Wednesday, July 24, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 103: Joe

Prompt: "A live song that sounds totally different than the original studio version"

Selected by Joe


"Your Fool"
Natalie Prass
World Café Live, 11/11/15

My thought is that the live version needs to be from the same artist, and not just another artist covering it live to make it sound different (since we already kinda did the covers thing, ya know?), so that disqualifies Jim O'Rourke's 33-minute version of "Fast Car," which would've been real fun, to see how many people listened to the whole thing today. I've listened to that version once in my life. Please press play if you overdid it with the Luke Combs version last year, and desire to feel your brain get wiped like magnets on a hard drive.

My thought is that the live version needs to do more than just add to the song. Something needs to be changed, as in subtracted and then morphed and then added back in. If you were talking just "different," well then every live version is different from every studio version. That's like saying "find a snowflake that's different." This is disqualifies something like Led Zeppelin's 23-minute version of "Whole Lotta Love," which simply adds a bunch of other blues songs into the middle, but doesn't change the chemical makeup of the song itself when they deign to play it.

My thought along the same lines is that this would disqualify anything that simply speeds it up a little bit, or adds an intro, or both. I was originally thinking the song "I Want You" performed by Bob Dylan and Grateful Dead off the 1989 live album Dylan & the Dead, which always enamored me by the way the Dead graft that interesting little guitar rift to the beginning of the song before everyone stumbles into a 1.2x-speed version of the Dylan deep cut. But when I was listening to it, I didn't feel like it was "totally different" enough just based on those two things. And maybe I'm a little worried that the live version might be the first time you've ever heard the song, which is an idea that makes me uncomfortable for reasons that aren't worth extrapolating on today.

My thought is that I probably shouldn't have written about the song before, which eliminates some other Dylan stuff. But with my mind roiling with all these thoughts about classic Bob Dylan live music fuckery, I figure it's probably time to check out that Bob Dylan at Budokan album that promises some wild and unexpected arrangements. Ah, when I have the time, when I have the time!

My thoughts turn to Natalie Prass. Pam and I still play her debut self-titled probably once a month. One of my favorite albums of the 2010s. It's full of lush arrangements, all kinds of strings and horns piled on top of what might have been a sort of a coffee house-ish folk album otherwise. We liked it a lot back in 2015, and decided to check her out at World Café Live when she came to town. This was several lifetimes ago.

I'm just realizing now that this concert that we attended was not included in the running total of concerts that I've attended in my life. Seems like a pretty major oversight, and makes me wonder what else from my life that I've forgotten. I'll make sure to update that fucker after this current post is published. That way I can link back to this thing I'm writing now, and not repeat my apologies. It's all connected here on the blog.

But the interesting thing about this show was that she was traveling as a four-person band. Just Natalie Prass (vocals, backing guitar), and a guitarist/bassist/drummer combo. If you listen to her album, you'll hear a lot more sounds than just guitar and bass and percussion. It sounds like a whole damn orchestra is behind her for most of the songs. But that would be financially unfeasible to even consider for a touring outfit, and so the foursome just had to change the arrangements for every single song. It was a fascinating transformation, mostly because of how great the songs still sounded.

The above video is the only one I could find on YouTube from the show we were at, but it works. Typically, "Your Fool" has this real pretty bridge that using the strings as a rhythm with a cool staccato trumpet pattern that sticks to your brain for a long time. Here, the guitarist fills the space with a sweet guitar solo, and it sounds like it's always been part of the song. I like it a lot. I'll always prefer the studio version, of course, but I'm thrilled that the circumstances of live music forced musicians to improvise and change and make something completely new, right before our very eyes. If it wasn't for this video, I would've never heard that song again! How weird is that to think about?

Here's my take on live music, since I know some snarky asshole is going to mention it, is that I've usually been pretty uncomfortable with the whole fucking ritual. But that take is evolving, especially recently, in sobriety. Not using alcohol as a crutch meant reevaluating literally everything I do in a social manner. The vast majority of it got a lot worse and then gradually started to get better. I found at the King Tuff concert that attending a concert with friends was one of the few things that immediately got just a little bit better.

Not so better that I'm going to see a band play every week (clearly, if Los Camps! has been the only other concert I've been to in the past sixteen months), but noticeably different in subtly positive ways. For one, I was able to see the entire concert instead of blacking out halfway through. For another, I found that the anxiety about large crowds maaaaybe had more to do with the anxiety of needing to drink in that (and every) social situation than the crowds themselves. Of course, I also can't feel that cathartic release of yelling song lyrics with reckless abandon, since reckless abandon seems to, as far as I can tell within myself, require alcohol, but I have no choice but to accept that particular loss, and lean into the idea of standing stoically in the back of the room and still yelling along to some choice lyrics but maybe with fewer fists in the air and less slobber dribbling down my chin.

I'm starting to sincerely appreciate the ritual, is basically what I'm trying to say here. Don't love it, but appreciate it. I can appreciate the act of seeing something new. I can really appreciate the act of seeing something that is precious and will possibly never be seen again. That's what I think about when I think about that Natalie Prass concert. I think about how utterly charmed I was by this talented musician who was forced under specific circumstances to strip away the sound that made her known (to me and Pam, anyway), and made something totally new and just as worthy and just as great, and most importantly, something that will never get to experience again. Unless someone uploads it on YouTube or whatever.

No comments: