Prompt: "A song that you believe sucks but that you fear will be reclaimed by future generations as a bellwether or high-water mark of the era"
Selected by Bridget
"Club classics"
Charli XCX
brat, 2024
Ok, per Joe on PoYB, brat was the second-best album this year. And while I do agree this album is BRAT as hell and fun, this song just doesn't hit for me. It somehow feels like it's an SNL skit? Or something someone wrote and dropped on their Tumblr in 2013. Is that a bad take? Probably! It just doesn't do it for me. And that's the fun part about music is that everyone is allowed to have different takes in regards to what everyone likes and doesn't. So here I am, not ashamed, to admit that this is the worst song on the record. I hope all the brats out there can forgive me.
3 comments:
Joe's official brat song rankings:
15. I might say something stupid
14. So I
13. Everything is romantic
12. Mean Girls
11. Rewind
10. Von dutch
9. Club classics
8. Talk talk
7. I Think About It All the Time
6. 365
5. B2B
4. 360
3. Apple
2. Girl, so confusing
1. Sympathy is a knife
My take on "Club classics" is that it's supposed to be slightly satirical. One of the themes that runs through brat is that this is Charli grappling with the fact that she'll never be an A-list pop star. Because she's too good for that, right? But this is her leaning into the simplicity of dumb A-list pop music. The hyperpop stylings of producer A.G. Cook underline the joke—it's her "attempt" and "being basic" but the weird-ass hyperpop fat bass bloops and bleeps betray the fact that she could never.
I like what you had to say here re: liking and not liking music, and I'm gonna touch on those thoughts in a blog post at some point.
Post a Comment