "Space Monkey" is adjacent to the Doors. "Privilege (Set Me Free)" is adjacent to the Stooges. I have known and liked Horses for a while, but Easter is the one that got me to sit up and take notice of Patti Smith's punk rock bonafides. This is some cool shit.

Except............... ah shit, yeah, let's see how long it takes me to talk about this one song before I'm satisfied. Maybe you already know the song I'm talking about. This album is almost 50 years old, and so we can definitely say it was a different time, but as always, it's more complicated than that. Okay, uh, the song title's first three words are "Rock n Roll" and the fourth word is the N-word. And there's not really any way to get around it. You can asterisk the title like I originally did, but then you have, like, the whole goddamn song to contend with. Patti Smith, a white woman, just yelling the N-word over and over, as loud as she can. Immediately this becomes the type of album that you can't just hit play on the office speakers and forget about it.

Smith provided an explanation, saying that she was using the term to mean a "rebellious and honorable outsider." She also made claim that she doesn't really think that words have power like that, and claimed that she could walk down the street and call someone the N-word and that would be okay. I get what she's trying to say about words, and in some respects, I agree. But at the same time, she's missing a key element of existing in human society—empathy. A Rolling Stone reporter tried to interview her about it, and she dismissed his question about (e.g.) growing up hard in Harlem, and how she could have the same experience as that. I think in the 50 years since, some people have come to take that a little more seriously, how yes of fucking course Black people have had more to content with due to personal and systematic racism, and so it's not really Smith's role as a white woman to try to move the definition of that word around.

To put it in simpler terms, she doesn't mean it to be a racial slur, but it is absolutely a racist slur regardless. There's just no getting around it. There's no explanation that softens the blow of hearing the worst racial slur you can hear. I didn't see if Smith had any updates on her personal feelings about the song, but I'll admit to you here that I didn't do much research. I couldn't! How could I possibly even search for that song title on a work computer? Even just having the Wikipedia page up made me nervous as hell.

I don't think that Patti Smith had bad intentions back then, but I also think that there's probably no use for this song now. If you use the word "cancelled" here, though, then I'm going to flip the fuck out. That's not how cancellation works. If I found evidence that this song was a manifestation of Smith's deep-seeded racism, then yeah, sure, I wouldn't be listening to this artist anymore. But that's not how it is. She tried to make a point about a word, tried to take it back, and it just didn't work, and fifty years later, it feels like a limp-dick attempt at it. That's time informing that decision, though. There's an alternate universe in which society makes actual strides toward racial harmony and Black leaders decide that a good way to aid in those strides is to cut down the power of the racial slur by changing its meaning, and there's Smith's song with an alternate meaning sitting right there.

I'm a white dude so I don't even know if I have the ability to speculate on any of that, and I certainly don't have the power to change the culture, and I do not have the ability nor the desire to defend Patti Smith's song. I listened to it a few times, just to see what was up with it. A disappointing aspect to this song is how goddamn good it is musically. Just a total fucking banger from our girl Patti. But lyrically, it is utterly indefensible. And you can see how this might create an issue within my own brain. I like a song, and I'm hearing that song replayed in my head, and then all of a sudden my brain is replaying the N-word over and over. Can't have that, and I don't want that, so my limited plays of this song have run out.

I am pretty unsatisfied with what I've written about this song so far, but I feel like whenever this subject comes up, I never feel satisfied completely. It's like I'm always missing something, some answer that is going to solve everything. There's no answer, though. It's just a misguided song destined for the trash bins of history, and the taint that it puts on Easter is neither negligible nor overwhelming. Just like I still look back fondly on my experience with Breakfast at Tiffany's, I still feel fondly toward Easter. It's just that the fondness is purposefully placing the terrible mistake to the side, and focusing on the good stuff. The mistake still remains, regardless of how I feel, or what I remember.

No comments: