Thursday, December 12, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 171: Allison

Prompt: "A song that you believe sucks but that you fear will be reclaimed by future generations as a bellwether or high-water mark of the era"

Selected by Allison


"My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys"
The Tortured Poets Department, 2024

Now that the Eras Tour era is over, maybe we can stop talking about Taylor Swift? I'm tired of Taylor! Taylor overload! We, as a group, have already written about 21 Taylor Swift songs, and I'm a part of the problem. I returned to my first post about Taylor, where I (and three others) chose a song of hers as "a song in between that best song and worst song, in terms of quality." Remember January? We were so young. Of Taylor Swift, I said, "I don't like her, but I can't fault anyone for liking her. She's fine. She's catchy. Who am I to say she's bad? But it's not for me." I stand by it. Nearly a year later, nothing's changed. So why am I still talking about Taylor Swift? Is this a cheap shot at the most popular female artist of all time? Is this jealousy? Is this toxic pick-me behavior? Do I not support women? As Lala Kent said to Raquel during the Season 7 Vanderpump Rules Reunion, "Just because you have a vagina doesn't mean I'm going to support you." These timeless words (that I'm certain couldn't possibly age poorly) sum up my feelings about Taylor Swift. You do you, boo.

4 comments:

Allison said...

Is this a tired take? Yes, but so am I!

Joe K said...

I disagree. There's still meat on these bones, and we're gonna pick 'em clean in the next nine days. Especially if it's framed like a "full circle" kind of thing: Remember how much we liked Taylor Swift on Day 1? And just think, all it took was one year and 20+ forced listens of her songs to change everything!

Sara said...

As the president of the “I hate Taylor swift club” I endorse this message.

Maeve said...

This take is correct! And I know I've said this is my favorite album of hers, but this song is a big ole yawn.