I am assuming, as always, that most people are going to choose to ignore this album. For the rest of us, a different assumption: that perhaps this album altered your life in some way. I listened to Super Ghostbusters way too many times and then was at a trunk-or-treat (ugh) and heard "Ghostbusters" by Ray Parker Jr. over the DJ's loudspeakers and was sort of taken aback, the sounds reaching my ears sounding now so alien, so fucking bizarre, that some man would be singing about capturing ghosts and not, like, shitting a McDonald's burger in his pants or something.
So let's here from those who listened: whatchya think about this one?
What were some choice lines that will stick with you?
What are you doing for Halloween tonight and do your plans include making prank calls to local pizza parlors and getting your legs broken over it?
Also this week: I'll be copying/pasting the old exit survey into this space, just in case the RC captain wants to answer the questions in the comments. Starting this week since I am the RC captain, and can assure you, dear reader, that I will not be passing up this opportunity to WRITE MORE on this godforsaken blog. I suppose the questions might serve as convenient prompts for those who participate of their own free will too, if that's your thing.
Happy Halloween, everybody. Thanks for being here. Have a safe night, free from ghosts, both real and in spooky spaghetti!
Exit survey:
1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?

15 comments:
Thanks to the PoYB full-time staff for clocking in on this one. I tried to get some guest contributors, didn't really work out. I thought this would've been a good one to get some outside perplexed opinions. Ah well. Looks like there's only five more people on this earth who will be thinking about the rat man and shitting their pants when they hear the Ray Parker Jr. classic "Ghostbusters."
This is relevant because it involves two RC alumni and two others who have been involved in some RC music, but Snocaps dropped their surprise debut self-titled today. Snocaps is: Katie Crutchfield (Waxahatchee), Allison Crutchfield, MJ Lenderman, Brad Cook.
1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?
Happy to hear that at least some people engaged with this weird-ass thing that I found on RYM a year or two ago and have had on a list of potential albums for just as long. It makes me think about how many of you are freaks like me and come across a hitherto unknown album and say "oh shit, this would be really fun to listen to in the context of Record Club."
Which, for the record, is a completely different reaction then "oh shit, this is a good album, I want to recommend it to other people." Record Club can be that, but that feels boring to me. Because then all the albums are good, and the writing withers. And plus, there are a thousand other ways to recommend a piece of music to someone. Record Club is more specific than that.
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
I wanted someone to go to bat for this thing. But I wasn't sure what type of person would do that. I think maybe Epimemeologist Pat? That was a keen mention of Pat that Sunny made in his review. Pat is probably plugged into the correct portions of the internet for this thing to make sense to him.
Otherwise, it ranged from "this could be funny I guess" to "this is terrible." This is assuming that Zach's review is drenched in sarcasm, which I'm only 50% sure of.
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
Gloria's pinpointed what I now realize is the most cutting criticism that anyone can give in the context of RC: "You should not have picked this album." Doesn't happen too often. Usually people are content to go along with the flow and give something a negative review. But every once in a while you get a Nate/McGruff or Rachel/DMB situation where someone hates something so much that they question the very foundations of Record Club itself. That opinion, like all opinions, is valid. Even if I don't agree with it.
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
Has anyone seen those Ghostbusters sequels from the past five years or so? Are they bad? They seem bad. They seem like a nostalgia cash-in. I'm not down with that. I'll stick with the only Ghostbusters that matters (the 2016 all-female reboot). It's the only thing that Kate McKinnon has ever done that doesn't make me cringe so hard that I die of shock.
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
No regrets whatsoever. I promised Gloria that I would be picking something even worse for next Halloween, and you know how I stick to promises like that.
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
Nate's review made me wonder what my life would've been like if I had gotten really into Adult Swim-type shows growing up, how my alt sense of humor would've pushed my life in different directions. I don't know. I do know that the review made me watch Too Many Cooks again.
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
I am pretty sure I have the holiday albums all set up for the poll that's dropping in a couple weeks. I managed to find a Hannukah album this year that might be of interest. Still looking for that Kwanzaa album.
What I think an exercise like this comes down to is:
1) Do you value the act of creating art, even if you hate the art that is being made?
or
2) Do you value the act of creating art, even if the artist strives to create the artifice of "carelessness"?
a 3) might be something about styles of humor, and willingness to explore other styles of humor, or conversely believing that styles of humor are silos that cannot be crossed over.
so i put all these comments in a crack pipe and i smonk
I "should" like Waxahatchee - like, her music is the type of music I generally like - but, weirdly enough, I just don't, and I don't get the hype, either.
A quote from the Stereogum article that announced this album to me at 5 AM: "If you’ve been missing Katie Crutchfield in indie rock mode during Waxahatchee’s prestige Americana era, this may be the album for you."
"Listening to this album was a waste of my time." - Gloria, today. Me, 45 our of 52 weeks of the year in record club.
I love that you hated it, Gloria. I love that it befuddled Subes. Even my fellow internet mind warrior Sunny didn't go for this shit! I stand alone at the vanguard of thinking this was ... well, not "rad," per say, but certainly ... hm, not "worthwhile" really ...
I feel affection for this album, I suppose.
I think if there's one thing that Record Club is good at—there are many things, but I won't waste anyone's time here listing them—it's the way that it can make something feel like it's "ours." There are plenty of people out there who like this album, sincerely or ironically (or else it wouldn't have been listed as the number-one parody album on RYM and I would never have seen it), but in the act of either enjoying or at least withstanding the album as it passes through our private space here, it becomes "ours." Feels like an in-joke now that I can make and have at least four people get what I'm talking about. That's a good feeling for me, not sure about anyone else.
It’s taken me about 40 weeks of writing for Record Club to realize that RC is more of a writing club with an album as a prompt vs a music sharing club, lol
I think that that mindset gives a lot of context to certain choices for albums
Your 'review' made me soften a bit more, and tap into that part of me that was 13 watching [as] at all hours at night. Also that Brak video gave me a smile.
Nice to keep some affection for the strange
Hell yes! That's definitely where I've settled on it, at least for the past four or five years, and will continue to choose albums that feel like they might be interesting, while not necessarily being good. (Especially since I don't usually listen to an album before its week in the RC sun starts, so logically it can't be a recommendation.) If there weren't so many other lanes of the blog open for recommendations, I'd feel bad about it.
I did not and will not listen to this album. But seeing all the pictures of the dude who made it...i cant be the only one who thinks its Matt L*****???
I didn't see it before, I can kind of see it now, but my main theory is that we're all just confused because Freddie Freeman has been in our lives for way too long.
Post a Comment