Prompt: "A song involving a fork or a knife or a spoon (unironically, please)"
Selected by Joe
"Something About the Real World"
Spencer Krug
I Just Drew This Knife, 2023
I've sat through at least three preschool assemblies in my adult life so far in which the children are called on one by one to proclaim what they'd like to be when they grow up. Most preschool shit is extremely cute but this particular ritual is cringe. The world is just so fucking open to you when you're four years old, just an overwhelming amount of paths forked out in infinite fractals from where you stand at that age, that saying what career you want to pursue is nothing but vanity for the adults watching, for them to pat themselves on the back and say "yes, these are good children, because they have chosen careers that in my opinion are worthy." You can be whatever you want to be, I'm not denying that. But are these kids really all gonna be firefighters and cops and doctors? And what are we trying to say when we reinforce this ritual? That if you don't become a doctor, that you're a failure? Maybe it wouldn't have rankled me so much in its last iteration if the guest speaker wasn't a fucking cop.
I just feel like there needs to be room in our society for all those people who don't necessarily know what they "want to do" and might possibly never figure that out. All the in-betweeners. And let's even forget about the common refrain of "well I wouldn't even want to work at all if I didn't have to," of course that's true, I hate working, but let's put that aside. Let's assume you have to work. And I do, that's true. But there was never, ever a job or career path for me that ever felt "right," ya know? Nothing that fit perfectly like a glove. I'm thinking of the scene from a recent episode of The Bear ***SPOILERS*** when Michael and Tina are talking about Carmy and marveling at the idea that he's always known what he wanted to do and was so fucking good at it. I don't have that. I imagine most people don't.
And yet we have to do something, and so many of us fall into careers that will never be spoken allowed at a fucking preschool assembly. I'm looking at the list of everyone who's done YSC this year in any regular capacity, and I'm counting three teachers, three nurses, two lawyers. That's basically it for "classic" jobs. The rest are working gigs that a preschooler wouldn't know about (and even "lawyer" is pushing it). I'm not speaking for anyone but myself, but I wonder how many of those eight people had an inkling to shout that job title out when they were in preschool. This obviously is a separate conversation than how much you like you're job or how good you are at your job—that can all happen while you're doing that job, like you can grow as a person or the job can grow on you or you can flourish right there in the thick of things. I'm more talking about the conversations we have with each other and with ourselves prior to making that decision. What do I want to be when I grow up? The question is fucking rigged. Let's stop asking our preschoolers about it.
In another sense, this question directed toward preschoolers is designed for their parents, because it makes them feel better when the parents are fucking clueless about how to guide the kids who don't have any inkling about what they want to do. Go back to the Carmy example. He's going to be a chef, right? Everyone knows this, ever since Carmy is a kid. In this specific regard, being his parent must have been pretty easy! It's easy to support a dream and a desire that can be defined and written down on paper. (That Carmy's parents were generally unhelpful/unsupportive is a separate issue.)
I'm trying to put myself in my own parents' shoes. I had potential, and they knew I had potential and articulated that I did, but the general question for all of us was "for what?" I didn't know then and I still don't know. And so if I were my parents, what would I have done for me? I don't have answers, and they probably didn't either. Paid tuition for a good high school, encouraged me to apply for the honors program in college, that kind of thing? Yes, that provides a bedrock so that opportunities are gonna be possible down the road, but as to what those opportunities would actually be is a different question, and certainly not one that a parent can answer for their child. And if that child grows up and still doesn't know, then at a certain point it starts to feel like wasted potential. And maybe everyone starts to accept that the potential will never actually be fulfilled, ya know? This is the only possible explanation I can come up with regarding the fact that, at the age of 23, my dad was encouraging me to apply to be a SEPTA janitor.
Because what the fuck else was he supposed to say? I never once, not since preschool, indicated that I was interested in any particular career, or cared at all about finding a passion and turning that passion into a career. I just don't have that within me. So I did what a lot of people do, and stumble around through a few different jobs, before finally one that is gonna be able to financially support what I needed supported without making me want to commit suicide. And I get to playact the part, get the master's and soon become a supervisor and speak intelligently about theory, pretend that this is "what I'm meant to do," even though we all know that isn't true. It can't be true because I'm not meant to do anything, at least nothing that I'm aware of yet.
All this is written through the lens of a particularly harrowing leadership decision last week that I already wrote my way around in my last YSC entry, so of course I'm going to be pessimistic about this shit at this current juncture. I'm leaving out a lot of the good stuff, by design. The stability, the concrete ability to affect (very) small change, the money that is just barely enough to keep the family functioning, the... something to write about obliquely in ostensibly music-based blog posts? I don't know.
I wonder if I'm being to hard on myself vis-à-vis labels. Like I'm bitching and moaning about not having a clear purpose in life, but maybe we don't have to in order to be happy. Knowing what you want to do in life when you're in preschool and having the ability to enact that desire because you're good at it and you have the support, that's fucking rare, and sort of a shortcut in life. Who the fuck am I to say that I shouldn't be down here in the muck and mire with the rest of us, fighting day-to-day through a job that is rarely emotionally fulfilling at all?
I'm wondering now (see, this is blogging therapy at work, in real time!) whether we can't give ourselves those labels, and fuck everyone else. That we get to switch out those labels at will, and that that's the real gift. Maybe knowing for certain at age four that you are going to be something and holding yourself to that for your entire life is actually a fucking CAGE. Like, maybe this is something I've fallen into, being a social worker with a master's degree and hopefully the wherewithal to hold on for another 28 years, but not make it something that necessarily defines me. That I can see this career and also define it as more of a way to sneak away on the computer and type about music on a blog for a few hours a day. That I can tell people I'm a social worker but really it's just a way to be a supportive father. That I'm meant for something different but just because I don't know what exactly that is yet doesn't mean that I have to be so fucking miserable or feel lost.
Something about this song feels poignant in this particular way (though, of course, it might just be the drunk ramblings of a mad genius too, I don't know). How the artist draws a knife, but then indicates that it's also a real knife. Or how he sees light protruding from a small hole and calls it a star, and how even though it's not a star, the fact that he defines it as a star makes it a star. The idea of a four-year-old defining their lives in this brutally capitalistic way gives me the heebie-jeebies, but I guess there's nothing actually wrong with it. Because we define our own lives however we want. And if a four-year-old wants to say that she wants to be a doctor even though she's probably not gonna be a doctor, then that's no different than me saying that I'm a social worker even though most days I don't feel like I am a social worker or even want to be a social worker. None of this shit matters. Call it whatever you want. You have the power to define it however you want to. If you say it's a star, then that single dot must be a star.
I'm trying to put myself in my own parents' shoes. I had potential, and they knew I had potential and articulated that I did, but the general question for all of us was "for what?" I didn't know then and I still don't know. And so if I were my parents, what would I have done for me? I don't have answers, and they probably didn't either. Paid tuition for a good high school, encouraged me to apply for the honors program in college, that kind of thing? Yes, that provides a bedrock so that opportunities are gonna be possible down the road, but as to what those opportunities would actually be is a different question, and certainly not one that a parent can answer for their child. And if that child grows up and still doesn't know, then at a certain point it starts to feel like wasted potential. And maybe everyone starts to accept that the potential will never actually be fulfilled, ya know? This is the only possible explanation I can come up with regarding the fact that, at the age of 23, my dad was encouraging me to apply to be a SEPTA janitor.
Because what the fuck else was he supposed to say? I never once, not since preschool, indicated that I was interested in any particular career, or cared at all about finding a passion and turning that passion into a career. I just don't have that within me. So I did what a lot of people do, and stumble around through a few different jobs, before finally one that is gonna be able to financially support what I needed supported without making me want to commit suicide. And I get to playact the part, get the master's and soon become a supervisor and speak intelligently about theory, pretend that this is "what I'm meant to do," even though we all know that isn't true. It can't be true because I'm not meant to do anything, at least nothing that I'm aware of yet.
All this is written through the lens of a particularly harrowing leadership decision last week that I already wrote my way around in my last YSC entry, so of course I'm going to be pessimistic about this shit at this current juncture. I'm leaving out a lot of the good stuff, by design. The stability, the concrete ability to affect (very) small change, the money that is just barely enough to keep the family functioning, the... something to write about obliquely in ostensibly music-based blog posts? I don't know.
I wonder if I'm being to hard on myself vis-à-vis labels. Like I'm bitching and moaning about not having a clear purpose in life, but maybe we don't have to in order to be happy. Knowing what you want to do in life when you're in preschool and having the ability to enact that desire because you're good at it and you have the support, that's fucking rare, and sort of a shortcut in life. Who the fuck am I to say that I shouldn't be down here in the muck and mire with the rest of us, fighting day-to-day through a job that is rarely emotionally fulfilling at all?
I'm wondering now (see, this is blogging therapy at work, in real time!) whether we can't give ourselves those labels, and fuck everyone else. That we get to switch out those labels at will, and that that's the real gift. Maybe knowing for certain at age four that you are going to be something and holding yourself to that for your entire life is actually a fucking CAGE. Like, maybe this is something I've fallen into, being a social worker with a master's degree and hopefully the wherewithal to hold on for another 28 years, but not make it something that necessarily defines me. That I can see this career and also define it as more of a way to sneak away on the computer and type about music on a blog for a few hours a day. That I can tell people I'm a social worker but really it's just a way to be a supportive father. That I'm meant for something different but just because I don't know what exactly that is yet doesn't mean that I have to be so fucking miserable or feel lost.
Something about this song feels poignant in this particular way (though, of course, it might just be the drunk ramblings of a mad genius too, I don't know). How the artist draws a knife, but then indicates that it's also a real knife. Or how he sees light protruding from a small hole and calls it a star, and how even though it's not a star, the fact that he defines it as a star makes it a star. The idea of a four-year-old defining their lives in this brutally capitalistic way gives me the heebie-jeebies, but I guess there's nothing actually wrong with it. Because we define our own lives however we want. And if a four-year-old wants to say that she wants to be a doctor even though she's probably not gonna be a doctor, then that's no different than me saying that I'm a social worker even though most days I don't feel like I am a social worker or even want to be a social worker. None of this shit matters. Call it whatever you want. You have the power to define it however you want to. If you say it's a star, then that single dot must be a star.
No comments:
Post a Comment