Friday, October 28, 2022

Return of Saturn, Pam


I've always really liked Return of Saturn. Say what you will about Gwen Stefani these days: does being on The Voice ruin her credibility as a cool musician from the '90s? Did marrying Blake Shelton? Or has she always been the type of musician who was destined to be on a show like The Voice (at least it's not The Masked Singer)? This week had me thinking about this a lot. Did No Doubt sell out? Or were they always a pop-adjacent cheesy band? Maybe I'm just cheesy myself, but I grew up listening to this music and always held Gwen Stefani to a high standard of coolness. (WOW, I just read that she's 53 years old. Gwen Stefani is a golden goddess.) 

I think the fact that I've always thought very highly of No Doubt, and of Gwen Stefani in particular, is the reason why this album matters so much to me. How humanizing it was, around that high school/college age, to hear one of my favorite musicians expressing vulnerability about, well, kinda girly stuff—wanting to get married/become a mom, etc. Listening to Return of Saturn throughout the week, the algorithm constantly put huge pop artists, like Lady Gaga and Christina Aguilera, up in the queue after the album. Which I guess makes sense, but I've always felt Gwen had a bit more of an edge to her than a lot of those artists she tends to get lumped in with. And in terms of expressing that female vulnerability, it's just done so well on Return of Saturn, all the while still sounding very fresh.

Admittedly, some of the songs, like "Magic's in the Makeup," are even a little cheesy for me. The album itself is a little long, which is never a plus for Record Club (sorry all!). But for the most part, Return of Saturn is full of slightly quirky, fun, energetic songs ("Ex-Girlfriend," "Bathwater," "New") that allow the listener to escape into the world of a lovesick and rather depressed-sounding Gwen Stefani. Even the songs that aren't the obvious hits are still enjoyable, with a sound that evolved from their brand of funky California ska which made them famous. If I could hit the high notes on "Bathwater," it would absolutely be a go-to karaoke song of mine (can’t, better stick to "Just a Girl").

The subject matter mainly centering around Gwen Stefani's love life made me think of two previously reviewed Record Club albums—Olivia Rodrigo's SOUR and Fleetwood Mac's Rumours. So, I know that No Doubt’s song "Don’t Speak," from Tragic Kingdom, was written about Gwen and the bassist Tony Kanal's break-up. But I'm still not sure who, if anyone specifically, the songs on Return of Saturn were written about. Either way, the lyrics reminded me of how well Olivia Rodrigo also captured that same intensity on SOUR, 21 years later. Gah, was Olivia Rodrigo even born in 2000? Extremely weird to think about (answer: nope, 2003). And then when I was thinking the songs were about Kanal, it gave me big Rumours vibes (how weird to be playing a break-up song written about you?). But now that I know the ex-boyfriend in question might be a mystery man, I have to wonder whether knowing who a song is about pulls a bigger punch than not knowing. Then I think about Carly Simon's "You're So Vain" and it confirms for me that not knowing can have the same effect, perhaps being even more effectual in that example.

I guess what I learned this week is that if you're a songwriter, reflecting on the type of pain and sadness written about on Return of Saturn, whether it's something you're currently going through or it's in the past, will generate good music that most people can identify with at some point. It's a recipe for a great album. As people, we can be a sad bunch. I mean, who of you doesn't have someone whose bathwater you would have gladly washed in at one point in your life, someone who did not reciprocate those same feelings? I remember listening to some of the songs on Return of Saturn in college and feeling so sad and angsty. It was nice intensely revisiting this album for the week.

And to circle back to the beginning of this "review," I think Gwen Stefani revealed a lot about herself on Return of Saturn. And I think that, at this point in her life, she's embraced the things she sang about on the album, like settling down and wanting a "simple man" (sorry Blake Shelton), things that may have seemed corny at the time. She's happy, which is cool in itself.

I also learned that, on a personal level, I have a much harder time being frank in my writing about music that I like, when compared to music that I absolutely despise or feel ambivalent towards. Especially an album that I picked. And this is likely because Record Club can be a tough crowd at times. As a member, I know this to be true, and regularly contribute to this overall feeling. Well, here I am on record: I really like this album, probably even more now that I've been listening to it non-stop for a week. Gwen Stefani is still a queen in my eyes.

No comments: