Haven't gotten much sleep lately. You know the deal. Plus, I had to get blood drawn at 1 PM after fasting all day, and then immediately went to Fergie's and had two Narragansett pounders (plus a cheeseburger). So you'll please excuse me for falling asleep on the El on the way home. Weird thing is, I woke up and had these notes written in my phone memo app about No Doubt's 2000 LP Return of Saturn. No idea how they got there. Figured I should try to make sense of 'em anyway.
Hmm, let's see. First note says "history of band." Gotta assume that this means my own personal history with the band, and not, ya know, the overall history of No Doubt. If you wanted the latter, you could just read Wikipedia. I'm definitely not your guy. The former can fit in a paragraph or two. Can't say that I've ever been a No Doubt "fan." I did, however, love their singles in back in the '90s. I remember being particularly obsessed with "Don't Speak" in like second grade. I was also really into Sideways Stories from Wayside School. The two are now conflated in my mind as the "art" that I liked that year. Through no fault of No Doubt, I've thus always considered them a little childish.
Maybe that's why I never really got into Tragic Kingdom as an adult (I'm talking about this album now because "tragic kingdom" is written in these notes, along with "second grade"). Too "childish"? Unfortunately so. The big hits (the aforementioned "Don't Speak," plus "Just a Girl" of course) have been in my life since I was a wee lad. They are great, but they make no impact on this 30-something-year-old sleepy boy.
Ah, okay, the notes say "pro/con big hits??" and I guess this is what that means? That I should talk the pluses and minuses of listening to an album that features familiar singles? Well, there's the negative—if your album features two or three songs that I'm already intimate with, then the other songs (known usually as "deep cuts") suffer because of that. But so here is the positive—Return of Saturn is an album with none of those distractions. Can't say that I've never heard any of these songs in my life, but none of them really received significant enough radio airplay in the early '00s that I, a twelve-year-old who pretty much exclusively consumed music via the radio on car rides, would have registered them in any significant way. Maybe "Simple Kind of Life"? But maybe not, I don't know. Point being that I'm coming into Return of Saturn fresh, and that's to its benefit. No distractions (well, no distractions with the music, and no need to discuss any distractions this week otherwise, you'll get enough of that soon enough on the blog I'm sure).
The next note says: "Uobeat? grungy on eg "artifical"? 90s sound? who cares?" I guess this is where I talk about what Return of Saturn sounds like. I'm also assuming that the typo is supposed to read "upbeat," and I'm supposed to note here that some of Return of Saturn is decidedly not upbeat. Like, not too many bright pop songs on this one ("Marry Me" and "Suspension Without Suspense" and so on). That's good. I like it. It helped mature my perception of this band. After Return of Saturn, I'm no longer thinking adjectives like "childish." The other misspelling in this note refers to "Artificial Sweetener," and how it definitely has a sort of grungy quality to it, especially with those guitars. That reads to me like the band stretching and doing something new. I'm into it.
Of course, then we're getting into the "genre" discussion. There's a note for that too: "ska? doc." I'm not usually a fan of dissection an album to try to figure out what "genre" it is. Seems like a waste of time to me, personally. But I am genuinely curious and interested when someone else does it. I like knowing how other people feel about music, and I like knowing why they feel that way. If someone calls this "ska," then that tells me a lot about that person. If someone pushes back against the idea of No Doubt being "ska," then that's interesting too. I watched a ska documentary called Pick It Up! a year or two ago, and I remember specifically a brief interlude in the doc in which the third-wave ska lifers were discussing No Doubt, and how weird it was that it was this particular band that made it big, since they weren't really ska music, and yet the music press ran with it anyway and called them "ska," and how the idea that this was the flag-bearer for a particular genre made uncomfortable the folks who were actually playing ska music as me and you might know it.
True, I didn't hear much ska on Return of Saturn. Maybe the horns on "Bathwater"? I don't really care to talk about my thoughts on the matter, but it's interesting to me that the ska community pushed back against music critics calling this "ska." I get the protectiveness of something that you feel like you're a part of, and the distress you might feel when someone takes that thing and exposes it to the world in a way that you might not approve of. But on the other hand, I feel like No Doubt is vindicated somewhat through Return of Saturn—this isn't ska, who gives a shit, it's great regardless of what you call you, etc.
Let's move onto the next note. "gwen now, colors perception?" This one also appears to speak to the idea of how time warps your opinion of art over long periods of time. Is it worth talking about Gwen Stefani post-2000? Do I even have the right to regurgitate Wikipedia back at you? Should any of this even matter in 2022? I don't know. But it's in the notes that appeared on this memo while I was asleep, so I have to at least touch on it.
I think The Voice is one of the worst television programs in history. Gwen Stefani is (was?) a big presence on that show, which is a shame. She got a husband out of it though, so I guess good for her? Blake Shelton is the sort of slick fake-backwoods country music star that I can't stand and will never trust, but they seem to be happy together, I guess (according to Pam vis-à-vis Gwen's Instagram). Not that this has a measurable impact on what Return of Saturn is supposed to be, even in retrospect, except to say that Gwen Stefani is clearly, at this point, part of the Great Pop Music Machine, through her boring country collaborations with her idiot husband, through her "brand" on some reality competition show (one that also gleefully featured rapist CeeLo Green, because the Great Pop Music Machine stops for no one), to say nothing of "B-A-N-A-N-A-S" and all that stuff... I'm just curious if all of that has a way of watering down this. And I have to say that I don't really think it does.
The tunes are there, even if they are melancholy. The thematic resonance is there too, which informs the sense of melancholy. None of this reads as false to me. And if this really was the last time that Gwen Stefani was open and honest and real through her music, then so be it. We have Return of Saturn. What a gift.
It really made me think too about what kind of headspace one needs to be in to create truly great art. There's a note for this too: "themes of domesticity, how does that hit?" Pretty clear throughout most of these songs that Gwen Stefani was hurting a little bit, conflicted by the desire to "settle down" while acknowledging that such an idea is difficult to consider when you're fronting one of the most popular rock bands of the '90s, always on the road, never stopping, never settling. I'm really glad that Stefani eventually had those experiences—three kids with the dude from Bush, then the aforementioned honeymoon with her Honey Bee—but I don't think that Return of Saturn would have been half the album it is had she been happy and had everything she ever wanted while she was making it. The desire fuels the art. Kinda like how this album review is kind of shitty because I have no complaints right now in my own life. There's no conflict. Conflict breeds good art. Good art isn't everything, but it's still cool to witness. Return of Saturn is good art.
Last note says "voice powerful," and I think this is probably the correct note to end with. Yes, Gwen Stefani's voice is powerful. It's a force of fucking nature. I'll admit that it took me till this week to really appreciate it, but I was constantly marveling over what she does with some of these songs. Her voice has this sort of plastic quality to it—soft enough to be pliable, hard enough to hold up skyscrapers. It's either the toughest coo or the softest growl. Either way, I love it. Just listen to "Comforting Lie." Just a completely dominate performance, as explosive as the bombs she's singing about.
Alright, I'm out of notes. A huge thank you to whoever wrote them in my phone while I was sleeping. They made for a disjointed review but at least I got it done. Can't imagine I'll be getting much sleep at all from now on, so we'll have to get back to writing reviews like a normal person next week.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment