Thursday, December 12, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 171: Brianna

Prompt: "A song that you believe sucks but that you fear will be reclaimed by future generations as a bellwether or high-water mark of the era"

Selected by Brianna


"BIRDS OF A FEATHER"
Billie Eilish
HIT ME HARD AND SOFT, 2024

Collective music culture these days is weird. Not the music itself (I wish that was weirder, to be honest), but, like, how the modern music community operates. 

There was a time when the radio ruled all. What was played was what you got, and if you liked it, you had to go out and invest in it. In this way, popular artists were more communal. Think about it: music is more widely accessible now than ever before in history, but "today's hit music" isn't served to you on a ready to go platter. You kind of have to seek it out. The consequence of this is a kind of musical echo chamber. Unless you have friends sharing new artists or trust a streaming services recommendation (or are a regular on PoYB music themed challenges and clubs), you're going to go ahead and keep listening to the stuff you know you liked. 

This is a long prelude to my confession that the recent wave of Pop Girlies taking over the world doesn't really resonate with me. After a certain point of my life, pop in general kind of disappeared from my listening habits, so maybe that's shaped my opinion in some ways? I don't know, it's all just a bit boring to me. Even after listening to this Billie song a few times on my drive home, I couldn't sit here and honestly replay any part of the song in my head. Nothing stuck out to me as interesting or exciting. 

When it comes to something as subjective as music tastes, I loathe to yuck another person's yums. Let's just chalk it up to different musical paths in the great big atlas of music these days, okay?

2 comments:

Joe K said...

There are four songs chosen today that are actually really good, and this is one of them. And they are all bunched up here at the beginning.

I will say that this newest Billie album is the first one that I connected with on any significant level, and even then, it's just VERY GOOD instead of GREAT.

My theory for you specifically, sis, is that you can't get into the rising tide of young female pop stars because the tickets are too expensive to see them in concert!

Nate said...

It's funny you're talking about this: I was driving my kids to school this morning, flipping channels to avoid commercials, and I landed on the alt-rock station playing "Everlong." My genuine reaction was, "oh, sweet, 'Everlong!'" I like the Foo Fighters just fine but it would never occur to me to listen to them with all of recorded music available to me at the drop of a hat. But finding them in real life, on accident, felt different, and made the song feel different.