Prompt: "A song that feels specifically written for you"
Selected by Joe
"Float On"
Modest Mouse
Good News for People Who Love Bad News, 2004
Oh yikes, already the third Modest Mouse pick for ol' Joey here. That was not intentional. Counting Dave's pick of maybe Modest Mouse's best song (without him actually mentioning the song, which, sure, that's probably for the best, let us keep "Missed the Boat" preserved in amber for its own protection), we have most phases covered. Meanwhile, poor Nate is over here constrained to just 2021's The Golden Casket, and is left to pledge fealty to Modest Mouse via some Bandcamp filler. I don't really know what to say here. I like Modest Mouse but could definitely do some work in reeducating myself on the deeper cuts on the less popular albums.
"Float On," on the other hand, is their biggest song on probably their biggest album, speaking in terms of popularity and general seepage into the public consciousness. It's the song from the hitherto niche NW indie rock weirdos that somehow snuck through the door and became a worldwide hit. The one that everyone knows. There will be no one reading this blog post today that will not be able hum along as they hear the tune, for what will probably be the 900th time in their lives. I'm not out here trying to purposefully pick popular songs for these prompts, nor am I wringing my hands in an attempt to find something unknown and new and unheard of. I'm just going from the gut here. And I'm saying that "Float On," both at a specific time in my life and also in some ways even now, feels like a song that was written for me.
"Float On," on the other hand, is their biggest song on probably their biggest album, speaking in terms of popularity and general seepage into the public consciousness. It's the song from the hitherto niche NW indie rock weirdos that somehow snuck through the door and became a worldwide hit. The one that everyone knows. There will be no one reading this blog post today that will not be able hum along as they hear the tune, for what will probably be the 900th time in their lives. I'm not out here trying to purposefully pick popular songs for these prompts, nor am I wringing my hands in an attempt to find something unknown and new and unheard of. I'm just going from the gut here. And I'm saying that "Float On," both at a specific time in my life and also in some ways even now, feels like a song that was written for me.
I acknowledge that saying as much comes anchored to a certain lack of a humility. That's what the word "me" will do to ya in a prompt. There are no songs in the universe literally written for me. But some of the most popular songs are popular because they are able to trick the audience into believing that it was written for them. Like, that's the whole point. It's empathy in action. You, the musician, are writing a song that the audience can relate to. If they can relate to it, then they are by and large going to enjoy listening to it. I have a weird, small memory of my aunt-not-related saying something like "Every time me and [my daughter's friend] are in the car together, 'Hey Ya!' comes on the radio, it's like it's our song!" This was at the height of "Hey Ya!"'s power. It wasn't written for anyone, it was just playing all the time. You turn on the car and the song was most likely gonna be on, didn't matter which of your kid's pals was in the car.
But convincing yourself that it's a personal thing is the fun in it. It's part of what makes music fun in general. You put your earbuds in and you think that the artist is speaking to you directly. You go to a concert and you can convince yourself that the frontman is staring straight at you. I've always viewed music as a personal, private, secret activity (with the blog akin to "sharing a secret"), and so of course there are going to be plenty of songs that feel personal, to me, that are there for me when I need them, that are designed for me and me alone. That's the magic.
My own moment with "Float On" occurred in college, so we assume I am extremely intoxicated. It's freshman year and I'm intoxicated, so we assume I am sitting in a dorm room on the second floor of St. Albert. I'm sitting in a St. Albert dorm room and I'm sad, so we assume that I had just broken up with my first college girlfriend, or was about to, or something along those lines. I'm drunk and sad and sitting in a dorm room and feel so damn alone and "Float On" comes on the speakers.
Now you should know something about "Float On." It's meant to be ironic. It's meant to be viewed as satire. Intended reaction: "Psh, we all float on? Get fucking real. Have you seen the ugliness of this world?" Isaac Brock himself has admitted that it was more of a writing exercise than anything else, that he certainly wasn't feeling very optimistic in the mid-'00s, when substance abuse was tightening its grip and a bunch of unruly teens broke his jaw. The song's own fucking video undercuts any chance at sincerity when it portrays all those willing to partake in the cliché of "we all float on" as sheep for the slaughter.
So does that make me stupid, to find a way to appreciate the song's message in an unironic fashion? I don't think so. Especially if the irony is noted first, before being ignored. On that (let's call it a) Thursday night in freshman year of college, drunk and sad, and I found solace in the message. The opening clicks of the song found me sitting slumped in a chair with a warm cup of Jägermeister/Monster in my hand, but by the time Brock is yelping into the night about things being a bit to heavy and not worrying about it, I was up out of the chair, jumping around the room, a few college pals in tow, feeling just a little bit better about life and my hopes for its immediate future. I was floating.
I don't care if that's not what Isaac Brock intended. Music is a personal thing, and in that moment, I made it personal. All irony was discarded in favor of feeling better. I can't be the only one who feels like this song was written for them. I can't be, or else I probably wouldn't be talking about it right now.
So does that make me stupid, to find a way to appreciate the song's message in an unironic fashion? I don't think so. Especially if the irony is noted first, before being ignored. On that (let's call it a) Thursday night in freshman year of college, drunk and sad, and I found solace in the message. The opening clicks of the song found me sitting slumped in a chair with a warm cup of Jägermeister/Monster in my hand, but by the time Brock is yelping into the night about things being a bit to heavy and not worrying about it, I was up out of the chair, jumping around the room, a few college pals in tow, feeling just a little bit better about life and my hopes for its immediate future. I was floating.
I don't care if that's not what Isaac Brock intended. Music is a personal thing, and in that moment, I made it personal. All irony was discarded in favor of feeling better. I can't be the only one who feels like this song was written for them. I can't be, or else I probably wouldn't be talking about it right now.
No comments:
Post a Comment