Prompt: "A song about forever"
Selected by Nate
"Forever"
Hovvdy
Hovvdy, 2024
THE YEAR IN JOE
For the founder of the feast, and for anyone fool enough to click on what will certainly have to be a "click here" button, I have taken the liberty of ranking all 179 songs Joe has selected for this year's Song Challenge.
This is not, it should be noted, a ranking of the posts, or of the content therein on each post, but simply of the song chosen, irrespective of the prompt. Let it be known that I considered several bits and gimmicks for this list as a back-door tribute to Joe—just randomizing the songs in no particular order, listing them chronologically or alphabetically, things of this nature—but rather than do all that, we'll just play it straight. Let it also be known that I do realize I said "back-door tribute to Joe" one sentence ago, and will not be commenting on it further, you sick freaks. Take it to your Puke on Your Birthday fanfic Tumblr, which I am certain exists.
Finally, before the list: Joe, sorry if you feel like you're getting short shrift here. For what it's worth, I think you correctly nailed your best writing in the Thanksgiving post you wrote a month ago, and I would mark your realization that the jackass at your school is just a guy with a past trying to make good as one to revisit. Alas, the hours wind down on this challenge and like the Ghost of Christmas Present, I grow smaller and more white-haired. No big goodbye or farewell for you, see you on Friday for a The End is Near review.
179: "Peaquad Biloxii" by Keith Wolk
Respect to Keith for seemingly recording a riff he came up with and putting it onto YouTube. No need for anyone to listen to this, for Joe to find this, for me to try and write more novels.
178: "Dancing with My Elf" by Mia Lynn Bangunan
I'll be completely honest, I didn’t even finish listening to this song. I got everything I needed in less than 30 seconds. God, Christmas music, get it the fuck out of here.
177: "No Mercy" by B.A.P
I'm not so cold that I can't appreciate the Kelly Rowland flip in the pre-chorus, but I also can't really appreciate anything else going on here. It's bad, y'all.
176: "36 Cents" by the Bacon Brothers
All list-making comes via the interpretation of art through ineffable qualities and foibles of the makers themselves. There is nothing "wrong" with "36 Cents," beyond it being the sort of run-of-the-mill retirement rock band fair that plays medium-bad at the local brewpub on live music night, and yet the knowledge of the handsome sneering Bacon Brothers as the authors and performers gives what is there a rich patina of slime and stink. For all the good looks, charm, and acclaimed influence, this is the best you can do? The stars are really just like us.
175: "Blob Digs a Hole" by Buckethead
Honestly, with songs like this, it's hard to understand what Joe sees in Buckethead. I'll admit it, he's got at least 50 great albums, but listening to the rest of it? He's a real bucketfreak, and more power to him for his commitment to a great, now-dead artist.
174: "It's Christmas Time (in Cleveland Heights)" by the Philly Specials ft. Boyz II Men and Travis Kelce
It feels relevant to ask now if Philadelphia will ever be rid of Jason Kelce, or if he will continue to hang from the city like a Jaworski or a Swift, drinking for free and maybe showing up on the radio to chop it up with Ike Reese and Sal Paolantonio about the Birds' chances against Dallas in the year 2043 when all other sports have been outlawed and the NFL has render itself the new ruling structure of the United North American States and nation-states war in organized combat over resources and new territories. Perhaps then, under the third administration of Baron Trump, with all other holidays officially dominated, we will be free of his Christmas music.
173: "Sesame Street Presents the '80s: Loose Goose / Colors (There's Like a Million) / Two Heads are Better Than One / Count to Nineteen / Super Grouch / Tuck Elmo In Before Before Bed Oh-Oh / Bake Cookie / Don't Stop Your Reading / Always Gonna Be Your Friend" by the Sesame Street Cast
Even I am not so cold and internally-dead to make fun of Sesame Street PSYCH, FUCK YOU BIG BIRD YOU GANGLY BITCH.
172: "Baby, I Love Your Way/Freebird Medley (Free Baby)" by Will to Power
If this were the first song I had ever heard it would also be the last song I ever heard because I would have concluded that music was not worth it. Joe has always had a more charitable heart than I. This is why he works to make the world better and I work to send emails to people who would prefer not to read them.
171: "Edge of Twilight" by Gentle Giant
The fucking timpani prompt. Goddamn you, K***, for making people have to suss out A) what a timpani is and B) if a song happens to have one in it.
170: "Spiral Mountain" by Grant Kirkhope
Mine was a Donkey Konga home, two houses alike in dignity.
169: "You Don't Own Me" by Dusty Springfield
A side-effect of being raised by my parents is that I have maintained a perspective that the culture of the past sucked and is not to be revisited. This has extended to Dusty Springfield, a name that I know but cannot place. After hearing this song, they may remain unplaced as far as I am concerned.
168: "Love Is the Drug" by Divinyls
I believe this is from a very well-regarded mid-'90s film?
167: "Rude" by Magic!
Sometimes collective society decides that something sucks and it's bad and there will be a critical dog-piling onto something that, while probably bad, doesn't really deserve the ire it receives. That thing will then, fueled in some way by the arms taken up against it, sustain and remain strong despite the ill will of others. So it goes with white people and reggae music, so it goes with songs made only for wedding between white people and no other purpose.
166: "The Pool Shark" by Dave Dudley
I've been to a bunch of pool halls, and anyone who ordered a brandy would be getting a healthy amount of spit in their drink.
165: "Knock Three Times" by Dawn
I would prefer that my songs about banging be a little less Cialis commercial than this one is.
164: "I Want You" by Savage Garden
I would prefer my songs about middle school dances be a little less Cialis commercial than this one is.
163: "Where Do I Hide" by Nickelback
They really do suck, don't they?
162: "Whatever it Takes" by Lisa Dalbello and a children's choir
Not enough is made about Drake—the current most-famous and influential pop musician somewhat credible accused of sex-based misconduct with minors—being a child actor on this show. This would be a little bit like if Ryan Gosling went from Baby Hercules or whatever show he was on into being Post Malone and no one ever talked about it. It's not weird, exactly, but it's something! Also, I don't know why Joe and Sara care about this show, and I will not do any work to find out.
161: "Girls like You" by Maroon 5 ft. Cardi B
I still ride for "She Will Be Loved," but woof, this band stinks! The Nickleback of our time.
160: "Cake by the Ocean" by DNCE
This is a KidzBop all-timer in my house, which does it or I no favors. That said, who among us wouldn't enjoy a little ass by the beach? Truthfully, I think I would have a lot more time for this song if it was called "Ass by the Beach." Alas, we live in a doomed and imperfect world.
159: "May Your Dreams Come True" by John Hinckley
Genuinely jarring stuff.
158: "The Stripper" by David Rose & His Orchestra
Only comprehensible if you played—and were kicked out of—a pep band.
157: "Frankenstein" by the Edgar Winter Group
Ohhh, shit! These are the guys and this is that song with the one big guitar riff! Was this song actually from Vinyl? Holy cow, I'll bet that show fuckin suuuuuuucked.
156: "Nights of the Living Dead" by Tilly and the Wall
Hard pass on all this tap-dancing beret-wearing horseshit. Twee must be killed, unless it's Belle and Sebastian, they can hang.
155: "Old Brown Dog" by Ralph McTell
Not a dog guy, not an “old music” guy.
154: "Live by the Sword" by the Rolling Stones ft. Elton John
Congrats to the ancient animated corpses of the Rolling Stores for making it out of the bottom 10% of Joe's picks. The piano on this is pretty good, Elton still got it.
153: "Take the Money and Run" by Steve Miller Band
HEY GUYS MAKE SURE TO LIKE AND SUBSCRIBE, HERE COMES SOME OF THAT REAL ROCK AND ROLL FOR YOU. I wish to be hit in the head with a lead pipe and left in the conservatory before ever hearing this song or Steve Miller and his band again.
152: "Big Foot" by Nicki Minaj
I was recently made aware of a subreddit called "NickiMinajGoonCave." I have not done the requisite research to see if this community is still up-and-running (as far as you know at least, what a man searches on his incognito mode is between him, his internet service provider, and the spy machines of China), but I'll say that I understand the impulse, if not the manifestation.
151: "The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter" by Reba McEntire
The Anniversary did it better.
150: "Fancy" by Iggy Azalea ft. Charli XCX
Speaking of goon caves, I can only imagine the glazing Joe has done thinking about these two dames over the last ten years. I know he's on the record about how hot to trot he is for Charli, but I don't know if he's ever been as forthright regarding his thoughts vis-à-vis getting a boner for Iggy. I could see it being somewhat of a forbidden fruit given her codeswitching and co-opting of black culture, but the fruit you can't eat is the one you want the most. I'm sure Joe will either link me to a post or do a blog on it sometime in the next 40 years.
149: "I Am Yours" by Tedeschi Trucks Band with Trey Anastasio
I will drop kayfabe for a moment and share that we are now out of the sub-basement of horrors and entering into the normal basement of "just some songs that aren't so great." We cannot see the light yet, but we can understand how light might exist in a world like this.
148: "Sex on Fire" by Kings of Leon
I prefer the original version.
147: "Twistin' the Night Away" by Sam Cooke
995 people were killed in rail fatalities in America in 2023, and to make fun of their suffering is not only in poor taste, but exactly what we should have all come to expect by now on this foul and disgusting blog.
146: "Slip Inside This House" by the 13th Floor Elevators
You know, this song is pretty good.
145: "Homesick" by the Vines
Props for identifying non-singles work by the Vines. I believe the lead singer of this band is neurodivergent in some way? My kid received a book about neurodivergent brains for Christmas, and to say more about the book and the circumstances around her receiving it would be prehaprs too much information to share publicly, but if you're somehow hanging in 3,000 words into what will probably be a 15,000 blog post, shoot me a text and I'll tell you the tea.
144: "Sympathy is a knife" by Charli XCX
I wonder if I had just spent more time with brat if I would have found in it what so many others seemed to find. Ah well, no way to know for sure.
143: "How Long's Eternity?" by Video Age
Not quite my preferred tempo in power-pop; a little too New Zealand, a little too Beatles worship. I've added them to the Bandcamp wishlist all the same.
142: "Untitled 1" by Don Martin Three
This song is pretty good, too.
141: "11.12" by Kadafi Li
The Rolling Stones: Not as good as Kadafi Li.
140: "The Bird" by the Time
Like most of Joe's posts, a good thing is ruined by going too long.
139: "Un Poco Loco" by Miguel ft. Héctor
Best case scenario for what comes on the "Disney Radio" shuffle playlist on Spotify. Thanks to my kids, my top five songs on that blasted platform were all from Encanto, save one from Frozen. Can't remember which one now, but it wasn't one of the big ones. Frozen deep cuts only in our house.
138: "Keep It on the Hush" by Ludacris ft. Jazze Pha
Ludacris has made ten great songs, ten awful songs, and about 200 overwhelmingly medium songs. Here's one of the 200.
137: "Girls Do, Boys Don't" by Bardot
Pop that aims to be big and doesn't get there is such a fascinating little pocket-genre. Carly Rae Jepsen is the queen of that little negative space, but somewhere in her army of never-weres sit the ladies of Bardot. How'd you even find this shit, man?
136: "The Boxer" by Simon & Garfunkel
This song is about my novel from last year.
135: "What I Want is a Proper Cup of Coffee" by Trout Fishing in America
I read The Feather Thief on Gilson's suggestion earlier this year. It's about a guy who steals a bunch of dead birds so he can—get this—tie historically-accurate flys for flyfishing. What a weird little world and weird little crime.
134: "The Gift" by the Velvet Underground
This is as good a place as any to share my resolutions for 2024: I will read more books than my sister-in-law (loser has to paint a portrait of the winner, oil on canvas); I will run 500 miles; I will be extra large by the end of the years (as opposed to what I am now, which is extra-extra large); I will say less (hard to quantify this one, but I'd basically like to think before I speak, especially in non-professional settings).
133: "The Deejoy Crawling Crab Song" by the Deejoy Green Crawling Crab
I would love to get my hands on the Deejoy Crawling Crab, let it loose in front of, say, Savage Garden, and then tell them "Hear that? You should have done that instead of what you did."
132: "The Steve Martin" by EPMD
I do think this is funny, I must admit.
131: "Cod'ine" by Buffy Sainte-Marie
Folk just might not be for me. I can recognize why someone would like this, but not why someone would commit their lives to it. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have to continue my nearly 25-year-career of listening to hardcore bands from western New York. The great work continues!
130: "Save Me" by Remy Zero
No thanks, Remy.
129: "Jump" by Kris Kross
I suspect I have placed this song too high, because I think I'd probably rather listen to the Deejoy Crawling Crab song than this. Oh well, too late. I had this CD growing up, really liked the song about missing the bus, I'm pretty sure it's called "I Missed the Bus."
128: "Too Sweet" by Hozier
My three-year-old loved this song for a couple of weeks earlier this fall. I love her, but this shit sucks.
127: "Rock Around the Clock" by Bill Haley & His Comets
Minutes in the hour, RANKED:
1. :00
2. :15
3. :30
4. :25
5. :23
6. :10
7. :05
8. :59
9. :45
10. :50
Ah, you know what, that's enough.
126: "Time" by Amen Dunes
Had no idea this is what Amen Dunes sounded like, but I understand now why there wasn't as much of a fuss over this as the artist would have liked.
125: "#246" by Walt Mink
Total bullshit what Pitchfork said about this album. This is a 9.6, MAYBE, but to give it a complete 10? Miscarriage of justice.
124: "Modern Art" by Art Brut
It makes me want to rock out.
123: "This Magic Moment" by the Drifters
The rare good old song.
122: "Mr. Tangerine Man" by Wesley Stance
You know, if I was raking these again, I'd have this much closer to the bottom. This is because I AM MAGA, BABY, I CAN FINALY ADMIT IT DOWN HERE IN THE BOWLES OF A YEAR-END WRAP-UP! Nah, just kidding. This song is bad though. Fuck Trump and anyone who loves him, for real, but this song is bad. Certainly, we can all find community there.
121: "I Wan'na Be Like You (The Monkey Song)" by King Louie and Baloo the Bear
I remember thinking this was a good song, but I cannot sing a single note or bar of it now, as I sit here running out the clock on a workday. Oh well, onto other simian concerns.
120: "I'm a Believer" by the Monkees
See what I mean? I think this song would be good even without Shrek. Sunny said something very on-point about Shrek earlier this year, good luck finding it. You could search "Shrek" in the blogspot search bar, I guess, if you're a coward. Or, if you're really bout it bout it, you can click on the "Sunny" button and get to reading, coward. You're gonna find out some wild stuff if you do that, though. He's lukewarm on OutKast, can you believe it?
119: "October, First Account" by Be Your Own Pet
I sometimes think Joe is the only person left alive holding a candle for this band, assuming that he's holding one at all. I don't believe in much, but I do believe that no one is dead until they are forgotten, and if that's true, then fear not, Be Your Own Pet, you will live on in the mind of Joe.
118: "Never Fuck a Spider on the Fly" by Modest Mouse
Cannot explain to you how important Modest Mouse was to me in my late-college / early 20s, cannot explain to you how repulsive most of the current catalog is to me now.
117: "The Big Game (Movements 1 & 2)" by Sledding with Tigers
TOO TWEE. SEE: PREVIOUS STANCE ON TWEE.
116: "Cavern" by Phish
Here's how to make a list like this. You put a song on a spreadsheet. You put another song on the spreadsheet, deciding if it is better or worse than the first song on the spreadsheet. If better, put it below. If worse, above. Over time, you'll start to realize you have anchor songs that act as wayposts for more precise placements. "Cavern" is one of the loadbearing signposts on this list. Everything after this is decidedly good.
115: "Something About the Real World" by Spencer Krug
If I could ever truly back off my pursuit of the new, I'd like to take a year and listen to everything Krug has gotten up to outside of Wolf Parade. He's one of our greatest weirdos, I think, and I know Joe has a deep and abiding affection for him. Alas, I cannot stop myself from being myself. Maybe next year.
114: "Paprika" by Japanese Breakfast
Was Crying in H Mart really that good? Am I going to have to read it this year? I might as well, I've gotta run down my sister-in-law somehow.
113: "How Can You Really" by Foxygen
This is a charter member of the Bands Joe Thinks Are Great That I Am More Ambivalent About Society. Every band on that list is due for a re-evaluation at some point. Maybe after I get through the Krug works.
112: "Cacao and Cocaine" by SOFIA ISELLA
Sup, Stephan?
111: "Inmates" by Restraining Order
Boston has a great and storied hardcore scene, right up there with anyone else's hardcore scene. When you're talking hardcore scenes, you're really looking at a couple of places: New York City, Southern California (not really LA, but not not LA), DC, Boston. I know I made a joke about it up there a minute ago, but Buffalo has fostered some great hardcore in its time, though nowhere near as high on the list as those other big cities. Philly hasn’t really been the greatest spot for it, despite the best efforts of Paint it Black and Joey Hardcore / This is Hardcore fest. Anyway, this has been another Moment in Hardcore with a 38-year-old man.
110: "Wu-Gambinos" by Raekwon ft. Ghostface Killah, Method Man, RZA, and Masta Killa
Very pleased to be reminded of this late-era possie cut.
109: "Thank You for Being a Friend" by Cynthia Fee
I will admit it now, I was responsible for the Cam'ron Alert. Cam'ron rapped over this song! Isn't that swell?
108: "Under the Bridge" by Red Hot Chili Peppers
The rare—and perhaps only?—good Red Hot Chili Peppers song. I know Brianna agrees!
107: "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" by Steely Dan
Ever year a man ages, he gains a proportionate amount of appreciate for Steely Dan. It can't be helped, and should not be fought.
106: "Frog on the Floor" by 100 gecs
The passage of time is a motherfucker. All those moments lost to time like frogs on the floor.
105: "Money on the Table" by Country Westerns
I think 2025 might be the year I turn away from Country Westerns music and make a hard pivot back to rap. It's not to say that one can't enjoy one without eschewing the other, or that there's some kind of false dichotomy between the two genres, but that I've spent more time recently a-twangin' than I have a-rappin', and 2025 might be a fine time to reverse the trend. Bandcamp accepts all comers, after all.
104: "Don't Be Cruel" by Bobby Brown
High comedy coming from you, Robert.
103: "1000 Days" by Wand
Pretty cool song.
102: "Painting of My Time" by Floodlights
I like the banjo as an instrument, but you really gotta be picking that thing to be getting the most out of it. Strumming it ain't the same.
101: "Sweet Robbery - Part 2" by Three 6 Mafia
Need to get more Project Pat and Pastor Troy on the blog in 2025.
100: "Survival Song" by AJJ
Only 79 more to go!
Ah shit, that’s not right. 100 more to go. Fuck!
99: "Late to the Party" by RFA
I've been numbering these as I go, and so far I haven't fucked it up, but I remain horrified at the prospect of getting to the bottom of this list and finding I don't have enough numbers, or worse, that I have too many. I can promise you this: I will not be fixing it either way.
98: "Title Track" by Okkervil River
Joe, did you check out that Will Sheff solo record from a little while ago? Think it was 2023, but could have been 2022 or 2024. It wasn't all that good, I'm sad to say.
97: "Hallelujah" by Haim
It's mystifying to me that there's any argument as to which Haim sister is the most crush-worthy, but I guess if we all agreed, there would be no one to listen to Charli XCX.
96: "Mystery Man" by SUSTO
This song makes me think of one thing and one thing only: THE FUCKING HOLIDAYS, BABY.
95: "Haunted" by Spanish Love Songs
This band should be Nate-core, but they are almost too much my thing that I come around to being suspicious of them.
94: "Inspector Norse" by Todd Terje
God, can this guy make good disco!
93: "Your Fool" by Natalie Prass
You know, I don't remember what this song sounds like at all. Let me go check it out...
...ah, right. That's right.
92: "OOO" by The Sun Days
Same for this one...
...huh. You know, I think I got the order right on these two.
91: "<" by Waxahatchee
I can confess here that I was never that big a fan of P.S. Elliot, but I was (and I suppose am) a large supporter of the Swearin' project. Come back to me, Swearin'!
90: "The Ballad of Scarlet Town" by Johnny and the Moon
Man, going back and adding the links to all these songs is going to be a slog. Same with adding the stars for the songs that I didn't know about. Are we sure Tuesday is tomorrow? That feels right to everyone? Alright, fine. So be it.
89: "For Cheez (My Friend, Not the Food)" by Illuminati Hotties
You know, this is a band that is someday going to pull it all together and meet all the promise and attention they received over the last five years with a project that is worthy of the attention and the accolades, but I didn't think it happened this year, and if I'm honest, I think we're in something of a Sky Ferreira situation here. But still and all, I hope it happens, and I begrudge no one who thinks it'll happen.
88: "Kristina She Don't Know I Exist" by Catch 22
Joe loves ska. I don't remember if he's ever come out and put it in those terms before on the blog, but I am willing to do so here. He loves Catch 22. He loves Less Than Jake (only the early stuff). He loves Mustard Plug. He Loves Skanin' Pickle. He loves the Aquabats. He loves the Specials. He loves the Arrogant Sons of Bitches. He loves it! Wearing those little suits? Doing that skank dance? He cannot get enough and will never be able to fill the hole inside of him with enough ska.
87: "Black Hole Sun" by Soundgarden
Video is still very scary.
86: "Tuesday" by Malibu Ken
Hell yeah, Joe.
85: "I Gotcha Back" by GZA
HELL yeah, Joe!
84: "Everyone in Town" by the Brights
Somewhere a bunch of words ago I said that something was too New Zealand. This is the appropriate amount of New Zealand. The power-pop agenda continues apace.
83: "Good Time" by Carly Rae Jepsen and Owl City
Owl City guy. What a bummer!
82: "Strangers" by Langhorne Slim & the Law
Langhorne Slim will forever be trying to outrun "The Way We Move," rightfully so, since that song whips ass. The video for the song, less so. I didn't realize "The Law" meant "dressing like John Depp as a member of Mumford and Sons," but here we are, and there they were.
81: "Bust Your Windows" by Jazmine Sullivan
I love anytime Joe comes knuckle to knuckle with Jazmine Sullivan, because he's basically trying to put his arms around a specific cross-section of black women from Philadelphia when doing so. Send Joe to Essence Fest for the blog next year.
80: "How We Met, the Long Version" by Jens Lekman
The man loves Jens, what can I say?
79: "Going Out Swingin'" by the So So Glos
I saw this band open for Ted Leo at the First Unitarian Church sometime in college—maybe 2007—and I have since been waiting for them to capture even a fraction of what they were capable of live on their recorded output. Still waiting at time of writing.
78: "Twelve Dollar Snickers" by Ogbert the Nerd
You'd think I'd like this band based on My Whole Deal, and yet I do not! Song is pretty good, though.
77: "Fearless" by Taylor Swift
Me eldest got Red and Lover for Christmas. Red is my favorite one, I think.
76: "Your Magic Is Working" by Of Montreal
Not quite yet.
75: "Off the Record" by My Morning Jacket
Brianna, wake up, someone mentioned My Morning Jacket!
74: "Right as Rain" by Adele
I did enjoy the softening on Adele that took place this year. When I lived in New Jersey and 21 came out, I had such a white-hot crush on Adele. I cooked up a whole plan to win her over and make her mine so that I could be a kept man somewhere in England while she made the donuts by belting out old heartache to audiences of thousands, only to come home to my warm arms. I got married to my wife instead. Still a good deal for me, even if I have to work.
73: "Shake It Off" by A Golden Era
Hi, Will! Will recorded two of my old band's EPs. I think he put some extra shine on one of our songs that the band didn't like at first, but I have always thought was good. I wonder if Will is still into cars? I suspect he is. Nice man!
72: "Silver Moons" by Sunset Rubdown
Krug hive, activate.
71: "Lip Gloss" by Lil Mama
Genuinely shocked to see this song this high on the list, but what can I say? Cheerleader choruses are effective, and more bands and artists should leverage them!
70: I'm Waking Up to Us" by Belle & Sebastian
NO MORE TWEE ALLOWED, GODDAMN IT!
I think I have told this story on the blog, or if not I have certainly told this story in person, but I once took too many drugs on accident and thought I was going to die during a Belle & Sebastian concert, and I remember in the middle of my panic attack thinking "what a candy-ass band to die during. I cannot believe I am going out like this." Turns out I was fine.
69: "Pet Cemetery" by Tierra Whack
Joe's embrace of Tierra Whack is genuinely heartwarming to me.
68: "Fuck the System" by System of a Down
Between this and Knocked Loose, Bob and I are going to get you into metal, mark my words.
67: "Semicircle Song" by the Go! Team
God, I love this fucking band and I consider it a medium-sized miracle that they continued making music after their initial wave. You simply must love it to see it.
66: "Leave It in the Sun" by Jeff Rosenstock
Rosenstock was Bob Dylan to me once, but the longer he goes on the wider the path between he and I separates.
65: "Apple" by Charli XCX
Love a song with a dance so simple even Gilson can do it. Eat that, Gilson, get to dancing, you bitch!
64: "Point/Counterpoint" by Streetlight Manifesto
WHAT DID I TELL YOU ABOUT JOE AND HIS SKA? MUST YOU ALWAYS BE SO SKEPTICAL OF ME? MUST IT ALWAYS BE THIS WAY BETWEEN YOU AND I?
63: "Teenage Dirtbag" by Wheatus
Truly iconic falsetto.
63: "Sucker's Prayer" by the Decemberists
Blowjob joke.
61: "K2" by Liquid Mike
The Power Pop Agenda Continues Apace.
60: "Radio" by Margo Price ft. Sharon Van Etten
Margo Price, hello. Sharon Van Etten, hello to you as well.
59: "Raw Hide" by Ol' Dirty Bastard ft. Method Man and Raekwon
ODB songs are either A) the most life-affirming and electric rap songs ever pressed to wax or B) complete unlistenable disasters. Thankfully, we've reached the former on this here list. Also, sometimes they're both. I should move that sentence so it's closer to the first one, but I'm not going to. God, how does Joe do this every couple of days, write something that's just hundreds and hundreds of words? It's a testament to putting one's head down and plowing through the work, or maybe a testament to not being worried about being caught fucking around at the office as long as you've got a word document open in front of you. I know how much he loves being back in the office. The camaraderie, the banter, the opportunities for coaching and collaboration. I'll bet he wishes he could go into the office even more days during the week! I work in my attic.
58: "The Same Boy You've Always Known" by the White Stripes
Not the best White Stripes song, I think he'd agree, but still pretty good.
57: "Ghosts" by Bruce Springsteen
You think Springsteen believes in the paranormal? I'll bet he's catholic now, so maybe he's open to spirits. I personally do not think ghosts are real, but sometimes if I am trying to freak myself out when going into the basement later at night to change the laundry over, I will imagine that there is a tall, thin man waiting for me down there, hiding behind one of the kids' doll houses, or behind the door of the bathroom, and he is watching me while I put clothes into the machine. His desires and objectives are unclear to me. He's not really down there right now. But I like to pretend he is. I have an active imagination. I like to tell myself I do at least, who really knows.
56: "It's Rough on Rats (If You're Asking)" by Jack White
Goddamn that new Jack White album was good! Didn't think he had it in him anymore.
55: "Machine Gun" by Portishead
Oy, bruv. It's class, innit?
54: "Stay Positive" by the Hold Steady ft. Mosh Pit Josh
Listening to Bars of Gold as I write this one. This is the band the dudes in Bear vs Shark made after Bear vs Shark broke up. "Blue Lightning," that's the song. Love the lyrics on this one: "I get up early / way too early to have evenings," and also "this is for the people who work / on Christmas." The first part is for parents of children under the age of seven, shout out to you Joe. The second part is for a lot of people. Love to you all, may it get easier and my fewer of us add to the weight.
53: "Blues" by Geordie Greep
I am putting my stake in the ground now: in ten years, when Joe is still plugging away at this blog, he is going to point to Greep as one of his touchstone artists of the decade. I can feel it in my bones. Greep is sticking around with Joe. Greep ain't going away.
52: "I Will Buy You a New Life" by Everclear
Pretty good song, one of my personal favorites about buying someone a new life.
51: "Mine's Not a High Horse" by the Shins
AW FUCK HOW'D THIS TWEE SHIT GET IN HERE!
50: "The Writhing South" by Say Anything
Look, I'm as surprised as the rest of you. Bemis is unhinged, but sometimes that means the door swings the right way.
49: "Hard to Love" by Bully
I was once very dismissive of Bully on this blog, only to text Joe about how much I liked the new Bully effort and for him to remind me that I was dismissive! What a fucker! Anyway, Bully is good and sometimes your cruelty will come back on you.
48: "The Money Grows on Trees" by Willi Carlisle
This was my favorite find of the campaign. Thanks for assist, Joe.
47: "Turkey Vultures" by Wednesday
MJ LENDERMAN IS FEATURED ON THIS TRACK.
46: "All Fires" by Swan Lake
This is Krug, right? I liked this one a lot.
45: "Summer" by Modest Mouse
Here we are, this is the Modest Mouse I remember / committed my life to. Man, so many Modest Mouse tattoos were narrowly avoided during this era. "The years move fast and the days move so low," "It's all nice on ice alright," "bankrupt on selling," a picture of a cockroach. Much bad ink avoided, unlike my current good tattoo of... some pancakes. I'm adding "get another tattoo" to the 2025 resolutions list.
44: "Family Tree" by TV on the Radio
I have 36 first cousins, and I'd estimate that fifteen of them have blogged on this blog, specifically when I asked them to weigh in on Katy Perry in an attempt to win money that I somehow did not succeed at. Fucking Huey Lewis and the News / the improv community. I will be rid of you all yet! Give me that $30! I have to save up for a new tattoo!
43: "One Trick Ponies" by Kurt Vile
I know I have mentioned this before, but on an episode of The Best Show, Tom Scharpling asked Kurt Vile what his top five favorite albums were, and Vile said "Wildflowers by Tom Petty, and my four albums." Legendary shit.
42: "Snowball" by Forests
This particular kind of twinkle-tap emo has fallen out of fashion, but goddamn if I don't still love it a lot.
41: "Not Gonna Die" by Will Butler
GREAT fucking song! Joe, nice one! How'd you come across this.
40: "Devil with the Green Eyes" by Matthew Sweet
THE POWER POP AGENDA CONTINUES APACE.
39: "Four Winds" by Bright Eyes
Last great Bright Eyes song? Last great Bright Eyes song.
38: "Party Pit" by the Hold Steady
Love and respect to you and to what this song means to you, Joe. It ain't no "Same Kooks."
37: "A Psychic Wound" by Los Campesinos!
This is one of my top 20 albums of the year. Why, just today I received a Los Campesinos! shirt in the mail, purchased by me for me. I've had it on my Christmas wish list for the last three years and no one in my family felt the need to snag it, so I said fuck it, and now I have a King of Bands shirt hanging up in my closet. Yes, I do hang up my t-shirts, what of it?
36: "The Whole of the Moon" by the Waterboys
Goddamn, this song also kicks ass! Gonna have to give this record a full look.
35: "Same Kooks" by the Hold Steady
See, now we're talking.
34: "0 to 100 Bars" by Cassidy
My Philly bonafides, whatever they're worth and however much they exist, would now allow me to put this any lower on the list than here. Quick aside: when I worked at the deli for a year, one of the guys I worked with was—and I say this with love—a West Philly goon. He had done some jail time for shooting his gun into the air on New Year's Eve right when a cop happened to drive down his block (the same thing happened to me, only it was for pissing on the sidewalk), he and his brother had tag-teamed a consenting co-worker in the basement, he was still adjacent to street life but very clearly trying to stay out of it. We played some basketball together sometimes. He was a nice guy. Anyway, I bring him up because he was the number one Cassidy fan, and basically claimed that A) he had no wack bars (debatable) B) had no bad songs (unlikely) and C) kicked the shit out of Freeway in that studio freestyle battle (indisputable). A Philadelphia legend deserves his spot.
33: "Newmyer's Roof" by Craig Finn
I feel like this is a song of some regard among the Finn knowers. It's not my favorite, but it's good enough to be here.
32: "Crowded Mind (Lemon Lime)" by Dazy
THE POWER POP AGENDAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
31: "25!" by Bomb the Music Industry!
Great song about having a freak-out, applicable at any age.
30: "Slide 2 Me" by Drug Church
Man, I can't even think of a good joke or jab to put in here. This Song Challenge truly cannot roll over fast enough.
29: "Float On" by Modest Mouse
Can't pretend it didn't kick the door open for a lot of people, can't pretend that hook doesn't still go these 20 years later. If this is the beginning of the end for my beloved Mouse, so be it, I'm glad everyone gets healthcare now.
28: "The Downtown Lights" by The Blue Nile
Goddamn, another incredible song from Ye Olden Days (before 2019). I would love a survey course in songs that sound exactly like this and that Waterboys track from ten spots back or so. All other songs from the '80s can get lost. Except for Big Country. And maybe select songs from Huey Lewis and the News (GIVE ME MY $30 YOU FUCKS).
27: "My Girl" by the Temptations
Girls that have been mine at one point or another:
Colleen, Clara, Angelica, Adrienne, Colleen (a different one), Shannon, Stephanie, Julia, Memphis.
Girls that have never been mine:
Brandi, Monica, almost every single other girl on the earth.
26: "Dancing with Myself" by Billy Idol
Perfect pop song, even if it's a minute or two too long.
25: "Cause = Time" by Broken Social Scene
Maybe the fifth-best Broken Social Scene song, which still puts it pretty fuckin' high on this list. It goes without saying, but it's all bangers from here on out.
24: "Raise Your Voice Joyce" by Fucked Up
I don't understand why rock and roll fans are not listening to everything this band does at all times. Well, okay, I do understand why they aren't, but still, this is incredibly good shit, and if you cannot hear that because you have ears that do not hear past a certain vocal register, well I think that's horseapples, is what I think.
23: "DVP" by PUP
Extremely good song to run to, extremely good song to speed on Ontario highways too, perhaps as good as this band has ever been.
22: "Point Breeze" by Marah
Philly legends who never had a problem understanding which neighborhoods are which, of which the same could not be said for Joe.
21: "No Future Part Three: Escape from No Future" by Titus Andronicus
Seems like something I would enjoy.
20 "Shut Up and Get on the Plane" by Drive-by Truckers
Seems like something I would enjoy.
19 "Life in Drag" by the Hotelier
It's a spectrum, man, and finding your place within it doesn't imply static holding or require a definition outside of the one you give yourself. There's a place in your heart that only you know and that only you get to decide who enters into. Forget whatever else happens outside of that place. Learn to live with it, have shoulders broad enough to carry it, and know that nothing can hurt you unless you let it.
18: "The Underdog" by Spoon
I am genuinely impressed that you took down your list of favorite songs. I've been staring down the barrel of such a list for at least six years, unable or unwilling to pull the trigger. I'm more or less just talking to Joe now, I guess, for a while here. I think you'll know when I stop.
17: "Fourth of July, Philadelphia (SANDY)" by Cymbals Eat Guitars
I do appreciate how much you rep for the city in these song selections and in your life writ large. I guess this is part and parcel with being from a place and never leaving it for an extended period of time. Not to diminish a summer in Las Vegas or to suggest you're some kind of bumpkin, but you haven't been especially transient as far as I know. You wear your love for this city on your skin, even the parts of it you hate (La Salle, certain mayors). You cannot hate something unless you love it first, right? I like that. I get that. I see it, though not as well as you do.
16: "Woke Up New" by the Mountain Goats
Legitimately I don't know how you do the job that you do. I know the job now is not what the job was, that you're not making as many home visits as you used to, and that your job now seems to be, generally speaking, "computer," which I say without judgement because as I have said before, my job is "email," but you still had to be in the thick of it in a way that few people will ever really get. And I know what you'd say here because you've said it before: it's a part of a system, the people you're interacting with are doing their best by and large, you believe in rehabilitation, you come up with pathways and coping mechanisms to allow you to do the work. I know all that is true and I am sure that if I had to do the work I would come up with those same things. But I've never had to because I haven't done the work because, well for a lot of reasons, but at least one being I don't really know if I could. So again, it's a cool thing, and an unbelievable one, even if it's so mundane it happens all the time.
15: "Fake Empire" by the National
Here's the thing though, man: I know you find a lot of joy and self-discovery in writing, but I fear you must accept that many people do not find it to be that, and that they likely never will find it to be that. I don't know where that leaves you, trying to prop up a blog after two years of wildly successful crowdsourcing. I know those experiences have suggested there are people who need and want this, and I am not saying there aren't. But there are people, god love them, who are never going to put their fingers to a keyboard for anything except work, and they're going to live happy and fulfilled lives no matter what we think of how they spend their time. Don't kill yourself trying to get people here, is what I am saying, I think. The curse of "more" is a curse. Foster what you've got and hope it grows, maybe is my advice.
14: "I Will Follow You into the Dark" by Death Cab for Cutie
But the problem with talking about any of this is the knowledge that whatever I might say about whatever topic I might think to address is likely already responded to and articulated somewhere in the pages of the last five years or so. Not to say that there aren't great truths and solutions to be found in the Xanga life raft from earlier this year—and thank god that particular trip into the heart of darkness is over—but this thing has largely been reborn I think with the onset of Record Club, which you can see is born out in the post increasing over time. So that means that whatever I think about whatever you've written, you've no doubt written about it and I've just missed it.
13: "The Past Is a Grotesque Animal" by Of Montreal
It's a shame, when you've shared yourself with others and they've missed it. The good news it, it's all in writing somewhere, and they can always go find it, you can always go point them to it.
12: "Your Deep Rest" by the Hotelier
I'm losing the thread a little bit here, which is wont to happen when I go long like this. Suffice to say, whatever my point was, I was right.
11: "Explain It to Me" by Liz Phair
Also, no need to treat this like more than it is. Like I said way up there, I'll be back on Friday. You've got my number. I've got several emails of 1975 to respond to. I'll get to it, in time. There's a jukebox project to jump into next year, something lower-key than all this.
10: "The Bleeding Heart Show" by the New Pornographers
All this was nice, though. I'm not close to Maeve or Allison. I see Sunny often enough, and I'll email Zach (sp?) once a year, but we're not really Getting Into The Shit when we chop it up. Sara's a complete nutbag, but it's nice to hear what a nutbag has to say from a distance.
9: "Jesus, Etc." by Wilco
This is a nice platform, is what I'm saying. This is a nice place you've built that we've decorated together. In a way, you're making good on that aborted tagline for this place, even if it's less about The Nights We Can't Remember With The Friends We Can't Forget and more about which joints are creaking or which reality shows are good.
8: "The Ballad of the Kingsmen" by Todd Snider
This is an A+ song for golfing. Real golfers know the only way to play the game is to either treat it like an outdoor bar with a Divorced Miami Uncle costume party attached to it, or to play it monastic silence in isolation from all others. I find this song works in either context.
7: "Day Tripper" by Otis Redding
Great voice on this guy, shame what happened to him.
6: "6th Avenue Heartache" by the Wallflowers
When I was in high school, I used to get a ride from a friend who lived on my block. He drove some red beater pickup truck with no working radio, so he'd throw a boombox in the back seat and play one of two tapes: The Block is Hot by Lil Wayne or, you know it, Bringing Down the Horse by the Wallflowers. I heard this song and "The Difference" so many times my junior and senior years. Two great albums that do not taste great together no matter how many times I hear them.
5: "The Battle of Hampton Roads" by Titus Andronicus
I will return next year for the fourth annual Titus Andronicus bracket. Hopefully there's a new album of songs to get beaten out by this tune.
4: "I'll Believe in Anything" by Wolf Parade
This is my favorite song ever. Number one song of my life. Here is the Science Club song where I jacked its chorus. Plagiarism is real and its name is Nate.
3: "Like a Rolling Stone" by Bob Dylan
I secretly think that Bob Dylan might suck, but I acknowledge this song for the sway it holds over Pat Stickles.
2: "B.O.B" by OutKast
Thanks again, Joe. Thanks again, everyone. This was fun. See you all at the reunion!
1: "Hey Joe" by the Jimi Hendrix Experience
Holy fuck, I numbed them all right. We're ending this year on a high note.
8 comments:
The king of blogging strikes again. What an achievement.
This pissed me off for a few reasons.
One, because Blogspot is terrible with formatting, and in order to get it from Gmail to the blog, I had to strip all of the formatting and start over, which means all the hyperlinks disappeared, and I just straight-up did not have the time or energy to add them all back in. I'll add them eventually, but it was not an 11-PM-with-a-stomach-bug task.
Two, because I read through it all and had so many responses to each little blurb and decision you made here, but had to remain silent like a good editor. Thought about adding editor's notes, decided against it. Thought about writing a whole new blog post in which I respond to each point, decided to put a pin in it (because, again: sick, tired).
Three, because Nate being sincere and wholesome knocks me out of my comfort zone so much that I get disoriented. Call me a piece of shit for sending you an email about the 1975 at three in the morning on Christmas Day! That would make me more comfortable I think!
I do want to respond to everything I can, however. I'll start with #15, which was a harsh truth that was actually really helpful to read last night, as we begin transition away from YSC. I don't know if I'd describe it as "needing more," but maybe in practice it does end up being that, I don't know. I think ultimately it boils down to "how do I bring my friends joy" and this being the only way I know how to do it, even though, ya know, results can vary, and outliers like YSC and its wild emotional successes can trick me into thinking that we can find this anywhere.
In any case, thanks for saying this. And I appreciate having you here, for obvious reasons.
#150 — I hope you know at this point that I wouldn't bullshit you on who I am attracted to and who I'm not, or who I'm into and who I'm not, or who I'd take the F in MFK and who I'd take the K. So when I say this, I am being completely honest, and you should know this.
I do not find Iggy Azalea attractive. I find Charli XCX very attractive, but let's not let my obsession with brat make anyone think that I'm obsessed with her sexually. I will say that about plenty of other female musicians, but I wouldn't say that about Charli. (He says after two days of not showering and not changing out of his pajamas and flabbiness hanging over said pajamas as he types on a blog, acknowledging that the "is she attractive" discussion trends precariously toward incel territory if not handled delicately.)
#144 — I feel like whenever I do a long dumb ranking like this, you come into the comments and pick out one specific choice that I made and say something hyperbolic like "when you said THIS movie is better than THAT movie I wanted to blow myself up with a m80." Putting "Sympathy is a knife" was your attempt at eliciting that reaction from me, I know.
Alright, more later, maybe. Or maybe I just keep returning to this space to nitpick and use as fodder for future blogging.
Hey, thanks for taking the time to do this, by the way. I had fun reading your list.
i don't think i ever wrote this much in college. no i did not graduate "in time."
Correct as always re: golfing and #8
Incredible showing from this hovvdy album this year, which, despite all my trying I still pronounce with two v's instead of a w
Post a Comment