Monday, October 24, 2022

Song of the Day: "Purgatory (Jubilee Version)"

A quick week of songs. See all of 'em HERE.


"Purgatory (Jubilee Version)"
Tyler Childers
from Can I Take My Hounds to Heaven?
2022

I like when music is extra. When it goes above and beyond. When it does more than necessary. When it takes an idea to its limit, and perhaps even past it. I like all that. I always have. The extra-ness of it all interests me. Flaws are okay when there's extra. The flaws make it interesting too. I'd rather have something be a huge epic fucking mess than have a tight little compact above-average piece of work.

I feel like you don't really see "extra" too much in the realm of country music. Maybe that's my own ignorance, not knowing the genre as well as others. But I've felt it recently in a couple albums. There was Ashley McBryde's trashy/fun country-opera Ashley McBryde Presents: Lindeville, which is worth your time, especially if you like concept albums. But I want to talk (extremely briefly) about Tyler Childers' new album today, if only because he is a Record Club alumnus and thus closer to my heart.

The "extra" aspect to this one, Can I Take My Hounds to Heaven?, is that not only is it a triple-album, but also each disc features the same eight songs, with each disc featuring the songs in a different style. Disc 1 is just five dudes in a room, jamming out. Disc 2 brings in the strings and the horns and really blows the whole thing wide open. Disc 3 replaces all the vocals with sound collages and random voice clips.

Really interesting! Especially when you consider the fact that, had Childers just released Disc 2 (the "Jubilee" version), he would've had another swell album under that reliable, dependent belt of his. But there's also Disc 1 ("Hallelujah" versions), which is good too but kind of act like demos, and Disc 3 ("Joyful Noise" versions), which is fucking terrible. It's borderline unlistenable. And that's cool! Not because I'll never listen to any of the eight Joyful Noise songs ever again, but because this country music artist is really swinging for the fences, trying something different. The failure of Disc 3 does not cancel out the joys of Disc 2. They enhance them. He throws everything at the wall, and only some of it sticks, and that's really fun to watch.

Now, one can make the argument that it's lazy too, that he only really had to write eight songs for this triple album (not even counting the fact that one of them is a redo of a song he's already released! the title track to our RC album to boot!), that he could've done more. Maybe. I dunno. I wouldn't have complained about having a rock-solid thirteen new songs from one of the best country music artists working today. But my point is that I'm also not complaining about this. Really interesting stuff. Thanks for keeping me on my toes when it comes to country music, Tyler.

Record Club Alumni Follow-Up
Can I Take My Hounds to Heaven? by Tyler Childers
Released: September 30, 2022
Follow-up to: Purgatory, Week 180

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5 (-0.5 from previous review)

No comments: