Going down the list of 200 movies I've never seen before, down, and then back, and to the left.
Oliver Stone
1991
I don't often find myself in the position of denying movie magic. A good film sucks you in, and 99 times out of 100, I'm content to just let it. That's the fun part, isn't it? That this two-to-three-hour sojourn in a strange world can act as an escape. A good film is one that makes you forget about everything else for a little bit. More than that, though, a good film can also change your worldview a little bit. Very rarely is a film "life-changing," but a good film can return you back to the real world slightly different, viewing the world from a slightly different perspective.
Considering these benchmarks, it is easy to consider JFK a good film. I was engrossed for the entirety of it's three-hour runtime, and, integrally, it makes a naked appeal to the audience to change their worldview.
What I'm proposing here is that, for JFK, that appeal should be resisted. It's charming when Kevin Costner ends captivating 20-minute monologue by staring directly into the camera and asking the audience to "do what's right" and challenge the established narrative. Resist his charms.
Had I viewed this film in 1991, I would have been more open-minded about the idea of a large-scale conspiracy to kill the president. Viewing it in 2022, the idea of a "conspiracy theory" just seems to dangerous to me—physically and mentally—to really accept as a valid bedrock to a major motion picture. People are stupid and believe a lot of dumb shit.
Like, I just saw something with QAnon in Canada where some conspiracist who calls herself "Queen of Canada" convinced her followers to stop paying their utilities bills? Just insultingly dumb bullshit that is also a real danger to the stupids of the world. While it's kind of funny to think about some moron sitting in a house with no heat because the internet convinced him to not pay his bills, it's less funny to think about conspiracy theories leading large swaths of young white men to want to buy assault rifles and shoot children in schools.
So maybe this is an overreaction based on the context in which I am finally viewing this 30-year-old film, but imagine the fallout today if a movie like this was able to convince audiences that this conspiracy theory was real. At the very least, there'd be instances in which, I dunno, the judge's wife is getting threatening phone calls, shit like that. There would also be a distinct possibility that some white dude gets so worked up over the conspiracy that he commits murder.
Considering those hypotheticals feels a little preachy to me, so let's cut off that line of reasoning and consider instead how I felt personally while watching it. Honestly, I'll say that, in the moment, I was completely and totally convinced that there was a conspiracy to kill JFK. I was in. Kevin Costner got me. He was appealing to some of my already established beliefs, mainly that the government is structured to protect the ruling class. An argument like "JFK wanted to end war and racism and classism and so he was stopped from doing that by any means necessary" is an argument that confirms my biases. I want to believe that it's true, because it would confirm what I already believe in my heart to be true.
And that's a fucking huge problem! Because the actual truth does not give a fuck what "I believe in my heart." It's irresponsible of me to believe something without doing any research. After watching the movie, I did start to read up about it, and there was enough out there to suggest that a vast majority of the arguments in this film were bullshit. I get it, and I'm cool with the idea of a film pumping fiction into real life to create that movie magic. But I am also totally cool with the idea of admitting that I am wrong when I'm actually wrong. I was wrong to believe for even a second that there was enough evidence to suggest that the government hired the mob to assassinate the president.
The problem is that I seem to be in the minority of Americans in having the ability to admit that I'm wrong. I am dumb, but I am not among the dumbest people in the country. I am angry, but I have enough self-awareness about my own emotions that I'm able to respond appropriately to that anger. Someone who is dumb and angry and totally willing to accept confirmation bias without any amount of critical reasoning is the type of person who is going to watch JFK and do something terrible, either act out or implode.
Man... I loved this movie. I thought the acting was fantastic. I loved the insane characters, like flopsweat Joe Pesci, and how larger-than-life they all seemed, while also being based on real-life people. I thought the structure was fascinating, how the film gave all this room to these insane monologues, like Donald Sutherland going long on his Mr. X thing. I loved the mystery of it all, and how the film was so convincing in providing answers that seemed right but could never actually be proven so.
My main concern is that the true reason that JFK works is the fact that the arguments it presents could be true. The subsequent fact that the arguments it presents probably are not true then undercuts the appeal. JFK has movie magic, and for once, that magic becomes a criticism.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Alright, enough of all this, give me a big dumb action movie. Give me John Wick.

No comments:
Post a Comment