Monday, December 16, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 173: Joe

Prompt: "A song that has the same exact title as a song that was chosen already for Song Challenge, but is in fact a completely different song"

Selected by Joe

The same exact title as Jeanine's song from Day 4


"Shake It Off"
A Golden Era
Life: As Played by People, 2009

At this point in the Yearlong Song Challenge, I think we can all agree on one thing: FUCK TAYLOR SWIFT. Here to chat with me about how much Taylor Swift has a far inferior song also called "Shake It Off," we have Will S., the drummer of A Golden Era. I know I sometimes do fake transcripts on this blog, but this one is real. We talked on Google Chat. Will is very cool and was very gracious in this interview, and he would never say it, but we all know what the deal is here: Taylor Swift stole from A Golden Era, and now owes them a percentage of her $2b profits from that world tour she just ended. Thanks Will! Come back to the blog soon!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: Thanks for chatting with me about the songs called "Shake It Off." I wanted to go right to the source and briefly interview the drummer of A Golden Era about their own "Shake It Off." The premise is that I'm still blogging in the year 2024, and was assigned to choose a song for a Yearlong Song Challenge that has the same title as another song chosen previously. Taylor Swift's "Shake It Off" was chosen all the way back on January 6th, so I've been sitting on the idea of talking to you for a while now. Thanks for chatting.

WILL: I guess I should make it known that as far as A Golden Era was concerned, it really came down to the song writing prowess of the Beck brothers, Dustin and Dale. This song is a prime example of that. Dale came up with the music (including the main drum part in the verses, I just jazzed it up a bit) and Dustin wrote all the melodies and lyrics.
WILL: I actually just went back and listened to the original demo that was sent to me during the writing process. It's a bit slower tempo-wise, and the chorus was a little less choppy from a rhythm standpoint, but basically the same song that ended up getting recorded.

JOE: I mean, look, as a (former) drummer myself, I get it. That's the classic struggle. You are in a band, but don't necessarily lead the band. Pretty rare that the drummer gets the spotlight. But you would say you were a full-time member of A Golden Era, right? Like you're the band's drummer. You drummed really well for them, as far as I can hear.

WILL: lol. For sure, I recorded all the drum parts and had my hands in the recording process. Mostly because I was living at home and my parents had a nice wide open finished basement. haha

JOE: What did you (the band) think about when you heard about the Taylor Swift song "Shake It Off"? Was your first thought "goddamn it"?

WILL: Not at all. I can't speak for anyone else in the band, but I've enjoyed Taylor's stuff, really starting with the album Red.

JOE: There wasn't ANY sort of reaction like "well now we definitely don't have the most popular 'Shake It Off'"? or anything like that? Maybe I'm projecting. I would've been fucking pissed!

WILL: I don't think it even crossed our minds that they happened to be titled the same thing until later when she continued to rise to a stratospheric level
WILL: That's probably not a satisfying response for this, but I think we may have been on a "break" during that time period

JOE: Fair enough. I think that's noble. Also, I don't know the timeline of AGE, I guess that might be important. I have your most recent album, Paper View, as 2013, and TS's "Shake It Off" is out in 2014. Were you still going as a band when that song hit? Are you still on a "break"? Can you give me a brief timeline here, I guess?

WILL: Actually, now that I look back chronologically, "Shake It Off" blew up right around the time I was moving, so the band was kind of wrapping it up at that point.
WILL: Ten years gets fuzzy real quick. lol
WILL: I honestly think the funnier tie in is the fact that Taylor Swift put on the biggest tour ever called "The Eras Tour," and A Golden Era wasn't a part of that.
WILL: We would've been a nice lead into Paramore on the European leg of things.

JOE: Yeah, that fucker! None of her eras were as golden as yours!
JOE: Has there been any talk in the past ten years of getting the band back together, if not touring Europe, then, I dunno, playing in your parents' finished basement again or anything like that?

WILL: Not really. The distance thing is too much of a hassle. Everyone else has kids and real shit to do. I'm the one who gets to re-record old songs and reminisce about the good old days.
WILL: At this point we're basically at the point of just texting random inside joke things from fifteen years ago.

JOE: I like that, and I don't think there's anything wrong with that. I had a dopey garage cover band in high school—so not in the same league as AGE—but I still hang out with those idiots sometimes. Was just at a playground the other day with our kids. It's nice to have that in the memory bank, have those good times, and not necessarily depend on them, but just have them as a reason to smile or share a joke or whatever.
JOE: What do you mean rerecording songs?

WILL: So I semi-recently recorded an updated version of our song "Long Way Home" and put it out on YouTube and SoundCloud just for fun.
WILL: I had gotten away from recording for about a decade, and just got back into it about a year ago, and it's been an awesome escape for me.

JOE: That's awesome, dude. I know that feeling. Any chance you'll be rerecording "Shake It Off" anytime soon?

WILL: I have no idea how to play the main guitar lick in that song, so probably not. lol

JOE: Where would you say that "Shake It Off" ranked in terms of popular AGE songs?

WILL: According to Spotify, it is our most played song. Which isn't saying much. lol
WILL: Keeping in mind, this album came out in 2009, when selling CDs at shows was the primary way to get your music heard
WILL: That and MySpace anyway

JOE: I don't ask this question to be insulting, because I fucking love this song and I think both of your albums are awesome and should have more streams, but how much do you think that it attributed to the fact that it shares the same name as the Taylor Swift song? Spotify users searching "Shake It Off" and finding their way to A Golden Era somehow. (Or even "shake it off era" since she has that live era tour concert shit on there I assume?)

WILL: Certainly possible but a search for the song "Shake It Off" doesn't even put ours in the top 100 search results.
WILL: If you search "Shake It Off Era" ours is the second song result. But that calls into question society's search abilities. lol

JOE: Never question that, my man. Imagine the average Spotify user, and how dumb he is, and then know that half the Spotify user base is dumber than that.

WILL: haha. It's so true. Sad but true

JOE: Okay, so there are 34 different "Shake It Off"s on Wikipedia. Doesn't include AGE's. But why is yours the best?

WILL: Let me take a look at this list.

JOE: The only one that has its own Wikipedia page is Mariah Carey's.
JOE: It's December, we don't have to talk about her.

WILL: We won't.

JOE: Hahaha
JOE: I am confident that none of these would be better than A Golden Era's. But I wanna hear you make the case for it.

WILL: That list has Stiff Little Fingers which, while I'm not a fan of myself, I know they are big contributors to the late-'90s, early-2000s pop punk bands that influenced us, so it's tough for me to make an argument. But I shall...
WILL: I think "Shake It Off" by A Golden Era is probably the most pure version of "Shake It Off" in existence. There was no outside influence on the song. The four of us, wrote, recorded, mixed, and released it on our own. Kim Rosen from Knack Mastering mastered it, so we can't take credit for that bit.

JOE: I buy it. You guys made it for the love of the game. Taylor and her collaborators made hers to herald her transition from country to pop. There were capitalistic hands at play there.

WILL: Don't get it twisted, we would've very much liked it if we had the help of outside influences at times. lol
WILL: But because we didn't, we'll take that as honor instead of lack of interest.

JOE: For the record, my 6yo loves "Shake It Off" by Taylor Swift. She has us play it every time we're in the car. I played AGE's version right afterward the other day, and made a big deal about how it had the same name as her song, and my daughter was... mostly nonplussed.

WILL: That's very fair.

JOE: She's a philistine at her age. She'll get there.

WILL: Pop vocals are very pleasing to the ear.

JOE: Would the hypothetical "Shake It Off" by A Golden Era video feature Will S. crawling through an endless row of shaking asses?

WILL: At the time... no. Now... no
WILL: I think it would be funny if we did do a video of it but do it as a parody of that viral cop video where he's singing Taylor Swift as he's going about his day.
WILL: I'll work up a treatment for that

JOE: Please keep the blog readers informed of your progress.
JOE: I searched for videos of "Shake It Off" by A Golden Era and found a couple.
JOE: Both live versions, one of them from La Salle University!
JOE: A lot of the readers and writers on this blog are alumni, they'll appreciate that.
JOE: I can't remember the name of the room that you played in. I keep thinking "Dunleavy," but I know that's not it. Someone will chime in in the comments below this interview. Do you remember this night?

WILL: I remember that performance being rough cause there was a crap-ton of echo in that room, so it sounded like we were playing in a cave. Still... far from the worst we've done. haha

JOE: I can confirm the acoustics in there were fucking atrocious. Played in there a couple times with the La Salle Jazz Band. Terrible.
JOE: Was your future wife in the audience?

WILL: You know what... I don't know for sure, but I don't think so. lol

JOE: I sure she would have if she knew how cute the drummer was.
JOE: I apologize, I was not there either.
JOE: Probably getting loaded in the La Salle Apartments.

WILL: No hard feelings, haha

JOE: Blog contributor Kait L. was there, as she makes a cameo in that video by getting pushed by someone in front of the camera. I reached out to her, and she says she remembered it, and you guys played well.
JOE: Would you consider yourself a good drummer? I'm not asking if you were—I can hear you, I think you are a good drummer. I'm asking if you consider yourself a good drummer.

WILL: I've always thought I was fine. I could play in the pocket well once I got used to playing to a click.
WILL: I didn't do anything too adventurous because I felt the type of music we played just didn't call for it.
WILL: The few times I did experiment with more technical stuff, it always came across as busy.

JOE: Do you still play?

WILL: No... I haven't played drums in ten-ish years. I program all my drums for songs now. Cheaper, less space requirements, and has the flexibility of easily going back and changing things if need be.
WILL: I'd love to have the space for a drum kit, but it wasn't in the cards with our current house.

JOE: I feel that, man. Life gets in the way. I tried playing the drums a couple years ago in a friend's basement, and I was extremely rusty. But it never really leaves you, does it? You could go 40 years without playing a drum kit and still consider yourself a drummer.

WILL: Absolutely, I think I could probably get through a set with AGE if I had to. Certainly wouldn't be perfect but I have enough of the muscle memory to get by.

JOE: Do you miss playing in a band?

WILL: For sure. I think at this point, I would like to play guitar/bass or sing in a band if I were to do it again. I tried to coax AGE into letting me switch to bass when we were looking for a new bass player, but I guess drummers are harder to find, so I stayed behind the kit.

JOE: I'm listening to Paper View as we're talking, and it struck me that "Making Plans and Taking Risks" is a good song, thematically, for this type of discussion. "When we were young and free / misguided and lonely." I think there's good reason to remember the good times, because they were fun. I also think that we forget a lot of what made being young tough, as we age and life gets harder in some ways but a lot easier in others. I dunno.
JOE: But I also think that music transcends that sometimes. Like if you wanna play music, then you can play it as an adult. You don't have to be young and free like we were.

WILL: I'm generally a nostalgic person and I often times think about what things could have been different but with music, I can just go back and re-record songs or re-imagine songs and that's a way to blur the lines between the good old days and the older and, hopefully, improved you. Ya know?

JOE: I mean, this is literally what the villain of this interview, Taylor Swift, does with her music, right? Rerecording it? I know she's doing it for different reasons, but I gotta imagine nostalgia came into play when she was rerecording "Shake It Off" for 1989 (Taylor's Version).

WILL: Everything from the people you were around to the places you wrote and recorded for sure.
WILL: Simple things like remember a funny thing someone said while you were doing takes of this one part. Simple stuff like that.

JOE: Can you tell us one thing about your "Shake It Off" like that? What's something you remember that we would never know if you didn't tell us?

WILL: Two things. The first is that the entire album was recorded with the guitar mic facing the wrong way. It was a new mic that we had gotten specifically for recording the guitars on the album, and we were none too savvy and had it positioned facing away from the amps the entire time, so the guitars are very uniquely captured for the song (and the album).
WILL: Second, we used two different programs for pitch-correcting vocals on the album, and "Shake It Off" utilized the more in-depth program, Melodyne, which was a lot more natural sounding than Antares AutoTune. It also allowed us to manipulate the melodies a little bit, which we did in the bridge by changing a few notes just to give it a little bit of flair.

JOE: Love it. I will be honest, I don't know what a lot of that means, but I am definitely all in on people who know something talking about that thing that they know so well. So this is cool to know, and I know those reading this who have professional recorded music before will get a lot out of that.

WILL: I'm a nerdy dude when it comes to that stuff, even if I've only ever dabbled with most of it.

JOE: What would you say that the song "Shake It Off" by A Golden Era is trying to say? What is its message, if there is one?

WILL: I think it's just a message of: people might put you down, but your own perseverance can get you through it and help you "shake it off."

JOE: Like I said, I haven't listened to the other "Shake It Off"s besides these two, but I wonder if having a title like "Shake It Off" means that the message has to be that.

WILL: Yeah, I feel like you're pretty locked in with the "Shake It Off" branding. haha

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Thanks again, Will! Please join us tomorrow for Part 2 of the interview, where we talk about A Golden Era's songs "The Tortured Poets Department" and "My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys."

3 comments:

Joe K said...

Proud of me for not choosing "Shake It Off" and interviewing the drummer of Wilco or "Shake It Off" and interviewing the drummer of Spoon or "Shake It Off" and interviewing the drummer of Mariah Carey or "Shake It Off" and interviewing the drummer of DJ Jazzy Jeff.

sunny said...

An un-expected and satisfying bit of closure in this post and exercise.

Appreciate all the bait you laid for Will to come down on Taylor that never bit. Always gotta lay down the crumbs.

Joe K said...

The humility was appreciated, but I don't think anyone will be surprised when I get Will back on the blog at some point and force him to say something negative about Taylor Swift.