This is my uncle's favorite album. It's tough to view music in a vacuum with information like that. The context is unavoidable. The fact that I'm listening to this album and purposefully not asking him about it pretty much means I'm talking to the wall. And I'm not asking him about it now because I think the act of talking to a wall is interesting. More interesting than telling Uncle Pat "Hey I finally listened to John Prine's self-titled debut" and him going "Great album" and me going "Definitely" and then that's that.
The wall says this: how can we grapple with the fact that this can be someone's favorite album, and that someone is a trumper Republican, and thus pro-war, and that someone unabashedly loves an album that is both implicitly and explicitly anti-war?
The wall also asks for nuance: for instance, Uncle Pat is pro-union, and we often find a very small moment at any given K*** happy hour to commiserate on our mutual hatred of Yeungling due to their anti-union tendencies. If we lived in a black-and-white world, then one would assume that my uncle is anti-union, because the Republican Party is on record as despising unions.
So this is a matter of not living in a black-and-white world, the wall says. Fair. There is no consistency. Some people don't align all their beliefs with one single group. Some people support that group anyway. Some people are trumpers because of policy, e.g. anti-union or whatever. Uncle Pat seems to be a trumper because he is incredibly racist. Like, this isn't me making assumptions at all. He's made racist comments to me, I've pointed out to him that those comments are racist, and he's told me that he doesn't care.
Forget the wall for a second, and let me ask you this directly: how do you feel about loving a piece of art that someone who shares very few of your personal beliefs also loves? Dealbreaker, or nah?
The wall is back: what is with the need to police the fans of anything you like? Can't a piece of art just be good and worthy on its own?
Is argue no, but I'll give a caveat. Someone like Uncle Pat—who I love because he is family but who I also hold at arm's length because we find very little common ground—can like whatever he likes, but his opinions are going to make me question mine. No. Wait. Not question. Here's a better word: audit. I need to sincerely look at this John Prine album and ask myself: who's side is Prine on?
That question probably says more about me than about Prine or Pat. Like, the need for the artists I love to be on "my side," whatever the fuck that means, is kind of weird, no? But that's probably just an extension of the age old "art vs. artist" argument. When Paul Ryan blasts Rage Against the Machine in his car, then do we really need to audit RAtM, or can we just put up that defense mechanism and say that P.R. is a fucking moron who has never visited genius.com in his life (or, more depressingly, actually adheres to RAtM ideology in theory but has sold his soul so thoroughly that, in practice, he finds himself diametrically opposed to RAtM anyway).
The result of the audit: John Prine is on my side. But, see, the genius of John Prine is that he plays it so cool that you might be forgiven for not noticing, even if you were somebody's idea of a cliché racist uncle.
The man makes no judgments. Rather, he makes simple observations, and then cloaks them in humor. The thing about pro-war decals is a masterclass. The rage isn't pointed toward people who support the war machine, but rather toward those with hypocritical bumper stickers. That softens the blow. So does the absurdity (e.g. that one if those bumper stickers also ends up on his wife's forehead). It's clear to those who listen: war is unforgivable. But the calmness and simplicity and soft irony point toward a culprit nonetheless.
Bob Dylan once said that "Prine's stuff is our Proustian existentialism." It's worth staying my opinion here that Prine most likely one-ups Dylan with his lyrics; there is poetry here without ever having to assume that I needed a hit of the joint to understand it. He's right though: the lyrics are front and center here. The word is "profundity," and the fact that he is able to hit that adjective without seeming bookish or snobby is a rare goddamn feat.
I suppose that's where we circle back around. This is blue collar poetry. This is the type of lyrical genius that does not require Genius for the lyrics. You feel what John Prine feels, and you feel it strongly because he has that weird savant power to present his poetry as the word of The People.
So it makes sense that a blue collar worker would be really into this album. The fact that that particular blue collar worker also adheres to some really heinous shit speaks more to the propaganda abilities of the ruling class than anything else.

No comments:
Post a Comment