Wednesday, October 29, 2025

The First Time I: Participated in the 49 Day Challenge

This is The First Time, a column where Zach either 1) writes about the first time he did something specific in his life and talks about any pop culture connections surrounding it, or 2) tries something for the first time ever in 2025 and writes about it—sees a new movie, eats a new food, etc. etc. etc.


My friend runs a challenge where you have to take on and take off at least one thing over the course of 49 days. For example: Take off smoking cigarettes, take on meditating for five minutes a day, or something like that.

This is the fourth time I've participated. The first cycle I did was in 2021. That time, I took on writing a small piece of writing a day, and talking to a stranger every day. I made at least one new friend on the train because of the second one—her name was Ruth, her husband is American, and she told me I could always come to them for a weekend meal if I so chose. 

I still have the Google Doc of the poems I wrote during the first cycle. Here is the first one I wrote:

It's always no.

Sitting next to each other
You talk, and they talk back
Was that a spark you felt, that flew just now?
Smiles exchanged, but—friendly?
Or is there something more?
Should I be shy? Withdrawn, hold back the great shefa that exists within me?
Common interests, common humor, that relaxation
Still, the voice inside your head
'Probably not,' you say
Because you live in a place
Where this happens all of the time
And anyways
Everyone around the city walks around
With a big red 'do not disturb' sign affixed to their back
So you see them again
And again
And you're just friends
Because there's no other way
And the answer is always no.

I took off all added sugar in food. I failed that one spectacularly. I was also trying to do a similar challenge during the summer of 2015, a thirty-day challenge at the time that overlapped with Sam and Hannah's wedding, but my resolve was no match for the alcoholic Slurpee that was served (anyone?).

Here's what I'm doing this challenge:

Take ons:
1. 1000 words/day on novel project
2. ⁠some mobility/stretching exercise every day (no specific time)
3. ⁠one small section of Pninei Halacha — Shabbat every day (book of Jewish law)
4. ⁠one positive unexpected reach out to a friend every day (someone I haven't talked to in a while or just want to say hi to)

Take offs:
1. Phone — no phone in bedroom at night, no videos on phone, no phone until after prayer/workout in morning (whichever comes first)

What would your take ons / take offs be, if you were doing this?

4 comments:

Nate said...

I think I'd take off night snacking / fourth meal.

What would I take on, hm. Nightly piano practice for at least 30 minutes. I think the piano is cool as hell.

Joe K said...

I think it was cool and smart to acknowledge that there is always gonna be life that gets in the way. Like if you take off something but then a wedding hits you. I want to say that I would take off sweets, it's an easy one to say because it's the worst part about my life right now by far... but also seems unlikely that I'd be able to do it for the next three Halloween-candy-soaked days. Maybe I can take off sweets for November, and put on reading for 30 minutes every day.

Gloria said...

So I had to google this and was interested to learn about Omer. Catholics have an equivalent season of Lent which lasts 40 days (not counting Sunday’s so it’s like 46 days) and happens slightly earlier (ours would end about when Passover starts). It’s a time of fasting, giving to the needy, extra prayer, and like sort of a mourning/not celebrating

Anyway, if I was doing a challenge to better myself over 49 days, I’d add on getting a minimum of 7 hours of sleep daily, and I’d give up hitting “extend time” when my iPhone cuts me off after doomscrolling for 15 mins on social media.

Zach said...

Nice! Yeah the idea of my friend who does this is to do a sort of "secondary Omer," which isn't a thing at all in Judaism but it's the reason why he does it specifically at this time of year. It's between holidays (the 49 day challenge ends the day before the holiday of Chanukah), which allows you to focus on your take ons/take offs without disruption. And it's also at the opposite end of the year of Passover, which is when the actual Omer starts.

I am curious to know more about Lent - I know people take things off, but I could never tell if it was more cultural, or if taking things off was a religious requirement.

I like all the take ons/take offs and maybe we'll check in mid-December to see if anyone did these.