There's been a lot of chatter over the past few months on PoYB from various parties about the value of country music and whether old biases are still applicable and if there are country songs worth listening to in 2024 and whether this genre is just pure shit all the way down. So I figured I could use this space to give a brief State of the Union address, where I tell you definitively where I stand on the subject of country music, at least in this point in time.
I believe, as I have for some time, that the genre is bifurcated. There is Americana, which chases the artistry of old country, outlaw country, that sorta thing, while not necessarily sticking to the subject matters of those old songs, but finding new ground to cover using tried-and-tested country sounds. This is the country music that I like. Then there is pop country, which chases the formula of the modern day country song that seems to have found lots of commercial success, and which eschews many older country sounds in favor of sleeker, more modern, more pop-leaning aesthetics, and sticking to a more narrow range of subject matter. This is the bad country.
I've believed this for maybe a half-decade now, when I start getting into the former type, the Jason Isbell type of music, all that stuff. But what's changed recently is that I am starting to really, really, really fucking despise the latter sort of country music, the pop shit, the boilerplate generic bullshit that I am forced to listen to under certain circumstances. Can't stand it. It's the type of music that instantly makes me lose respect for you if you indulge in it in any way beyond irony or alcoholism.
The integral part of this argument is that my hatred is not a blanket emotion, and it does not cover all country music. To say "I dislike country music" would be disingenuous. I just really fucking hate a certain breed of country music. And that particular breed is undoubtedly the most popular, and thus my hatred of it tends to be more public-facing than my love of the good country music. And it's hard to distinguish between the two sub-genres beyond a simple gut reaction to hearing something and knowing which is which without being about to describe it, which seems unfair to country music but that's just the way it is.
My gut is telling me that Zac Brown Band makes music that is of the terrible, horrible, no good, very bad country music. I did not like this album.
Another name that people call pop country is "bro country," but I don't think that this name encapsulates all of the bad country. There is certainly a strain of country that consists of young male artists who make "country" music for other white people who are too afraid of Black people to listen to anything besides country. But there are pop country musician who operate outside of this definition whose music also sucks shit in very similar and perhaps less racist ways. Zac Brown is not bro country. Zac Brown is undeniably pop country.
It's funny, because avoiding the specific bro country tropes means that Zac Brown is able to say with a straight face such things as: "If I hear one more tailgate-in-the-moonlight, Daisy Duke song, I'm gonna throw up." Which is very funny, because, to my ears, Zac Brown Band traffics in the same goddamn subject matter that I hear in every goddamn bro country song on earth. Whisky and livin' the good life and chasing after a pretty girl. I'm not saying that these subjects automatically make for a bad song. They don't. I love the idea(l) of livin' the good life just as much as anyone. But there isn't anything more to it than this, is the problem. Talk about cliché.
I've believed this for maybe a half-decade now, when I start getting into the former type, the Jason Isbell type of music, all that stuff. But what's changed recently is that I am starting to really, really, really fucking despise the latter sort of country music, the pop shit, the boilerplate generic bullshit that I am forced to listen to under certain circumstances. Can't stand it. It's the type of music that instantly makes me lose respect for you if you indulge in it in any way beyond irony or alcoholism.
The integral part of this argument is that my hatred is not a blanket emotion, and it does not cover all country music. To say "I dislike country music" would be disingenuous. I just really fucking hate a certain breed of country music. And that particular breed is undoubtedly the most popular, and thus my hatred of it tends to be more public-facing than my love of the good country music. And it's hard to distinguish between the two sub-genres beyond a simple gut reaction to hearing something and knowing which is which without being about to describe it, which seems unfair to country music but that's just the way it is.
My gut is telling me that Zac Brown Band makes music that is of the terrible, horrible, no good, very bad country music. I did not like this album.
Another name that people call pop country is "bro country," but I don't think that this name encapsulates all of the bad country. There is certainly a strain of country that consists of young male artists who make "country" music for other white people who are too afraid of Black people to listen to anything besides country. But there are pop country musician who operate outside of this definition whose music also sucks shit in very similar and perhaps less racist ways. Zac Brown is not bro country. Zac Brown is undeniably pop country.
It's funny, because avoiding the specific bro country tropes means that Zac Brown is able to say with a straight face such things as: "If I hear one more tailgate-in-the-moonlight, Daisy Duke song, I'm gonna throw up." Which is very funny, because, to my ears, Zac Brown Band traffics in the same goddamn subject matter that I hear in every goddamn bro country song on earth. Whisky and livin' the good life and chasing after a pretty girl. I'm not saying that these subjects automatically make for a bad song. They don't. I love the idea(l) of livin' the good life just as much as anyone. But there isn't anything more to it than this, is the problem. Talk about cliché.
It was very interesting listening to this album alongside Johnny Blue Skies' newest album, Passage du Desir. "Johnny Blue Skies" is the new stage name for Sturgill Simpson, but I intend to take the name change seriously and consider this a brand new project. Still, I know it's Sturgill, and so I know that this is the "good country" that I spoke of earlier. But then so it was also pretty interesting to hear a couple songs that, had I not known any better, I might be tempted to slip into the "bad country" category.
Consider "Scooter Blues." A catchy country song about relaxing in a calming locale and kicking up the feet and grabbing a cold beverage and just relaxing, man. I can close my eyes and hear one thousand country songs on the radio that could cover this ground. A simple reading of it would be that Johnny Blue Skies is trafficking in pop country. The more enlightened among us know (or could pretend) that the deeper level to the song is the idea of escapism made literal, how "disappearing" is a metaphor for easy living and also a deep-seeded desire by a man who changed his whole goddamn name in an attempt to become someone different and gain some semblance of anonymity. Which is a meta take that you do not see in pop country. Stripping all that away, though... are we really going to say that Johnny Blue Skies is all that different than Zac Brown Band?
I don't know. All I can tell you at this juncture is that I like what I like and I hate what I hate, and that you shouldn't let tens of millions of words on a blog fool you into thinking I know what the fuck I am even talking about. I like Johnny Blue Skies. I mostly don't like Zac Brown Band. I think that "Chicken Fried" sucks shit (but is blissfully not on You Get What You Give). I know that I want to strangle myself with a pool noodle every time we're out by the pool and my parents play 92.5 WXTU.
Consider "Scooter Blues." A catchy country song about relaxing in a calming locale and kicking up the feet and grabbing a cold beverage and just relaxing, man. I can close my eyes and hear one thousand country songs on the radio that could cover this ground. A simple reading of it would be that Johnny Blue Skies is trafficking in pop country. The more enlightened among us know (or could pretend) that the deeper level to the song is the idea of escapism made literal, how "disappearing" is a metaphor for easy living and also a deep-seeded desire by a man who changed his whole goddamn name in an attempt to become someone different and gain some semblance of anonymity. Which is a meta take that you do not see in pop country. Stripping all that away, though... are we really going to say that Johnny Blue Skies is all that different than Zac Brown Band?
I don't know. All I can tell you at this juncture is that I like what I like and I hate what I hate, and that you shouldn't let tens of millions of words on a blog fool you into thinking I know what the fuck I am even talking about. I like Johnny Blue Skies. I mostly don't like Zac Brown Band. I think that "Chicken Fried" sucks shit (but is blissfully not on You Get What You Give). I know that I want to strangle myself with a pool noodle every time we're out by the pool and my parents play 92.5 WXTU.
I wonder how Kailyn found herself here. I know it's probably just the same ol' bullshit about her liking a Zac Brown Band song and randomly choosing the album its on as one of her quote-unquote "favorite albums." Honestly, on days like today, I'd prefer that. I'd prefer it to the idea that this poor woman was subjected, poolside, to country music so often that Stockholm syndrome started to settle in. Because that would result in me losing respect for this person I will never meet.
What I'd prefer is to believe a best case scenario, and that is: Kailyn has exactly one song on her playlist by Zac Brown Band, and that song is "Who Knows," and that was the song that she liked so much that she'll randomly name the album it's on as one of her favorite just to get some fucking Philly creep off her back. If she loves "Who Knows," then we can share some common ground here. "Who Knows" is the one. A ten-minute barn-burner that, if you ask me (and who's asking?), it sounds like Dave Matthews Band attempting to play ska. Brown even yells "pick it up! pick it up!" at the 4:15 mark, so I'm not going crazy with that descriptor. Marvel at that drum solo! You ever hear a drum solo like that in a fucking bro country song? I haven't.
So here's something that I'm willing to concede to, even though I've talked shit about it in the past. Saying you like an album based on one song? Sounds like bullshit, but in certain cases, I concede that it's the right move. But only if the song is that fucking good. I don't like You Get What You Give as a whole, but I'm sure glad I listened to it, because now I can say that I like one single Zac Brown Band song, and like one song makes it all worth it. And if Kailyn only likes one song, and felt the need to lie to me about liking the whole album, well then I say let bygones be bygones, because "Who Knows" makes a million lies and a million acts of deceit worth it.
Other than that, though? Fuck this country noise.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5
A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:
What I'd prefer is to believe a best case scenario, and that is: Kailyn has exactly one song on her playlist by Zac Brown Band, and that song is "Who Knows," and that was the song that she liked so much that she'll randomly name the album it's on as one of her favorite just to get some fucking Philly creep off her back. If she loves "Who Knows," then we can share some common ground here. "Who Knows" is the one. A ten-minute barn-burner that, if you ask me (and who's asking?), it sounds like Dave Matthews Band attempting to play ska. Brown even yells "pick it up! pick it up!" at the 4:15 mark, so I'm not going crazy with that descriptor. Marvel at that drum solo! You ever hear a drum solo like that in a fucking bro country song? I haven't.
So here's something that I'm willing to concede to, even though I've talked shit about it in the past. Saying you like an album based on one song? Sounds like bullshit, but in certain cases, I concede that it's the right move. But only if the song is that fucking good. I don't like You Get What You Give as a whole, but I'm sure glad I listened to it, because now I can say that I like one single Zac Brown Band song, and like one song makes it all worth it. And if Kailyn only likes one song, and felt the need to lie to me about liking the whole album, well then I say let bygones be bygones, because "Who Knows" makes a million lies and a million acts of deceit worth it.
Other than that, though? Fuck this country noise.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5
A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:
- Hybrid Theory by Linkin Park
- Masterpiece Theatre by Mariana Trench
- Don't You Fake It by Red Jumpsuit Apparatus
- Meteora by Linkin Park
- Red River Blue by Blake Shelton
- Boys Like Girls by BOYS LIKE GIRLS
- Steal This Album! by System of a Down
- Avenged Sevenfold by Avenged Sevenfold
- American Tragedy by Hollywood Undead
- Stadium Arcadium by Red Hot Chili Peppers
- Relapse by Eminem
- Strummin' On Garth by Brooks Jefferson
- You Get What You Give by Zac Brown Band
- Stand Up and Scream by Asking Alexandria
- Me and My Gang by Rascal Flatts


No comments:
Post a Comment