Tuesday, October 14, 2025

Never Seen It #261: American Beauty

I had always heard your entire blog flashes in front of your eyes the second before you die. First of all, that one second isn't a second at all, it stretches on forever, like an ocean of time... For me, it was lying on my back at Boy Scout camp, watching falling stars... and yellow leaves, from the maple trees, that lined our street... and watching 400 movies I've never seen before...


American Beauty
1999
Sam Mendes

Something I've written about before in this space is the idea that the movie might be saying something that the characters in that movie are not necessarily saying. Or rather, that the film's characters might be saying one thing but the movie itself is saying the opposite, and if we're saying what the movie is "about," then that might not be the same answer as what the movie is "trying to say." It could be that the characters are used by the filmmakers as an example of how not to think or view the world.

This is just a thought process that I've developed over time, having watched all these movies, and given some thought to them, and having been provided with much room for trial and error. Like is Scorsese attempting to tell us that Jordan Belfast is the hero of Wolf of Wall Street or is he a cautionary tale or is his story a satire of our propensity as human beings to lie and cheat to get ahead, etc. If I'm going off of what the extensive "themes and analysis" section of American Beauty's Wikipedia page says multiple times, then I think another way of defining what I'm trying to say is "finding a movie's center."

I don't know if that's a widely used term—a quick google would suggest that it's not—or if the author of this Wikipedia page took one critic's off-the-cuff quote as doctrine and repeated it five more times. Regardless, it fits my purposes pretty well, and so I'm probably going to repeat it myself in Film Club pretty often from here on out. Especially for movies like American Beauty, that definitely appear to be saying one thing but also might be saying the opposite thing instead, or too? And then is also complicated by who is saying that thing, and what that person is in real life, yes, yes, you know who and what I'm talking about, we'll get to it.

Count me as someone who was emotionally affected and possibly even enthralled by that ending monologue (I would warn for spoilers here, but 13/14 Film Club surveys had a check mark next to this movie title, so I'm assuming most of y'all have seen it already). The thing about beauty being here on this earth and how important it is to find that beauty and appreciate it. I was then taken aback when I was told the possibility of this being a satire of that beauty, that maybe this is a certain mindset of the white middle class and that seeing beauty that makes our hearts burst and finding beauty in a dancing paper bag is maybe not healthy and it'll lead to finding beauty in your girlfriend's dead dad's blood and brains splattered all over the table. Which, yeah, now that you say it.

What's cool is that you have a choice here. You can view it optimistically or pessimistically. You can confirm your own beliefs that there's beauty everywhere, or you can let the darkness creep in and start to tell you that maybe there are places in this world that lack beauty, that maybe a dude who oversteps boundaries and is generally an asshole to everyone in his life is not the person to be getting life advice from, or following the example of, emotionally speaking. Both sides of the coin feel legitimate, and the filmmakers have purposefully left you hanging, not saying what they intended one way or the other, and so you need to choose. Maybe that's the true beauty, of this movie, the ability to choose.

In other words, American Beauty either lacks a center or features multiple possible centers that are not agreed upon. And so figuring out what this movie means to you means that you are choosing something as your center. This is complicated, for a few reasons. It's complicated from a logistics standpoint because, well, a movie is a complicated thing, with many moving parts, and many hands involved. When I've said "what is the movie saying" in the past, that's an oversimplification. A movie could, in fact, be saying multiple things, because multiple people have had a large part in making it. Is writer Alan Ball the center? Is director Sam Mendes? Do the actors play a part in shaping what it says, and if so, do we need to consider the Kevin Spacey of it all?

I believe the allegations, and I believe that Kevin Spacey is a monster in real life. I believe that the dismissal of court cases has more to do with the impossibility of providing sufficient evidence in cases like this than it has to do with their being a lack of truth in the allegations. And I believe my Dazed and Confused pal Anthony Rapp when he says that he was abused by Spacey. Rapp has specifically drawn parallels between Spacey's character's behavior in this film and Spacey's behavior in real life, and this is ultimately what complicates a viewing of American Beauty the most today. 

It's complicated because I do not believe that American Beauty is justifying ephebophilia through the actions of its central (though not center) character, and yet there's the reasonable concern that Spacey was able to connect so deeply with the character and win a probably well-earned Oscar for Best Lead Actor because he was, in real life, analogous to Lester Burnham. So you see how this might create some dead ends when you're searching for the center of the film. If the "beauty everywhere" thesis gave any justification whatsoever to Lester's actions, then real world developments have made that aspect of the film extremely uncomfortable at best. Like, what to make of the fact that Lester ultimately chooses not to molest but instead "take care of" Angela, now that we know Spacey made no such decision in real life? What to make of Lester's murder and from-the-afterlife observations if Spacey will face no such retribution or punishment? Or that the character's murder was based on a misunderstanding, which tightens the window of justification for that murder specifically, and yet no such tightening exists for a man who forced his victims to do the very thing that his character was assumed to do and didn't actually do and was killed for anyway?

#MeToo does not mean that I shouldn't watch this movie, because ultimately I think that Sam Mendes and Alan Ball are responsible for this film's being, and I try not to make a habit of throwing out the entire piece of art if one arm of that art is "cancelled." This isn't like music, which has an easily identifiable center. I don't think Spacey or Lester are the "center" as we have defined it in this blog post. But I do think that the complications that Spacey's involvement brings can and should affect how we talk about American Beauty. I can still consider the idea that the world can be observed as beautiful, but I'll have to view it taking into consideration that the movie, both in the text and especially in the context, paints the opposite picture. That maybe the center is in Allison Janney's Barbara—silent witness to the cruelties that this world has to offer, and too numb to be able to make much of a difference one way or the other.

FUCK there's so much to discuss about this movie, and I hate that I don't have unlimited time. I mean, I do, but maybe that time can be transferred to the comments section, just to see if anyone else has any other centers they'd like to discuss. In the meantime, I'll leave it here: it's fascinating to me that this movie has apparently fallen out of fashion in recent years. If it has, then that lends credence to the idea that a movie about a middle-aged white dude who is unsatisfied with life and only finds purpose and motivation when he discovers that he wants to fuck a sixteen-year-old is maybe NOT the movie for these current times. And I see that, and mostly agree. But I would also posit that maybe it's possible to pull something important from the movie, despite everything else, and to find beauty in something that is clearly ugly, both in purposeful and retrospectively accidental ways.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Alright, fine, fuck it, let's just get it over with—Kevin Spacey returns to win another Oscar in The Usual Suspects.

No comments: