2016
Dan Trachtenberg
Group G makes their first appearance in the bunker. Help them break free and meet us in the comments.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Stef
Menacing zaddy alert! This is John Goodman's bunker thirst trap. Every time he ladles chili or slams a door, you're torn between unsettling fear and asking for another bowl. His character radiates hot dad energy: protective, paranoid, and really working the cargo pants. The movie's tension is cool, but let's be honest—the real thrill comes from catching feelings for your doomsday captor. How could anyone resist? John Goodman doesn't just steal the movie; he locks it in his bunker, feeds it chili, and makes it feel emotionally confused.
GRADE: 2 out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~
Zach
This movie, for me, had nothing to do with aliens. It more had to do with what we believe and what we don't.
For most of the movie, I wasn't really sure if Howard had imprisoned Michelle because there was an alien attack or there wasn't. I wasn't sure if Emmett was in on it, even after Michelle starts to confide in him. Maybe he and Howard were working together? Clearly, at the end of the day, we know that Howard has the potential to imprison someone against their will—he did it with Mary. I suppose that in this case, he did actually save Michelle's life? I think this review feels more like me working out questions about the movie and Howard's intentions than a review of the movie itself.
If Howard was so depraved, and capable of this type of madness, why didn't he touch Michelle? That is one question that I was left with, for sure.
I didn't care about the alien parts. For me, the final twenty minutes of the movie could have been cut out. This could have easily been a psychological thriller about Howard, Michelle, and Emmett, and if it was, the tension could have been ratcheted up even more, and the story could have been deeper. The alien part could have been left as a final twist at the end—yes, there were aliens, thank you very much, Howard actually did save her life! But I didn't need to see her fighting aliens, or being a hero by driving to Houston.
What happened to Ben? What happened to Mary/Brittany? I know they're both dead, but it still feels unsatisfying. Maybe this says more about me than about the movie itself—I care less about the supernatural angle, and more about the human side of what's going on. I could do without the fantasy side of things.
2.5/5
~~~~~~~~~~~
Frank
I wanted to like this movie a whole lot more than I did. I just think at the end of the day it suffered from the fatal flaw of A) not making me care if any of the three characters lived or died (movie's fault), and B) all media where a woman is trapped in a bunker by a crazy man makes me think of Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt and then I get the theme song stuck in my head the whole film (no fault of the movie).
I think it could have benefited from quiet tension more? Or maybe some real doubt? It never created real doubt, it just pulled bait and switches like six times or answers questions immediately: Is Howard making the whole thing up? No, something awful did happen outside he was right to be paranoid, he's just a little weird and intense! But no wait he's actually still a bad guy after all! Does freezing the lock not work? Nope it actually does on the second try. Is the air actually breathable and the suit was pointless? Well yes but there are aliens with poison gas so it will come in handy after all!
I know the movie has to move and be tight on a smaller budget, but it never gives any of the stakes or tension room to breathe, it just plows right through onto the next level.
Speaking of the aliens... I really hated the last 20 minutes of this movie. I think having absurd aliens undercuts Howard as a really good, really human villain. I know that this movie was another script just about the bunker that JJ Abrahams got his mitts on and forced into his Cloverfieldverse for marketing purposes. However, I feel like there had to be a more elegant way to fold it in other than *shrug* I guess there are aliens now.
Two last gripes: I think "not Jim Halpert" from The Newsroom is kind of bad in this, or maybe just not given a ton to work with. Sorry "not Jim Halpert."
Separately... how long were they in the bunker? I wish I knew, kind of wish it was like a year or two, I think that would raise the stakes. What if it was less than a week?
Also, does she have enough gas to get to Houston? Also, why would Howard go out of his way to show her a picture of not Meghan? He didn't have to! Ugh, that peeved me.
Now that I'm done picking nits, I really liked John Goodman in this. I think he did a really good job of keeping you guessing whether he was just intense or evil. Also how his whole demeanor changes when he shaves his beard after his main sexual competition is gone: genuinely unnerving.
I also really loved the "I think we're alone now" montage. I wish the movie had more moments like this of world-building, the set design was really excellent and I wanted them to live in it more before the curtain was pulled.
2 out of 5 stars
~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
The last fifteen minutes or so piss me off. One, because it made for a worse movie (dropped a half a puke, I'd estimate), and I just want movies to be the best versions of the themselves that they can be, ya know? A glaring misstep doesn't make me feel good. I'm not a snobby critic who revels in this shit. I just wanna watch good movies, and 10 Cloverfield Lane really, truly was a good movie, up until everything got upended.
And then two, I'm a little pissed off, because those last fifteen minutes dominate any conversation that you can have about this otherwise great film. Examine the other voices in this very blog post—did anyone forget to mention the fact that there are aliens in the movie all of a sudden, and that now it's gotta be shoehorned into some fucking franchise with a couple scenes of generic "fight the monster" bullshit? I'm sincerely asking, as I'm writing these words before anyone else submits an email about 10 Cloverfield Lane. Maybe I'm wrong and that everyone wants to concentrate on the first 90 minutes, and we get to chat about the excellent, thrilling acting, the Hitchcockian subversive creepiness, the guy who voices the lawyer in Bee Movie playing a great horror villain, etc. Honestly, I hope I am. That would be cool.
But what are the chances? Okay, let me be clear what I'm talking about here, what exactly I take issue with. I'm not saying the movie immediately steers into the dogshit when the Cloverfield aliens appear. It just lingers too long. The sight of the aliens, and Michelle mumbling "shit" when she sees the alien spacecraft, is really cool, and works very well. This is because it answers the film's central question in a completely unexpected way. The question: "Is Howard right, or is he crazy?" When the spacecraft appears, the answer becomes: both! He's absolutely insane, and pretty much got all the details wrong, and also, ya know, drove a woman off the road just so that he could keep her captive in a bunker. But also, there was a wild threat outside the bunker, and they absolutely would've been safer to stay in that bunker for a few years.
I saw Cloverfield four and a half years ago, and was generally aware that this film was connected. So I wouldn't say that the existence of the aliens at the end of this one was necessarily a "shocking twist" or whatever. But even so, I still think that the moment landed, just because of all the work that was done in the bunker to lead up to that point. Even if you know there are aliens out there, Howard's ramblings about aliens (and Russians, lol) are just too boilerplate crazy to take at face value. I'm telling you, man, if this film had cut to black when Michelle saw that alien spacecraft, I'd be singing 10 Cloverfield Lane's praises.
Instead, we get to talk about how a completely different movie is grafted onto the end of it, turning on a dime from tense psychological thriller to generic fight-the-baddie action film. I think I understand what we're going for here—we are seeing the results of Michelle's progress, starting the movie running away from her Bradley Cooper-voiced problems, and ending it a self-sufficient badass who knows she's strong enough to survive. Hence the 90-degree left turn toward Houston so that she can continue to fight the baddies. But that journey would have already been complete had we ended right after the escape from the bunker. She was helpless, and then she proved that she was able to help herself. Her journey was complete. To then have to watch her fight generic alien #1 with a Molotov cocktail was unnecessary. I don't know why it pissed me off so much, but it did. Maybe I'm just hyping myself up too much by writing about it. But it really did upset me that a great movie got bumped down to a good movie because of some extra-textual franchise building.
If we're putting all that aside... I mean, we can't but let's say we did... then I'd be writing about the really tense, tight, condensed story that we witness for the majority of the film. So many aspects of this movie's first 90 minutes are going to stick with me: the lady outside of the bunker with the burns, the gun betrayal, the getting-on-with-life montage set to Tommy James and the Shondells, the quick shot of dissolving in acid, all the tiny little moments when we are convinced just for a couple seconds that maybe there's some good in Howard, the wild board game scene when Howard can't say the word "woman," and so many more. Maybe I just love "could have been a theater production on the stage" movies too much, and that's the real reason that the instantaneous expansion of the universe into a global-alien-invasion movie irks me so.
Here's one more theory for you: I just have a tough time talking about sequels. I noted during Bride of Frankenstein that there were very few sequels on the Film Club list, but I forgot about the movie that was a "surprise sequel" at the time of its release. I like watching sequels, especially for movies that I originally liked. But I struggle with the writing about them, or discussing them, or something like that. I don't know if this is actually true, I'm just speculating, but think about it. If this was a standalone, I'd be talking about a good movie. It's not a standalone, so now I have to talk about some other movie, one that I actually liked a little less, and one that negatively affects this movie due to simple association. It's just cooler to write about brand new worlds here in blog form. I don't need to revisit old ones. That's less interesting.
Let us forget about the aliens. Let us forget about any potential future team-ups with Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Ben Feldman and Gugu Mbatha-Raw (I had to look that last one up, I have no plans on watching The Cloverfield Paradox any time soon). Let us instead simple remember John Goodman standing at a jukebox, twerking in the sterile fluorescent lighting of the bunker. That's a better movie than survivors fighting aliens in Houston.
How pissed would you be if, like, you watched Whiplash (example fits since that film's creator worked on this film's script) and after that drum solo, the camera panned outside the auditorium and you saw Peter Parker and you realize that, oh shit, this was actually part of the Spider-Man franchise this entire time! Wow! I would fucking hate that! That's exactly what 10 Cloverfield Lane does. It takes a great film and then force-feeds it into the giant maw of extended-universe film franchising. Boo! No! Let good art stand on its own!
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
Alright, let's go. Any additional thoughts? Drop a comment below.
(NEXT TIME: We talk all about Eve with All About Eve.)

13 comments:
Something I didn't mention was the coincidence of Film Club covering this movie and Misery in the same week. Only because they both start with a car crash, and the protagonist waking up to find that they have been taken captive by the person who "saved" them. The films diverged completely from there, but I thought the coincidence was interesting enough to mention here, if not discuss.
Feels like we're all mostly in agreement with the failures of the end of the movie, but maybe find some disagreement in the value of the first hour and a half. Maybe if the tension of "is Howard telling the truth" isn't there for you, there's not much else in the bunker scenes that move you. I can understand that. I also wonder whether knowing or watching Cloverfield prior to watching this one affects your take on the first 3/4ths of the movie.
I think the best / most memorable parts of 10 Cloverfield Lane, at least for me sitting here trying to remember it from seeing it years back, are as follows:
- When Dalton Varsho hit a triple in the 4th inning, which was really more of a Teoscar Hernandez error than a display of titanic hitting power. That got the wheels turning to get the Jays up to a lead they'd never surrender.
-Also in the 4th when Yesavage, already well on his way to a record-setting 12ks in a World Series game, settled down after beaning Fred Freeman and giving up a single to the hapless Teoscar (shout out to Alej Kirk for the mid-inning chat). He forced the Dodgers to strand 2 on the bags and generally didn't allow them to build momentum in any inning thereafter.
-When Blake Snell was hitting the high 90s on his fastball 100 pitches into the game. He gave up four runs, but he did reached deep and found good stuff in an obviously gasses performance, going as long as he could to give his team a chance. Gotta recognize good stuff when it comes.
-When the Dodgers went to Banda, who despite being perhaps the hottest baseball player out there last night, is a complete wet noodle of an arm who gave up even more insurance runs to the mighty Jays. The took their heart in the 8th and the game was effectively over.
-When the series comes back to Canada tomorrow for game six, with what I assume will be a rematch of Gausman v Yamamoto. Let's. Fucking. Go. Blue. Jays.
-John Goodman was cooking in this movie.
The last 15 minutes of 10 Cloverfield Lane were like if the Blue Jays win the World Series in Game 6 and then all of a sudden the MLB is like "well actually now you have to win 2 out of 3 with the AL All-Star Team if you want to win the World Series." It's a bullshit tack-on.
Upon further reflection I think the biggest issue is being a cloverfield movie in terms of the tension for me. I just know in the back of my brain that there is some sci-fi thing hovering in the background, distracting me from enjoying Howard as the big bad. I really did think Goodman was great in it. I might have liked the first part of the movie more in the moment and the ending really soured me on the whole thing. I did want more moments of them being convinced Howard was a good guy after the reveal of the lady at the door. I think the more I think about it I like both things were true: he was right and he also was insane. He definitely murdered his family too right?
I absolutely thought how weird it was that you just watched misery!! That’s a great example of a movie knowing less is more.
Aw man, that's a good question, Anonymous. I hadn't thought about the possibility that he killed them too. My read on it was that wife and kid really did move to Chicago, and that's what broke Howard completely. I think I like the not knowing for sure though.
I'd be curious to know if there is a third movie that starts in this same way. I'm too afraid of spoilers on google though.
Okay, here's my question for those who happen upon this space in the coming hours or days or years.
In 10 Cloverfield Lane, the protagonist escapes through the hatch and sudde ly finds herself in a completely different movie—Cloverfield. And that was fine, I guess. But my question is, what other movie could she escape the bunker and find herself suddenly in that would make this whole thing better?
I've thought about this a lot and I think the bright light that Howard saw that he thought was aliens could be Paddington accidentally blowing up the marmalade factory and Michelle is suddenly in Paddington 2.
Michelle is suddenly in the middle of the masked orgy scene from Eyes Wide Shut.
I enjoy Alejandro being abbreviated to Alej, gets a chuckle out of me every time.
I see the Jays winning the series on a walkoff home run, a la Joe Carter. If it's in Game 7, it would make it the best World Series every. I don't know how they beat Yamamoto tonight though.
Something about Snell annoys me.
Let's all give it up for Davis Schneider, pride of Voorhees, New Jersey!
I would have liked an ending where she comes out of the bunker and Ben is on one knee with the ring she left and says "now forever with me doesn't seem that bad huh?" and when she says yes everybody that was in the bunker comes out and claps, they were all a troupe of actors.
Love Is Blind except instead of pods its bunkers with John Goodman.
Post a Comment