I don't know if there's value in reviewing something after one listen. Honestly, if it gets to the point where I'm only listening to an RC follow-up album once and then writing a review, then that most likely means that I wasn't all that interested in listening to the album more than once in the first place. See: the albums below.
Listening once is more than the average number of listens that the general public of the United States is going to give it, which hovers close to zero. I'm doing my best here. If you are getting butthurt because I'm not giving the Black Keys enough attention, then I welcome you to write your own review. I would sincerely get on my hands and knees and thank you and kiss your feet in thanks if I ever received a review for one of these albums. Please, send them over.
Released: March 28, 2025
Follow-up to: Set My Heart on Fire Immediately, Week 68
I don't have a good handle on this artist. I gave the RC album a few extra listens this past May for its RC@5 entry, and I came to mostly the same conclusion I did the first time around—pretty decent, a couple great songs surrounded by strained attempts at gravitas. I don't remember his next album at all, but PoYB documentation shows that it was boring as shit except for one song that apparently sounded like Squarepusher? That's interesting.
But so here we are for another set with Perfume Genius, and I'm determined to take it seriously and not escape with some cheap Pagliacci joke again. I am writing this review as I listen for the first time. As I'm writing this sentence, I'm at the end of the second song, "No Front Teeth." This and the first song, "It's a Mirror," are shockingly great! Wow! "It's a Mirror" had a great rhythm that maybe past experiences with Perfume Genius lacked, and now "No Front Teeth" is building up to something pretty crazy! The drums! Again: wow!
Okay, checking in after another three songs. Nothing even close to where those first two went. I think that "Left for Tomorrow" is interesting in the way the rhythms are busy in a jazz sort of way, but I also think that ultimately the drums are window dressing in that one. I don't know if I can maintain my faith in Glory. In the good songs v. bad songs, we're already in the red, after such a strong start.
And now I'm almost at the end. Sorry, gang, it's been a slog. "In a Row" has some tense moments, but even mentioning them here constitutes me grasping for straws. I have two songs left. Either one of them surprises me like the first two, or we continue down this path and I continue my life as a Perfume Genius skeptic. Let's see...
Noooo, damn, they were the slowest ones on the album. Absolutely wild sequencing on this album. Though I don't know if placing "It's a Mirror" or "No Front Teeth" somewhere in the middle would've fixed anything, because didn't we see such sequencing with "Without You" and "On the Floor"? Those songs couldn't save the RC album, and these good songs can't save another mediocre (or rather, "not for me") effort by Perfume Genius. Sorry, friends. I'm not into this.
And now I'm almost at the end. Sorry, gang, it's been a slog. "In a Row" has some tense moments, but even mentioning them here constitutes me grasping for straws. I have two songs left. Either one of them surprises me like the first two, or we continue down this path and I continue my life as a Perfume Genius skeptic. Let's see...
Noooo, damn, they were the slowest ones on the album. Absolutely wild sequencing on this album. Though I don't know if placing "It's a Mirror" or "No Front Teeth" somewhere in the middle would've fixed anything, because didn't we see such sequencing with "Without You" and "On the Floor"? Those songs couldn't save the RC album, and these good songs can't save another mediocre (or rather, "not for me") effort by Perfume Genius. Sorry, friends. I'm not into this.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5 (-1.0 from original review)
Released: April 18, 2025
Follow-up to: Hadsel, Week 259
I suppose it's pretty interesting that this album was commissioned by a Swedish circus. In the promo material, Beirut's Zach Condon acknowledges that it might be unwise for an already fanciful, circus-like indie act to lean into its reputation like that, but the hope was that the music would overcome it, I guess.
Look, this is some beautiful shit. It definitely brings me away from here, in the same way that Hadsel brought me away from a shitty basement office and in the same way that "Elephant Gun" brought me away from all the pedestrian concerns of dorm life in college. Beauty is something that pulls your concentration away from whatever it was you're doing and toward the thing that is beautiful. Beirut's music is still, and always has been, beautiful.
But I dunno, man, I'm not into this time around. It's too long, for one. Condon works with a No No No collaborator again on this one, but I feel like they both forgot the lessons learned on that great album—keep it small, keep it simple, the beauty will still be there. It's like fractals. If fractals are beautiful, then they are beautiful at any size, since they repeat both inward and outward, and so why not keep it small and manageable? This attempts to be too large. It's not playing to Beirut's strengths. But that's just my opinion.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5 (-1.0 from original review)
Released: August 8, 2025
Follow-up to: Dropout Boogie, Week 176
Aw damn, we gotta do this again? And so soon? Feels like just yesterday I was explaining how the RC album was overrated because it dropped for us right before the implosion of the Black Keys. And now, what, they're gonna just keep releasing music? And I'm gonna have to keep writing about it? Credit where it's due, I suppose: if I had the means to make music for the rest of my life, just follow my bliss and fuck around with friends, then I would do it in a fucking heartbeat. I couldn't blame these knuckleheads if they decided to make a new album every year for the rest of their lives. I'd hate it, but I couldn't get mad.
The "hook" with this latest is that they invited a bunch of established songwriters into the studio and had them put together the whole album. It's actually kinda fascinating if you go through the credits on Wikipedia. I've never heard of any of these guys, and yet, every single one of them has a Wikipedia page that includes in the intro paragraph the fact that they were inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame. So I guess that's the point that I've never heard of them—these dudes all write for other people. That's their job. And they've clocked in and clocked out on a new Black Keys album, and have created some competent songs that the Black Keys have played competently.
The "hook" with this latest is that they invited a bunch of established songwriters into the studio and had them put together the whole album. It's actually kinda fascinating if you go through the credits on Wikipedia. I've never heard of any of these guys, and yet, every single one of them has a Wikipedia page that includes in the intro paragraph the fact that they were inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame. So I guess that's the point that I've never heard of them—these dudes all write for other people. That's their job. And they've clocked in and clocked out on a new Black Keys album, and have created some competent songs that the Black Keys have played competently.
Nothing says "great album!" than a music critic using the word "competent" twice in one sentence, am I right?! What else can you say, though, about songs that were written by songwriters-for-hire and performed by a couple of crypto sellout jabronis? These aren't bad songs. They also don't even necessarily have to have been Black Keys songs. It's shockingly easy to listen to something like "Man on a Mission" and imagine it being sung by, like, Miley Cyrus or Harry Styles.
This is how pop music works, and on No Rain, No Flowers, Black Keys completely embed themselves within the pop music machinery. It works as intended.
This is how pop music works, and on No Rain, No Flowers, Black Keys completely embed themselves within the pop music machinery. It works as intended.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5 (no change from original review)
NEXT TIME: Let's check out some new ones from Kaytranada and the Red Jumpsuit Apparatus, so paired because I have a little moral handwringing to do, just you wait!!!!




No comments:
Post a Comment