Monday, July 15, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 96: Joe

Prompt: "A cover that just hits better than the original"

Selected by Joe


"Day Tripper"
Otis Redding
Complete & Unbelievable: The Otis Redding Dictionary of Soul, 1966

Okay, alright, let's clear the air. Thanks for having me. I, um... I can't believe I have to say this, but covering someone's song is not "stealing" their music. Which is just such a fucking weird thing to think, but I have legitimately heard that opinion in the past month or so. We were listening to Otis Redding (The Soul Album, not Dictionary of Soul), and person in question—I don't know, I don't think I should tell you who it was—was like "Oh, this is Three Dog Night." Like, insistence that it was Three Dog Night, even though I have an iPod and I take great pains in tagging everything correctly and you can clearly see that it is Otis Redding, on top of the fact that there is no one else on earth who has ever sounded like Otis Redding, ya know? Especially not Three Dog motherfucking Night. It took a hot minute to parse through where the (okay—drunken) misconception came from. "Try a Little Tenderness," for which Otis Redding I think objectively has the most popular version, was also covered, with relatively similar commercial success, by Three Dog Night. #25 peak on the Hot 100 for Otis, and #29 peak for 3DG, but we can all agree which one has stood the test of time. But, like, the song isn't even on The Soul Album! Which is what we were listening to, I swear. The only Three Dog Night song I have on the iPod is "Shambala" because of its use in one of the most gleeful episodes of Lost, the one where they fix up the van. I'm listening to their version of "Try a Little Tenderness" now for probably the first time in my life, and okay, fine, it's not all that completely different. I could see how, if it came on the radio, you might think for a few seconds that it was Otis Redding's version, before realizing your error. But c'mon. Come the fuck on. Let's not compare Three Dog Night to Otis Redding, in any capacity. Three Dog Night is a glorified cover band. Otis Redding is one of the Kings of Soul. Come on. And but so the "stealing" thing was what got me. It wasn't just that there was a misconception that the Otis Redding music we were listening to was actually Three Dog Night. It was the insistence now that Otis Redding must have stolen from Three Dog Night. An insane conclusion to be made under any circumstance, let alone this specific one, with Otis fucking Redding, one of the most distinctive voices in music history. I don't know why I care at this point in those situations with this person but I do and I did and so I found myself pontificating on the subject, how it was pretty common practice in the '60s and beyond to have professional songwriters who did not perform the songs themselves but instead passed them out to established artists, and that because of this, sometimes multiple artists found hits with the same song. I even pulled up the Wikipedia page for "Try a Little Tenderness," read off the names—Jimmy Campbell, Reg Connelly, Harry M. Woods—of those who wrote the song, none of whom are Otis Redding or Danny Hutton or Chuck Negron or Cory Wells, and so if anything, the King of Soul and the frontmen of Three Dog Night were stealing from songwriters who had written the song... but so it obviously wasn't stealing at all, is the thing, because that would be insane. I didn't even get into the fact that this is still how pop music largely operates today, with songwriters working with certain pop stars and letting those stars take the stage while the songwriters stay largely in the shadows. No one is stealing from Max Martin or Jack fucking Antonoff or whatever. But I didn't bring up the modern day pop music point because that would've muddied the already muddy waters in this conversation, which was quickly going off the deep end as the box of pinot grigio got lighter and lighter. No one was listening to me at this point, as usual in those situations, and somehow it devolved into a séance eventually, but here, at the tail end of the discussion, monologuing for no one, and thus porting the monologue over to you, my crowd today, rapt in ways that I could never command with the Three Dog Night-ers, I say: a cover is really only worth it if you're doing something different with it anyway. Even if Otis Redding had written this song and Three Dog Night had covered it, the cover would be inessential because it sounds too much like the "original" version. It can't be theft because covering a song presents a great opportunity to make new music. New, in a sense. New because all music is some recreation of music that came before it, but with slightly different variants and alternate energy sources, it becomes new. If you can't tell it's a cover then the band who's covering it didn't do their job! Take this Otis Redding cover that I chose for you today. Not even the person I've been talking about (still won't specifically indicate who) could mistake this song for the Beatles' original. You can tell that it's same song because it follows a similar structure and has mostly the same lyrics and, I don't know, chords? (I know very little about music composition.) But this is Otis Redding through and through. He turns up the heat, and uses his voice as the blowtorch (the tempo is the stovetop on which it rests). This doesn't mean that the Beatles' "Day Tripper" gets cancelled out, and it doesn't mean that Otis Redding was doing them some great disservice by making a subjectively better version. Otis Redding is just doing what every musician since two minutes after the beginning of time has done—he took something that already existed, and made it new again. People are too possessive about that shit. That's how you get stupid lawsuits, and that's how you get in really stupid arguments. If it was Otis Redding who really was taking a true Three Dog Night original song and performing a cover of it, then I have no doubt that Otis Redding would've done the same goddamn thing he does here. He would've taken that really good Three Dog Night song and made it sound motherfucking legendary. But he didn't steal shit, so let's drop it. Okay? Okay?

1 comment:

Joe K said...

Interesting dichotomy today between "cover songs that have supplanted the original songs in the pop culture consciousness" vs. "cover songs that I just personally think are better than the original." No wrong answers, I just thought it was interesting that this was a prompt that people went in two different directions for, which I was not expecting.