Thursday, December 19, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 174: Joe

Prompt: "A song that you know for sure makes someone else think of you when they hear it"

Selected by Joe


"Ghosts"
Letter to You, 2020

Isn't it funny how it's so much easier to remember what people hate, instead of what they like? Try it right now. Imagine there is a song that you hear, and when you hear this song, you think of me, Joe K***. Which song is it? More than likely, you're thinking of a song by Queen or Simon & Garfunkel, right? I hate that shit, I've made that known, you know it because I've made it known, and now that's "part of me." It's tougher to break through the noise with opinions about music that you love. I know that Nate loves Titus Andronicus, but I'm not listening to Titus Andronicus and thinking about Nate, you know what I mean?

I guess maybe it has more to do with cold take / hot take than it does with good song / bad song, now that I am thinking about it some more. I sure do seem to be in the minority in terms of not liking Queen, which I guess is what makes it memorable. Likewise, maybe professing a love for a song that everyone mostly thinks is trash is a good way to attach your name to that song, while also remaining positive and optimistic.

I don't like the idea of being known as the guy who hates so-and-so. I know it's inevitable to a certain extent, for reasons explained above, but that doesn't make me comfortable with the idea. It's because "hate" is a wide-ranging emotion, and could manifest for many different reasons, and if you're known as the guy who "hates" Queen, then it's impossible to control other people's interpretation of that hate.

I'm thinking about a comment that Boober made at one point (blogspot makes it impossible to search comments, unfortunately) where he asked if I hate Queen in the same way that I hate... I forget the example he used, but it was someone I don't listen to anymore because they were a rapist or whatever. And I had to explain that they were complete opposites, that I feel nothing for [whoever] because I don't listen to their music at all, whereas when I listen to Queen, I hate it for music-related reasons only. The blog isn't always going to be here to clarify opinions like that.

Because I'm also thinking of another Queen-related incident, many years ago. I was in my parents' backyard with my dad, shooting the shit while doing yardwork or whatever, and Queen came on the radio, and I said I hated it, and he said that he did too. But then, ya know, I had to clarify, because he implied in not so many words that his feelings had more to do with his still-latent late-'00s homophobia, and my feelings were not like that at all. And it's fucking weird, to have to defend an artist whose music you hate, because there's already so much hate in the world, ya feel me? And I hate the music but I don't want anyone to think that I'm adding to the level of hate in other, personal ways. It's just the music. The music sucks. That's all.

Now, I've certainly been on the other side of that conversation. I have a friend with whom I was talking recently about what kind of music we each like and dislike. She mentioned all the bands I loved as a teenager, the classic rock icons of Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, that kinda stuff. But she also mentioned Billy Joel, so I used that as a good opportunity to not seem like too much of a classic rock fanboy and say something along the lines of: "I fucking HATE Billy Joel." Which I was hoping would come off as slightly funny, like if I went over the top, then I would make my true opinion known while also acknowledging that none of this is all that serious and it's all just for fun and so on and so on.

She got me back good, though. Told me that her dad used to love Billy Joel and that he loved Billy Joel so much that she, my friend, was named after Billy Joel's daughter. Okay, good, good. It's nice to actually hear a compelling reason to like this jabroni! No, I don't like basically any of the songs on The Stranger, and I'm not afraid to say it... but I also totally respect loving an artist because it reminds you of your deceased father for very tangible reasons! And I'm not so cold as to deny this artist another shot, in that light.

This is similar to how I currently feel about "September." Sorry, this is going to be a tangent (I would've written about this song already if it weren't for the No Repeats rule). Had you asked me six months ago what I thought about this Earth, Wind & Fire song, I would've said something along the lines of: "I don't like it, it's overplayed." And it really has been. It's gone from banger of a high school pep band song to total cliché. Had I been flipping through the radio and heard "September" on the oldies station, I wouldn't have lingered too long before turning the dial.

That was before we watched Robot Dreams. I won't give away too much here, since you don't really have an excuse not to watch it—it is a family film, so you'll like it and your kids will like it too, you don't have to wait till they go to bed like you would if you were trying to watch hour #5 of Lars von Trier's NYMPH()MANIAC—but it's a film with no dialogue. Basically, a lonely dog wants a friend, and orders a robot in the mail. That's all I'll say. But "September" becomes both an integral part of the soundtrack and a key part of the connection between dog and robot. We've seen the movie maybe three times so far, and I've been pretty close to crying at the end of each viewing, so beautiful and poignant and awe-inspiring is it. So that's how I feel when I listen to "September" now, because of the movie. (My final pitch is "Robot Dreams is Past Lives for kids," and I'll leave it at that.)

So why not Billy Joel? I mean, I'm not actively seeking that shit out. But if anyone wanted to send me some Joel songs to hear, I'd be open to it. And an opportunity presented itself shortly after the Billy Joel familial connection from my friend, since, a few days later, she reveals to me that she has similarly hateful opinions about... Bruce Springsteen. Which, ya know, is fucking wrong, but my dad doesn't like or dislike Bruce Springsteen any more than your average white boomer dad on the east coast, so I don't have any personal appeals to make beyond "I really like his music," which falls flat sometimes, because, well, you know, that's just like, uh, my opinion, man.

Okay, so the proposal: we each send each other five deep-cut non-hits from each respective artist's discography, songs that might appeal to a person who "hates" an artist mostly based on the hits that classic rock radio has beaten to death with a hammer. Because that's all this is, right? Very rarely are you saying that you "hate" an artist based on the entire spectrum of their work. You hate them based on what you've been exposed to, and sometimes that exposure can lead to unwanted damages.

Here are the Billy Joel songs I was given:
  1. "And So It Goes"
  2. "She's Always a Woman"
  3. "Goodnight Saigon"
  4. "Just the Way You Are"
  5. "The Downeaster 'Alexa'"
I'm disqualifying #2 and #4 right off the bat, because I already know them! I see the titles and can hear them playing in my head! I know it's hard to imagine that the fourth- and fifth-most popular songs on The Stranger would be known to some Billy Joel-hating asshole like me, but it's true! Classic rock radio has raped and pillaged this album pretty good! So yes, fuck those songs.

But I gave an honest shot to the other three. "And So It Goes" was bad in a way that I expect Billy Joel to be bad—slow, saccharine, maudlin, excruciatingly dull. But the other two were pretty good! I like a good epic song about a ship, and "The Downeaster 'Alexa'" gave that to me. "Goodnight Saigon" was big and corny in the very best way. It felt lame in the way a bright and loud theater production is lame, i.e. FUN.

Though it's only two songs, I reach the same conclusion that I did the other day with Adele—I probably can't say that I "hate" Billy Joel if I like at least two of his songs, right? And so let's be real about a couple other things. One, if I was given a list of 100 Billy Joel deep cuts, I'd probably find a healthy dozen that I didn't hate. Two, I haven't mentioned this yet, but "Piano Man" is good, poignant in the same way as "Goodnight Saigon" is, though narrower in scope.

Here were the five Bruce songs that I passed along (noted to all involved that they are listed in reverse-chronological order):
  1. "Ghosts"
  2. "Land of Hopes and Dreams"
  3. "Mary's Place"
  4. "The Ties That Bind"
  5. "4th of July, Asbury Park (Sandy)"
I can't and won't speak for anyone else on this blog, including my Boss-hating friend—especially since the blog is wide open for anyone to write on, and indeed I am going to try to get this friend to join Record Club in 2025, the negotiations have already begun—but I can report that she indicated that she listened to "Ghosts" and liked it.

And because of that, I don't think it would be unreasonable to say that, if she's ever lucky to hear "Ghosts"—possibly the final A+ Bruce Springsteen song he'll ever write—in the future, my friend will think of me. This is the tangible connection of joy that we build by sharing music. She hated Bruce Springsteen, but can she really say that anymore now that she knows that he has at least one great song? Will I ever hear "Goodnight Saigon" out in the wild, and if so, how could I possibly hear it and not think of my friend and the ballbusting we exchanged in the great Billy/Bruce War of 2024?

All this to say that, I don't know, you guys, I'm going to miss Yearlong Song Challenge when it's over. For many reasons, but one of the big ones is that there are so many songs now that I hear and I think about one of my friends on the blog. Every day, we are building bridges between the music and the people who like that music and the friends who love the people who like that music.

I'm typing this sentence as XPN plays "Not Strong Enough" as their 87th-best song of the 21st century; how could I hear this song and not think about Maeve, after the herculean effort she has put in over the past two years to stamp her name all over this artist? Before that was "Somewhere Only We Know" at #88; I don't think I'd ever heard that song before Allison chose it this year, and now I hear this fucking thing fucking everywhere. That kind of thing, over and over this year. I love it.

I know that this was a sprawling project, and that was by design. Not all the music connected. Not every word written was direct from the heart. Not every blog post was a revelation. But some of it was. And some of this music is going to stick around. 

One day, most of you are going to be dead, much like Bruce Springsteen's old bandmates, as described in the great late-period Springsteen song "Ghosts," and I'm going to look around and feel guilty about being the last one standing, and I'm going to listen to "Ghosts," and I'm going to think of you, because of this moment, these words I am writing now, in a blog post ostensibly about "Ghosts," in a yearlong blog project that we all took part in, so many years ago. I won't hate it. I won't remember the hate. I will remember, instead, the love we shared, and the music.

6 comments:

Nate said...

Most of you will be dead, but I will not be.

Mary's Place whips ass.

sunny said...

Try it right now. Imagine there is a song that you hear, and when you hear this song, you think of me, Joe K***. Which song is it?

Hmm probably "Walk the Dinosaur" from the CLASSIC 1993 Super Mario Bros. movie

Joe K said...

@Nate — One of us will die, and one of us will be forced to blog about the other person's death in the form of an album review for the 1975's Notes on a Conditional Form.

Joe K said...

@Sunny — Never seen it, is it any good?

Sara said...

Party in the USA, and if it has to be a Bruce song I think of you and Maeve when Rosalita plays

Maeve said...

@Nate- I agree. Imagine *not* turning the radio up everytime The Boss tells you to