Prompt: "A song that feels specifically written for you"
Selected by Nate
"She's Leaving You"
MJ Lenderman
Manning Fireworks, 2024
"It falls apart, we've all got work to do / It gets dark, we've all got work to do." This is the ultimate universal truth of the universe, of existence and consciousness. The Russian authors knew it, and MJ Lenderman knows it. It's a sentiment that reads as pessimistic, but there's an optimism in it if you allow yourself to see it. All there is in this life is what's in front of you, and the value to be found is in doing the best you can, not for a reward, but because the alternative is to do less. If this is all there is, if this is all you get, why not do what you can when you can regardless of the weights and the tar and the shadow and the fear. Life is a side-scroller and you can pause on the screen if you want but eventually the programming kicks in and you get shuffled along to the right.
I informally left Catholicism in my early 20s, and this philosophy is as close to religion as I have come in the time since. Here's a song we'll play during service, which largely consists of a bunch of us sitting around talking about what hurts and what's hard and laughing where there's room to laugh and patting each other on the back when it's called for and we'll sip coffee and say "but what can you do, right?" then we'll shuffle up the steps and out into our lives because we've all got work to do. It's really easy to slide into dark and self-pitying places, even when that slide is starting to feel less theoretical and more inevitable.
Man, I'm not saying this right. I'm writing this on Tuesday July 16, and in the month or so a lot of dark and bad shit has been going down in American governance. It's the kind of stuff that makes me want to panic, then to be cynical and snarky with myself because I'm being so panicked, then to retreat into the security of my privilege to find manufactured and false comfort in the idea that nothing bad will happen to me, except a lot of bad shit seems likely to happen to a lot of people exactly like me and just because the falcon doesn't claw my eyes out doesn't mean I shouldn't be working on getting the falconer a megaphone or something. That metaphor is working overtime but the point I'm trying to circle around to is that this song works as both the short-term balm and the long-term balm. Short term: what can you do? What can anyone do? It gets dark, we've all got work to do. Long term: The only salvation is the one you make for yourself, the only strength is in the one you work to organize and support, so wallowing will not help and being unwilling to pick up the bare minimum tools at one's disposal, even if you do not think those tools will work, is the reason people are so easily defeated. It falls apart, we've all got work to do.
This is putting a lot of uncatalogued anxiety—not to mention the absence of spirituality that I genuinely believe is having a deteriorative effect on communities and individuals—on what is basically just a down-beat Ben Kweller song. Thank god it has the bones to support all this weight. Such is Lenderman's gift, such is the chemistry of being a specific kind of white guy in your late 30s. Why go to therapy when you've got Lenderman (this is joke, do not show this blog to any mental health professionals). Joe, I know you're going to put the "emo" tag on this, I will meet you in the octagon for physical combat and will deliver a devastating shin-kick to your hip.
3 comments:
I remain nonplussed every time someone acknowledges the existence of the blog tags. I always just assume no one knows they exist. They are a helpful way to organize!
Here's my take on the "Emo" tag. Back in the early days of the blog, during those first few times I dipped my toe into writing about the self in an honest and possibly therapeutic way, I was accused of being "too emo." So the tag name is just a way to lean into that. "Emo" is both sincere (it's for blog posts that are emotional in some way) and also slightly ironic (in that everyone who thinks that a blog post could ever be "too emo" can go suck a fat chode).
I am always happy to apply the Emo tag because that means that the writer was brave enough to write about themselves in a hopefully emotionally healing way.
I know that you, Nate, would vastly prefer to be snarky and pithy and ironically detached in your blog posts, and an "emo" tag on your post means that it wasn't that, that it was instead heartfelt and revealing and courageous, and that makes you uncomfortable. But I also want you to know that I attach the tag with love and appreciation, no octagon required.
You will also be nonplussed when I throw you into a hammerlock in front of your wife and children, who will be forced to the octogon to watch me make bloodsport of you.
I don’t know what a rear naked choke is but you should put him in it because it’s funny to say
Post a Comment